Alle verhalen

Een werkende penis willen, en weten dat ze die nooit kon krijgen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd584
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde persoon die zich als vrouw identificeert en nooit medisch is getransitioneerd, ik nam geen testosteron, en ik omschrijf mezelf nu gewoon als “een buitenbeentje met problemen, rondlopend in een biologisch vrouwelijk lichaam”, niet trans, cis of non-binair. Ik koos ervoor niet te transitioneren omdat ik een werkende penis wilde en wist dat ik die nooit zou kunnen hebben, en ik zat in therapie voordat ik HRT overwoog, maar volgde het advies van mijn psycholoog om te vertragen niet op. Mijn seksualiteit is biseksueel met een sterke aantrekking tot mannen, wat ik toeschrijf aan het feit dat mijn moeder een jongen wilde en dat mijn eerste seksuele relatie met een bi-man was. Ik ben een consequent criticus van de transgenderbeweging omdat ze genderrollen rigide codificeert in plaats van mensen ervan te bevrijden, en ik heb me verzet tegen retoriek die mensen onder druk zet hun aantrekking te veranderen. Ik heb een bekkenbodemprobleem gehad (behandeld met fysiotherapie, niet gerelateerd aan hormonen) en blijf kritisch over overhaaste medische beslissingen.

Volledig verhaal

I have never identified as trans, cis, or non-binary — I've described myself simply as "a misfit with issues, walking around in a biologically female body," and I've stated plainly that I am "unquestionably female." I never took testosterone or went through with a medical transition, and the reason I give is specific: "I wanted a functioning penis and knew I could never have one, that's why I *didn't* transition." I did, however, go to therapy before HRT was on the table for me, and I've said I didn't take my psychologist's advice to take things slow and be comfortable in uncertainty. I now think that advice was right — that you truly don't know how things will turn out or how you'll feel, and that the better stance is to be curious about why you feel the way you do rather than spiraling because you don't have every answer. My sexuality has been a central part of how I understand myself. My boyfriend described me as "a gay-leaning bisexual man in a woman's body," and I said he's not wrong: men having sex with each other turns me on, and I don't fully know why. I've said that if I had been male, or if I had gone through with transition, my sexuality would have been exactly the same — sometimes attracted to women, and "full of hot hard lust for men." I don't watch much porn, and I've been this way since before porn was easily accessible online. I attribute it to a combination of my mother having wanted a boy and my first sexual relationship being with a bi guy. I was exposed to sex younger than I probably should have been, though not in the extreme ways I've seen described elsewhere. I've been critical of the contemporary transgender movement for years, and it's the theme I return to most often. I've said repeatedly that I thought the trans thing was supposed to be about breaking free of rigid gender roles, but that it's actually codifying and reinforcing them more than ever — I've called this "the biggest heartbreaker" about the movement's rise, and said it reinforces gender stereotypes "with an oppressive rigidity that hasn't been seen since the 50s." I've also pushed back on the idea that attraction should be renegotiated: when someone told me they were advised to just keep "working on it" mentally to get over an aversion to penis, I called that "among the maddest" of all the madness in trans rhetoric — telling someone who isn't attracted to men that they have to convince themselves to like penis for any reason at all. I've shared an anecdote about a woman I know who was passionately pro-trans for years and who challenged me fiercely back in the late aughts, when Thomas Beatie, the "pregnant man," was in the news. I had remarked that I had no problem with trans people but that I could not consider a human being who got pregnant, carried and gave birth to a child with their own original equipment to be male. That woman, who then had a toddler daughter, now has a "son." On a physical level, I've dealt with a pelvic floor problem — not caused by testosterone, since I never took it, but for other reasons. I got pelvic floor physical therapy, which didn't completely solve it but helped a lot. I've also been in therapy, and I've spoken positively about therapy as a route to dealing with dysphoria without medical intervention. I've been supportive of individual people questioning or hesitating about transition. I've told someone who'd been happy for a year being themselves with no hormonal treatment not to mess with their physical health and risk medical complications, and I've endorsed the idea that "there's no need to rush a decision you might regret" as words to live by for all important decisions. I've also complimented people's appearances warmly and offered emotional support to others in the community. Outside of gender, I love growing food. I don't currently identify as anything beyond myself — I'm just me, a biologically female person who didn't transition and who is critical of how rigidly the modern trans movement codifies gender performance.