Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben geboren als vrouw en gedetransitioneerd, en ik identificeer nu als gender-nonconforme lesbische vrouw zonder gevoelde genderidentiteit. Ik herleid mijn dysforie tot seksueel misbruik in mijn kindertijd, waarschijnlijk onopgemerkt autisme en beperkende genderrollen, en ik hield op met transitie willen toen ik de bron van mijn nood van mijn lichaam naar de samenleving verplaatste. Ik heb geen eigen operaties beschreven, maar ik waarschuw anderen tegen lichtvaardige bovenoperaties en hormonen, en ik betoog dat spijt in wezen onvoorspelbaar is. Ik beheer mijn mentale gezondheid met gewichtheffen, klimmen en herkaderen, en heb publiekelijk gesproken over het verdwijnen van lesbische gemeenschappen. Ik blijf kritisch over transitie voor anderen, terwijl ik tegen conversietherapie en ROGD-achtig onderzoek ben.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female, and I've never described the exact age my dysphoria started, so I can't pin that down — what I can say is that by the time I was writing publicly about it in 2021 I had already lived through a period of identifying as trans and had come out the other side of it, identifying as a gender-nonconforming woman.
Looking back, I think the hatred I felt toward my body was the core of it. I wrote that "you have to deeply hate your body to go through with it. You need some desire to erase it." I connected that directly to childhood sexual abuse, saying "I think this is why a lot of us are child sex abuse victims... that kind of trauma can make a perfectly healthy body feel 'defiled'." That was my own framing of why I had wanted to change my body so drastically — the sense that it had been ruined. I also suspect I'm on the autism spectrum, though I've never been formally tested; I told another person that autism "manifests differently in female people" and suggested they get tested, and I said that a lot of dysphoria "is probably just autism, performing any kind of social role is uncomfortable for most of us." I've also dealt with depression: birth control made me "severely depressed for about two years" when I took it for acne, to the point where it made me "unable to function."
The thing that actually turned me around was a shift in where I located the problem. I wrote plainly: "I started identifying the source of my dysphoria as something external instead of internal. I stopped blaming my body." I tried to redirect the hatred I felt for my gender nonconformity and my homosexuality toward society instead — "My body and behaviors are not inherently 'wrong'. They just don't fit the current model of gender." I told myself, "I am not the problem, I am just caught up *in* the problem." Over time that became a positive project rather than just a reframing: I got into rock climbing, lifting, white-water rafting, kayaking, shooting, and squatting my body weight, and I described going braless with pasties while being "fucking jacked." I said I no longer wanted to be a man — "I want to be a weird woman that supports other weird woman haha."
I reasoned about the biology too. I read about the grandmother hypothesis and about testosterone burning men out over time while estrogen supports longevity, and I found solidarity in the idea of women's collective oppression and in the possibility that tracking menstrual cycles was an early form of timekeeping. I acknowledged that what bothers me most about womanhood — bras, pressure to have children, risk of harassment — "is usually social, not biological." I also recommended arming yourself: "a gun definitely helps level the playing field."
I have strong opinions about how transition should be handled for others. I think double mastectomies are "a form of self harm when they aren't medically necessary," while admitting my own breasts "feel alien on my body" — but removing a literal organ strikes me as a "fucked up approach." I've told people considering testosterone to masculinize in other ways first, like developing muscle or shaving their head, and to at least start low-dose. I've told people not to undergo surgery if they're unsure, and I've said flatly that "the surgeries aren't going to make you really female." I'm skeptical of the ROGD label because of its methodology — parents self-selected from explicitly anti-trans sites like 4th Wave Now — and I've argued that predicting regret is "as elusive as predicting the stock market." I don't believe in conversion therapy: "Conversion therapy doesn't work. It will only traumatize you further." My advice to dysphoric people is to accept the dysphoria rather than repress it, and let it fade into the background.
I don't have a gender identity in any felt sense. I wrote, "I do not have a gender identity. I do not identify as anything. I am simply seen as female because I have female anatomy, and that makes me fall into the social category 'woman'." I compare it to left-handedness — I don't feel left-handed, I just am. I'm a lesbian, and I've written about my discomfort with penises ("penises are fucking gross") and about the disappearance of lesbian communities, which I said I don't know how to cope with. I've also expressed worry about the loss of lesbian spaces and about the way gender roles drive people toward transition.
I don't describe myself as full of regret in these posts — the tone is more analytical and outward-facing than anguished — but I do carry the scars of what my body went through: the childhood sexual abuse, the two years of depression on birth control, and the alienation from my own chest. I live in the American South. I've been an active, vocal presence in detrans and gender-critical spaces, arguing with both sides, pushing back on ROGD, pushing back on people who pathologize butch women and gay people, and encouraging others to seek trauma therapy or therapy familiar with ASD rather than surgery.