Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben nooit getransitioneerd — ik ben een man die op r/detrans post als bondgenoot en als ouder van een 11-jarige biseksuele dochter, en ik bereid mezelf voor op wat er ook komt. Ik ben opgevoed door een gewelddadige, alcoholistische vader, werd op mijn 15e seksueel misbruikt door een 19-jarige man en als kind betast, en eind jaren 80 dacht ik kort dat vrouw worden me een beter leven zou geven. Ik ben kritisch over snelle medische trajecten, sceptisch over therapeuten en autoriteiten, en dring er bij mensen op aan niets blijvends te doen voordat ze mentaal stabiel zijn. Ik heb onorthodoxe opvattingen dat seksualiteit vloeiend en gekozen is in plaats van aangeboren, en ik maak me vooral zorgen over jongens zonder mannelijke rolmodellen. Ik identificeer me momenteel als man en ben niet gedetransitioneerd, omdat ik nooit getransitioneerd ben.
Volledig verhaal
I have never been trans myself, and I want to be clear about that up front — I'm a man who posts in this community as an ally and observer, and I've said plainly, "I've never been trans so I don't know exactly what you're going through." What I do have is my own history that made me understand, at least partly, why someone might think becoming a girl or woman would fix their life.
I was raised by an abusive alcoholic father, and I was sexually abused at 15 by a 19-year-old man. I was also sexually molested as a child. In the late 1980s, when I was growing up, I thought at one point that being a girl/woman would make my life easier than it was — I imagined it as a path to a better family and social life. Things were different then; I couldn't just go start HRT. I was, in my own words, "a man in a traumatic situation." I've told people here that maybe that's what's going on for them too, maybe it isn't.
I've never socially or medically transitioned, so there is no transition timeline for me: no coming out, no hormones, no surgeries, no blockers, no detransition date. My identity is and has always been male — I've written "half of us on the planet are men, myself included." I consider myself a sensitive, sometimes "feminine-minded" man who doesn't fit the brutish male archetype, and I've tried to encourage others, especially young men, to see that they don't have to fit a rigid box either. I've said, "Just cause I can't change the oil in my car doesn't mean I'm not a man."
I came to r/detrans partly as a parent: I've written that I'm "here as a parent with an 11 year old bisexual daughter preparing myself for anything." That parental stake shapes how I read the stories here. I'm wary of therapists and authority figures — I've said we "must remain skeptical of so-called 'authority figures'" and I've asked posters whether their parents were liberals who bought into whatever a therapist said without question. I'm critical of how quickly some places move toward medical intervention; about one Canadian case I wrote that "8 months seems way too inadequate of a time to come to a conclusion that disruptive."
On bodies and surgery, I've urged caution: "Please don't do anything permanent until you stabilize mentally," comparing a rush toward top surgery to an addict switching drugs — "You're not solving your mental problems by self-harm or surgeries; you're just avoiding them." I've drawn on my own abuse history to say it's "really hard to love, never mind even LIKE your body after something like that," while assuring people "It will get better."
I hold fairly heterodox views about sexuality. I've argued that sexuality is fluid, that "born gay" is pseudoscience, and that homosexuality is a choice rather than something fixed at conception — a position that got me downvoted. I've said we "fought to be accepted no matter who we wanted to be with" in the 90s, "not made-up science." On dating, I've said I'd date "the right guy with a vagina if she knew she was still a female and just preferred to present as a man."
I'm critical of how gender politics has played out, especially for boys: I've worried about who teaches boys to be men, pointed at schools with mostly female teachers, and argued fathers need to be reinserted into families. I've pushed back on claims that "gender isn't real," ending a conversation there. I've recommended r/LGBdroptheT to people whose stories fit the "just gay, convinced they're trans" pattern.
I try to be encouraging about self-acceptance. When someone wrote "I killed the girl she loved," I replied, "You're still in there. Fighting, but alive." When someone praised a poster's appearance as the woman they were born as, I agreed: "Don't let anyone ever take that away from you again. Even yourself." I've complimented people's appearance in transition timelines too — I'm not here to be cruel, just honest about my views.
I don't experience regret about transition because I never transitioned, but I do carry the weight of my abuse and my difficult upbringing. I've written that after childhood molestation it's hard to like your body, and I believe that gets better with time. My mental health struggles stem from my father's alcoholism and abuse and my sexual abuse at 15 and as a child; I haven't described specific diagnoses. I'm not suicidal and haven't described self-harm.
Overall I see myself as a supportive but critical voice here: I don't oppose transition for everyone in absolute terms, but I'm skeptical of medical authority, quick diagnoses, and the idea that stereotypes define sex. I advocate for people finding out what being a man or woman means to them on their own terms rather than changing bodies to fit a box.