Alle verhalen

TERF genoemd omdat ze non-binair verliet, en haar voornaamwoorden behouden

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd315
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die zich jarenlang als non-binair identificeerde maar nooit medisch is getransitioneerd. Ik verliet de NB-gemeenschap nadat ik TERF werd genoemd en geïsoleerd raakte, en ik accepteer nu mijn geboortesekse zonder genderlabel nodig te hebben, al heb ik nog een hekel aan mijn vulva en worstel ik met een lichaamsbeeld dat wortelt in vroege blootstelling aan porno. Ik ben biseksueel, heb een relatie met een vrouwelijke biseksuele man en veranderde mijn tweede naam in een unisekse naam (waar ik geen spijt van heb), maar behield mijn oorspronkelijke voornaamwoorden. Ik blijf kritisch over de huidige transideologie, vooral over hoe makkelijk radeloze jonge vrouwen richting NB- of FTM-identificatie gaan, en ik adviseer te wachten tot de volwassenheid voor medische transitie. Ik heb geen medische ingrepen gehad en heb nog wat onzekerheid over mijn lichaam.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and have always known I was biologically female. I never felt quite "right" in my body, and about five years before 2020 (so roughly 2015) I thought I had figured myself out when I found the non-binary/genderqueer community. At that time the NB community was small and hard to find, so I made a Facebook group for NB people that blew up to thousands of members. As the current ideology became more popular, I felt I could no longer be open and free in my own group. I'd always known I was biologically female, and when I heard "sex doesn't equal gender" I genuinely believed that and refused to see sex-based conversations as an attack on gender. Those views got me labeled a TERF and I was completely isolated by the community I'd felt so at home in, but I also don't feel right in radfem spaces — my views fall in between. Both sides tell me I'm brainwashed if I dare to be completely open, and after years of this I'm sick of feeling so isolated. I never went through any medical transition, which initially kept me away from detrans spaces, but I was told there are detransitioners who haven't medically transitioned. I've been watching detrans YouTube videos and, for the first time in a long time, felt I could relate and discuss my feelings about identity. I came out as bisexual pretty early in life, but I never got to experience the old-school LGBT community as an adult. It feels strange to know I'm LGBT but feel unwelcome in the community — it's almost as if sexuality doesn't matter to the movement anymore. I have a male partner who is bisexual and pretty feminine; early in our relationship he experimented with cross-dressing, and now he openly wears skirts and has very long hair. On my body: I've learned to love most of myself, but I hate my vulva and feel angry toward that part of my body, which is exhausting. I don't even mind being a woman, so I couldn't understand why I hated my vulva. I've always hated my genitals, and there was a point where I desperately wanted a male body, with the genitals bothering me most. I started feeling the need to be male while figuring out my sexual preferences — I always thought I liked gay men and that it was "gross and creepy and wrong" because I was a woman, and that they'd never want me. After a lot of deep thought I figured I'm just a woman who really likes feminine men. I still have massive insecurities about my genitals but the confusion is gone. I believe the sexualization is what bothers me: I didn't really have these problems until I was introduced to porn and everyone I knew was watching it, and it messed up my self-image because of my age at the time. I hate feeling that any one part of my body is exclusively needed for sexual purposes; I'm fairly sex-positive but want it on my own terms. In my teens I had awful self-esteem issues from the pressure to measure up to society's idea of "womanhood," and even now I sometimes struggle with it, though I'm far more at peace with my sex/body than I used to be. I questioned myself a lot because I don't "feel" like a woman, and it was freeing to realize I don't have to feel any particular way as a woman. I identified as NB partly because I don't "feel" a gender the way others insist they do. It has taken a lot to realize I can accept my birth sex without finding an airtight gender label — I can just be me. I really don't think of myself as cis and dislike it when people imply I am; I've never felt like a girl or woman, but not like any other gender either. I've had much more peace since I stopped worrying about having a gender, though there are still things I dislike about my body. I don't regret changing my middle name to a more unisex one — I did that while I still identified as NB, and I changed it around the time I got married. I still use my original pronouns because changing them was just more work than it was worth. I think the NB label was extra and unnecessary for me and set me back, making me question myself more. I believe dysphoria would be the defining factor for trans identification, and I think there's a massive difference between transsexuals who get full treatment and surgery versus an enby who just socially transitions, though you get backlash for acknowledging differences. I'm critical of how easily AFAB people can slide into FtM or NB identities as a quick way to feel accepted amid body and identity issues, and I note that gender-nonconforming women get the least support compared to openly feminine men. I also think sexism can no longer be discussed in depth without being labeled transphobic or a TERF, and that transphobia and sexism are separate struggles. I advise teenagers to wait until adulthood before seeking any medical transition, since social transition is fully reversible. I still sometimes question myself, but I've accepted my birth sex and stopped needing a label.