Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die in 2012 sociaal transitioneerde terwijl ik leed aan onopgemerkte schizoaffectieve stoornis, in het ziekenhuis werd gediagnosticeerd en rond 2017 detransitioneerde nadat antipsychotica me deden afvragen wat een man eigenlijk is. Ik nam nooit testosteron en had geen operaties, maar op mijn 29e ben ik bezorgd over terugkerende gevoelens dat ik een diepere stem en een platte borst wil, en ik vrees dat het erop wijst dat mijn mentale gezondheid weer achteruitgaat. Ik ervaar mijn masculiene presentatie (binden, packer, nepbaard, masculiene termen) als verkleedpartij en niet als non-binaire identiteit, en ik ben op mijn hoede voor het NB-label. Ik heb een zelfmoordpoging gedaan in mijn midden twintiger jaren, maar ben nu veel beter af, met een baan, een vriendin en steunende vrienden. Ik accepteer mijn biologie als vrouwelijk en koos voor detransitie omdat hormonen en operaties dat niet zouden veranderen.
Volledig verhaal
I began to socially transition in 2012, when I was very mentally unwell with undiagnosed schizoaffective disorder. I was very close to being put on testosterone, but my gender therapist saw the warning signs — I believed I was a mutilated cis male, that I was really born male at birth and the doctors had turned me female. She refused to give me T until I was seen by a psychotherapist, who diagnosed me with schizoaffective disorder.
Once I got on my antipsychotics, for the first time I could think clearly. I remember sitting in the hospital bed in 2017 and saying to myself "what is a man?" and when I couldn't answer, I felt I was making a mistake. I went back and decided not to transition. I never went on T, but the embarrassment of telling everyone who had accepted me that I was no longer a guy was a big identity crisis. For 5 years before that I had been a guy. After being treated for mental illness, my "trans" disappeared. Of course my family did the "I told you so, you weren't well, now you're our little girl again!" I went very hyper-feminine to make up for the times I threw all my makeup away because "Boys don't wear makeup."
I told my mum while I was in hospital, just saying "I don't think I'm a man any more." She asked what made me come to that conclusion. I said that no matter how much I changed I couldn't change my biology, and in the end knowing that I couldn't accept that, I decided to detransition. I wasn't happy knowing all the surgery and hormones wouldn't make me magically a man. It was a hard fact to swallow. When my partner said he was trans, it was the same question I asked him. He said he knew he was a woman, he knew his biology wouldn't change, and thus it was a better decision for him. I think my mum was more happy to accept me because I accepted reality finally.
I thought I was happy being cis again. I am now 29 (as of early 2023) and the feeling is creeping back. I love having long hair and looking feminine, but I say to myself I would love a deep masculine voice, and then I look at my chest and think I would love to be flatter. I've tried on my old packer and binder and found myself feeling neutral. I don't think I will ever try to transition, but I have found myself searching YouTube for ways to deepen my voice without T, or how to sound male. I'm worried it's a warning sign my meds aren't working any more. I know I'm not trans, I know I am 100% female, but I look at the NB term and feel like I'm falling for a trap. I don't want to have the breakdown I did back when I wasn't well. I'm scared this is a warning sign something is going on. I never liked my breasts even as a kid, always hated them, but I think a lot of girls feel that way too.
Growing up I was always very masculine as a kid — I was always playing the dad roles when no boys were around, but I was still a feminine person while also being a big tomboy. That's why I'm worried about terms like Non-Binary or Genderfluid, because I feel they're pointless, but at the same time I have no clue how to explain to people why I enjoy masculine terms, being called sir or mister. I'll put on a fake beard and makeup and bind my chest to look male while also being 100% happy with my biology.
I've used the term androgynous before, but every time I look it up it's put under the NB umbrella, like it's a whole gender, and it's confusing. To me androgynous is an outfit. I feel comfortable with they/them but don't care about being called she, because why would I? When I put on my beard and bind my chest I feel like I'm a guy, but I'm happy I get to take it all off and be a woman again. It's an outfit. When I put it on I'm a guy, take it off I'm a woman. But why are people saying that's NB and telling me I am NB? I'm playing dress up basically, which is why I don't know if I am NB. I'm more close to a drag king than anything else at this point, but even that's put under the trans umbrella.
A lot of my friends are trans, so they feed into the "you can get top surgery and not be trans" idea in my head. But I know I won't go down that route because I don't hate my breasts. I'm a UK size 10 and small in height, and a 36D, so even though I'm small I have some fat on me. I wear baggy shirts all the time, nothing tight — in pictures I look like a 90s kid with baggy pants, baggy shirts and a backwards cap. I would like to wear dresses sometimes but my chest keeps me from doing so. I think I'm hesitant about breast reduction because it seems obvious it's a type of body dysmorphia — if I get a reduction, then what, my hips too curvy? I haven't tried sport bras yet but will give them a try.
I have had a suicide attempt in the past, in my mid twenties, when I had no friends, no lover, no job and thought I was worthless. Over about six years things improved: I got a job I love, a wonderful girlfriend, friends who understand me. I'm now in my late twenties and doing much better.