Alle verhalen

Zonder bh in een land waar transitie niet beschikbaar was

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd216
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die nooit hormonen nam of een operatie had, deels omdat transitie in mijn land niet beschikbaar was. Als tiener haatte ik mijn zich ontwikkelende vrouwelijke lichaam, ontwikkelde ik een eetstoornis, beschadigde ik mezelf, bond ik mijn borsten en concludeerde ik dat ik een jongen was of iets anders dan een vrouw. Door radicale zelfacceptatie, stoïcisme, zonder bh lopen en volledige spiegels vermijden ben ik vrede gaan sluiten met mijn lichaam, en nu identificeer ik me als gender-non-conforme, masculiene vrouw in een relatie met een man. Ik voel me nog ongemakkelijk bij sommige aspecten van mijn sekse maar heb er vrede mee gesloten, en ik ben kritisch op hoe makkelijk therapie mensen richting transitie kan duwen.

Volledig verhaal

I never got as far as taking hormones or even seeking therapy — partly because it didn't exist in my country — but I relate deeply to stories of regret. I always felt incredibly inadequate as a woman. The 'growing pains' of puberty were traumatic at best; I was terrified of becoming a woman and of my developing body. I struggled with an eating disorder and did not feel like I was in control of my body or my mind. I watched the boys with envy and dreamed of being one of them so I could stop hating myself and being afraid. My parents told me I was 'too sensitive.' I felt I wasn't beautiful enough, wasn't feminine enough, couldn't be a woman — but I knew in my heart of hearts I couldn't be a man either, so I wanted badly not to be anything at all, not to be part of the whole charade. At 17 I hated my body so much I would become sick at my reflection sometimes. I would cry and hit the mirror in anguish, spend hours looking at it and feeling bad, pick at spots, pinch myself, punch my stomach — just hateful things. I developed an eating disorder, self-harmed, and bound my breasts. Binding my chest and being overly skinny protected me from sexual objectification, but it wasn't the solution; it just brought more pain. Changing into a woman's body was what started my eating disorder, and on top of that I obsessively found flaws because I was so focused on its appearance. I hated girl stuff and eventually came to the conclusion I was a boy or, if not a boy, something other than what I was told I was. I only learned in my 20s that nothing was wrong with my body and mind for being this way. I now understand it as internalised misogyny, which I couldn't have known back then. My mother went through breast cancer and lost one of her breasts, which upset me because it made me think this could happen to me. I thought about cutting my breasts off, but I knew I would just focus on where they used to be and hate the scars — it wouldn't make me a man, and it wasn't comforting. What moved me toward acceptance was radical self-acceptance. I stopped wearing a bra and ignored my breasts, wearing clothes that fit over them without emphasizing them and rarely touching them until I got used to them being there. It took months before I could look at them in the mirror, but then I did — I stared at their shape, felt their weight, and told myself they were just flesh. I read about stoicism during this period: nothing is good or bad, only our judgement makes it so. My femaleness isn't bad; it just is. I can never have a different body, and if I had surgeries I would be weaker and wounded, with scars and body parts that wouldn't make sense to me. I don't like being female, but I am, and there is nothing wrong with it. I also stopped owning large mirrors — after I recently moved and had none where I could see my whole body, my self-confidence shot up enormously, maybe 100x better, because the problem for me was thinking about it too much. I am gender non-conforming and I reject society's instructions about what I'm supposed to do with my body and appearance. I get strange looks and don't care anymore. I do what makes me feel strong, out of spite. I still struggle — sitting with terrible cramps while my male partner laughs at memes, mad that he can't understand how my body makes me feel, frustrated that I can lose muscle tone in weeks. But I'm dealing with it. I'm a masculine woman with a very small chest in a committed relationship with a man; some people think I'm a butch lesbian or that I 'should be' trans, but I disagree. I'm still a tomboy. I'm older now and I'm okay with my body — I don't love it, love it, but it does its job, and I've learned to make it my own. I don't have advice for people with very different experiences, but I try to be supportive. I'm critical of how easily therapy pushed one person toward transition, arguing that if the therapist had gone slower she would have seen the person wasn't actually trans — and questioning what makes someone a 'real' trans person at all. I also question what a 3-4 year old child could know about what it means to be a girl or boy, arguing that children learn gender from observing the outside world, cartoons, and ads, and that the issue is with the outside message. I believe women are socialised since childhood to talk about feelings while men are taught to repress them, and that femininity isn't real — 'an idea sold to us so we would participate in capitalism.'