Alle verhalen

Dysforie op haar 11e, butch-acceptatie op haar 30e, zonder hormonen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd965
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedesisteerde, als gedetransitioneerd identificerende lesbische vrouw die me in mijn jeugd als jongen identificeerde maar nooit medisch is getransitioneerd. Mijn genderdysforie begon rond mijn 11e, bereikte een hoogtepunt halverwege mijn tienerjaren met suïcidale gedachten, en verdween toen ik accepteerde dat ik een mannelijke, lesbische vrouw ben. Ik heb een depressie en was ooit suïcidaal, maar ik ben nu gelukkig als vrouwelijke butch-lesbienne. Ik ben kritisch over transitie en genderideologie en zie trans-identificatie als vergelijkbaar met anorexia: iets wat therapie nodig heeft in plaats van chirurgie.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I have always been a masculine girl — I wanted boy things from the start, and my mother is also masculine by nature, so I think some of us are simply born with masculine personalities rather than being born in the wrong body. My gender dysphoria started really young, at about 11, and it became too much by my mid-teens, when I couldn't even look at my body. I would just cry and think about suicide. I hated being female, I hated being judged for my personality because I was a girl, and I was convinced I couldn't do the things I wanted to do because I was a girl. For a while I truly believed I would never be happy because I couldn't be a boy, which is what I felt I was. I used to think I was a boy and identified as one, but I never medically did anything to my body — no hormones, no surgeries, nothing. Alongside that I was very misogynistic: I looked down on women even though I was, and still am, a lesbian. A few years ago I wished I was a gay man instead. I also had a phantom penis — I used to feel it, and I still feel it lightly sometimes when I think about sex with women — but I never took hormones, and I now understand that liking women is not a male thing and does not mean I have a male brain. What actually moved me was slowly accepting myself. One day I thought deeply about why I wanted to be a man, and I realised it was because I hated how people saw me — they held me to the basic female view of liking boys, makeup and so on, and when they didn't see me as manly and gay it hurt me deeply. I realised I wanted to be a man so that other people would treat me differently, and that changing my whole life so strangers would treat me differently would not make life easier. I also accepted that I am gay, and slowly I became happy with my sex. That is how my gender dysphoria got cured. I still every now and then feel a bit uncomfortable being female, but I do not wish to have been born a boy. I am female and happy. My orientation went through several stages: first I thought I was a lesbian, then I thought I was a gay or bi man, then for a short time a straight woman, then a bi woman, and now I know I'm a lesbian, and I've been sure of that for a few years. I didn't have much of a sex drive until about 18; I knew I was attracted to girls very young but only started feeling them sexually at 18, when I began masturbating to girls almost every day. I came out to my mother and a few other family members about having identified as a boy, but most people in real life and on social media don't know that part of my life. I live with depression and I was suicidal for many reasons, though every time I get through the urge to kill myself I see a better life and I'm always happy that I'm alive. Some days I feel bad about myself, but never in that bad way I did a few years back. I also had a bad experience with a therapist who forced her religious views on me. Now I'm happy to be myself and a lesbian, and I'm happy to be a female butch. It no longer matters to me whether people view me as a manly gay girl or a straight girl — I never thought I'd feel that way, but I do. What does still hurt is people telling me I'm trans when I'm not: because I'm manly, sometimes I look completely like a boy apart from my height, and people assume I must want to become a man or that I'll one day transition. They still call me she/her, but they think I deep down want to be a man. I've considered telling people about my past in the hope it stops them thinking I'm a boy, but I worry it might make things worse, and if I say trans brains aren't real people will call me transphobic. I now think gender is binary: masculinity and feminality are just personality, men can be like women and women like men, but there are physical differences between male and female and only females can give birth. I don't think gender dysphoria is genetic; I believe it comes from people, culture and stress, and that it can be fixed. I compare being trans to anorexia — both are illnesses that need therapy, and no one would encourage an anorexic with surgery. I don't want trans people to die even though I disagree with them, and I don't think anyone believes trans people should be killed; I'm tired of people treating criticism or non-acceptance of trans ideology as murder. I've described myself as desisted rather than detransitioned, since I never medically transitioned.