Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die opgroeide in Zuidoost-Azië, tijdens de middelbare school rigide Amerikaanse genderrollen meemaakte waardoor ik dysforisch en misplaatst voelde, en nu op mijn 22e in Japan woon en een carrière in non-profit/onderzoek nastreef. Ik worstelde met lichaamsbeeldnood en vond verlichting in een mix van DGT, CGT en EMDR-therapie na veel pogingen om de juiste match te vinden. Ik geloof dat strikte genderrollen en algoritmen van sociale media vrouwen van vrouwelijkheid wegduwen, en ik ben kritisch over de financiële prikkels van de transitie-industrie en overhaaste medische transitie. Ik pleit voor zelfacceptatie als vrouw, ongeacht presentatie, voor innerlijk-kindwerk en mededogen met je jongere zelf, en voor striktere eerlijkheid van medische zorgverleners. Ik blijf actief anderen te steunen in de detrans-gemeenschap.
Volledig verhaal
I grew up in Southeast Asia, in a culture where gender roles felt far more flexible than what I later encountered in the United States. Back home, soft-spoken men were simply men — our president is thin and soft-spoken, what Americans might call effeminate, and nobody questioned his manhood. Women in my country drove trucks, worked as electricians, taxi drivers, and sailors, some while wearing hijab, and those jobs didn't diminish their womanhood. When I moved to the US to study and live, I was struck by how rigid binary gender roles were there: women had to be skinny and doll-like, men gym-fit and dominant. Living in the US actually made me feel dysphoric. I didn't even know there were such things as 'masc' and 'fem' features before — to me they were just features. I lived there during high school, which exacerbated and magnified a feeling of being an 'out-group.' I'm skinny but felt I had to be skinnier (I'm built bigger because I've swum since I was little), and I felt that if I wasn't like an Instagram model I wouldn't be liked. I came to understand why men and women who don't fit narrow ideals feel they need to transition rather than accept themselves as they are — including me: there are women and girls bombarded by very strict gender roles who become so uncomfortable with womanhood they'd rather be male instead.
I was never formally diagnosed with anything in this transcript, but I struggled with body-image distress — loving my looks at times and loathing it at others — and sought therapy repeatedly. It took me three times to find the right therapist and another dozen or so attempts to find the right therapeutic approaches. I wasn't aware of DBT until my last therapy. Ultimately a mix of DBT with CBT helped me the most; I also did EMDR. DBT helped me get to a point where I felt empowered enough to properly learn and apply CBT. I've recommended trauma-informed therapists and DBT to others in similar situations.
I never used TikTok; my social media exposure was mostly Instagram. I've become critical of how algorithms push content — including content users explicitly asked not to see — and I think social media preys on the young, vulnerable, and impressionable. I believe it's time to stop blaming young users 100% for what they're exposed to, while also recognizing that algorithms don't depend on you alone. I've noted concerns about children as young as 8 being exposed to beauty standards, 11-year-olds praised by adults for makeup tutorials, and 9-year-olds addicted to porn.
I'm now 22 (as of 2022) and living in Japan. I'm somewhat closed off; I've only had 5 male friends in my whole 22 years, and the rest are all women. The only way I stay generally sane is to be surrounded by people who are kind to me and generally progressive. I've pursued academic and nonprofit work — Model UN, UN projects — where I felt seen, valued, and heard, and I'm pursuing a nonprofit and research career because academia feels like the safest place. I've volunteered and worked with women from other parts of the world, which opened my eyes to expansive and diverse womanhood and helped combat internalized misogyny.
On transition and detransition, I hold nuanced views. I believe female is a material/physical reality, and that there's no right way to be a woman — women can be confident, loud, hairy, aggressive. I've encouraged others to look at their younger selves compassionately and do inner child work to soothe, love, and forgive, since younger them made the best decision they could at the time. I'm skeptical of claims that dysphoria can never be fixed by therapy, arguing there's real money to be made from gender transition and that the industry wants you to take that path and influences your decision early. I've also pointed to the pressure parents and peers feel to affirm transition, citing pushback from communities, doctors, and social services when concerns are raised, and stories of people ostracized for questioning a transitioning friend. My most critical stance is that people confuse sex and gender under a misogynistic lens, and that the most important thing is not to rush medical transition and to make doctors and nurses more honest and strict about agreeing to it. I've offered support to others in the detrans community, telling them they are not broken, scarred, sinful, wrong, or tainted.