Alle verhalen

Vijftien jaar vrouw willen zijn — tot een vriendin er een einde aan maakte

Man · Gedesisteerd519
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde of gedesisteerde man die ongeveer 15 jaar vrouw wilde zijn totdat een baan, hobby's en een vriendin die gedachten deden verdwijnen. Ik beschrijf in deze posts niet dat ik zelf hormonen of operaties onderging, maar ik ben scherp kritisch over medische transitie, die ik zie als een sektarische, grotendeels onomkeerbare reactie op trauma, fetisj, geïnternaliseerde homofobie en door internet aangewakkerde verwarring, en niet als een echte identiteit. Ik heb jongeren afgeraden permanente veranderingen door te voeren, onderzoek dat puberteitsremmers in twijfel trekt geprezen en betoogd dat therapie (geen affirmatie) dysforie zou moeten behandelen zoals andere psychische aandoeningen. Politiek ben ik opgeschoven richting figuren als James Lindsay en Carl Benjamin. Ik identificeer me momenteel als man en hetero, en ben actief in detransgemeenschappen waar ik advies geef.

Volledig verhaal

I am a man who spent roughly 15 years wanting to be female before I got a job, a life goal, and a girlfriend. I've said openly that I'm happy there wasn't a "trans pipeline" available when I was younger, and that the desire to transition disappeared for me once even one of a job, a hobby, or real friends was in place. I've described myself as having had social issues and OCD when I was younger, and said that when I changed my social setting, the OCD went away almost immediately. I still talk to myself when very stressed or after a few days without seeing people, but said it's rare now — I only experienced it again during a stressful time at work after three years of isolation during COVID. I've written that I "kinda gaslighted myself into being bi" under peer pressure before actually trying and realizing I'm "pretty much 99% straight." I've referenced OkCupid statistics about bisexual identification to argue that most people claiming bisexuality don't behave that way. I don't describe undergoing hormones or surgeries myself in this transcript. I do discuss medical transition extensively in the abstract: I've argued that most trans treatment is sterilizing, that it "takes away future choices to give a travesty of gender change in exchange," and I've commented on someone's return of menstruation after detransition, noting they "might be sterile" but hoping they aren't because "it's nice to be able to have kids." I've also commented on bottom growth in a detransitioned woman's account, arguing people should disclose unusual genitalia before hookups. I hold strongly critical views of transition, particularly for young people. I've compared trans ideology to a cult and a religion, argued that increasing rates of trans identification among friend groups in schools reflects propaganda and grooming, and linked the trend to feminism, internalized homophobia, trauma, fetish, and internet culture. I've cited the Heritage Foundation's puberty blocker study approvingly, argued that a Karolinska correction showed there's no support that transition improves mental wellbeing, and criticized methodological problems in reviews like Rew et al. (2021) and the 73% puberty-blocker figure from James et al. (2016). I've said I don't "really believe in the trans concept more than as a response to trauma, a fetish, or a cultural phenomena, often with some internalised homophobia thrown in." I've advised younger people not to make permanent changes, telling one person "you seem like me when I was young" and warning that at that stage they'll "find ways to keep feeling unhappy" and "even do things you KNOW you will regret." I've recommended therapy to treat dysphoria symptoms the way one would treat anorexia, and criticized laws labeling non-affirming therapy as conversion therapy. Politically I've moved rightward, expressing admiration for James Lindsay and Carl Benjamin and arguing the left needs to manufacture suffering to justify itself. I've also said most conservatives don't mind gay people who mind their own business. I don't describe a formal detransition process, surgeries, or hormone use in my own case in this transcript, so those details remain unclear from what I've written.