Alle verhalen

Criticus van transitie die zelf nooit transitioneerde

Man · Gedesisteerd206
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een man van 40 die sinds 2019 kritisch heeft gepost over transitie en genderideologie in deze gemeenschap. Ik beschrijf een levenslange onzekerheid over mijn lichaam, een gevoel van verlies over ouder worden, en de overtuiging dat het veranderen van oppervlakkige kenmerken innerlijke ongelukkigheid niet kan oplossen. Ik zie het huidige bevestigingsmodel als sociale besmetting, versterkt door media, financiële prikkels, geestesziekte en fetisj, en ik ben vooral kritisch over medische transitie bij minderjarigen. Ik ben ondersteunend en geruststellend geweest voor individuele detransitioners en twijfelaars hier. In dit transcript beschrijf ik niet dat ik zelf een transitie heb ondergaan.

Volledig verhaal

I have been posting in this community since mid-2019, and what I have written there reflects where my thinking is now, though the transcript is mostly my comments to other people rather than a full account of my own history. I am 40 years old as of June 2019. I was born male. I have written about my own life only in fragments: I say that I have felt insecure about my body "my entire life" and that this insecurity is "part of the human condition." I also write that I "never looked the way I wanted to when I did look objectively good," and that now "all I feel is loss." I describe myself as "decaying before my very eyes" and say I don't feel good about how I look anymore. I have referred to having been a young man who was "pleasurable to be sexually attractive and successful with a fair number of women," but also found that "ultimately also quite empty" — I drew a distinction between pleasure and satisfaction there. I do not describe any transition, hormones, or surgeries of my own in this transcript, so I cannot date those; what I do describe is a long-standing dissatisfaction with my body and appearance, and a belief that changing superficial features does not fix inner unhappiness. I suggested to another person that they look into Buddhism, and elsewhere I wrote that "the Buddhists might say that attempting to change the immutable and striving for that which is actually unobtainable forever is a recipe for life long agony." When someone pushed back on that suggestion, I apologized but also told them bluntly that they didn't "even know what a man is" and that putting on a "mansuit" wouldn't fix their soul. My views on transition, especially for young people, are strongly critical. I attribute the rise in transition to "equal parts social contagion, media celebration, financial and social benefits, and underlying mental illness combined with an obsessive fetish." I argue that humans don't finish cognitive development until 25 and that it is wrong for media and the medical community to encourage 13-year-olds to make irreversible decisions. I compared this to a doctor affirming a 75-pound bulimic 13-year-old girl's belief that she is fat and performing lap-band surgery. I said I "can't imagine a scenario where this societal change has been a net positive" and that more people are unhappy now than would have been otherwise, pointing to people who might otherwise have lived as "butch lesbian or tomboy female or hetero man who likes to crossdress or effeminate gay man" but instead get "massive disfiguring surgery and hormone regimes and regrets it." I also raised the burden this creates on females. On medical liability, I discussed whether a doctor who transitioned a 14-year-old could be sued, explaining the standard-of-care threshold and suggesting a med-mal lawyer, while noting that if the local standard of care was met, there might be no liability even if the treatments are dangerous. I called it "fairly totalitarian to substitute ideology for medicine and science and force everyone to participate in the ideological farce at the threat of their livelihood or criminal sanction." I have been supportive toward individuals in the community who are detransitioning or questioning. I told one young person that they were dealt bad circumstances when the media and politicians celebrated this while they were vulnerable, that "it could happen to anyone and it was not your fault," that they were "simply following the advice given by those in authority," and that "you didn't fuck up, they failed you." I reassured another that their family just wanted them to be happy and wouldn't want them to live uncomfortably because of money spent, and I linked the sunk-cost fallacy to someone worried about disappointing their family. I told someone who was young that they would find people who love them, that their voice could maybe be changed back, and that there are beautiful women with no breast tissue and deep voices. I also pointed out to someone that their reasoning — liking masculine things so they must be a man — was the very theory behind why they had transitioned. I told one person, "I remember you. I like you and I hope you don't leave." I have also commented on what I see as contradictions in progressive gender ideology — that gender stereotypes are condemned when imposed on people of their own sex but celebrated when used to justify transition — and on articles that pressure lesbians to be open to trans partners, which I compared to conversion therapy aimed at lesbians. I do not describe current mental health diagnoses, medications, relationships, or family situation in this transcript. My regret, as expressed, is about loss and aging rather than a specific medical intervention, and I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm.