Alle verhalen

Anorexia van 12 tot 30, nooit getransitioneerd, en toch r/detrans lezen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd101
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde... nee: ik ben een gendercritische vrouw die nooit is getransitioneerd, geboren in 1978, die r/detrans bezoekt uit solidariteit en omdat het me helpt. Ik was anorectisch van mijn 12e tot mijn 30e en heb PCOS, en ik herken me diep in de angst van posters om 'vrouw te worden' en het gevoel dat hun lichaam vlees is. Ik ben kritisch over de aanpak van dysforie door de APA en over SRS, maar ik verzet me ook fel tegen wrede opmerkingen van zowel GC- als trans-kant jegens detransitioners. Ik heb geen dysforie, maar zeg dat ik die misschien had gehad als ik niet in een progressief gezin was opgegroeid. Ik blijf gendercritisch en ben geen detransitioner, en ik probeer in de sub te luisteren in plaats van te prediken.

Volledig verhaal

I am a gender critical woman who is not a detransitioner, and I came to r/detrans because the GenderCritical sidebar linked here, which made me assume people like me were welcome. I was born in 1978 and I am 40 years old as of these posts in late 2019. I am female, straight, and not traditionally feminine. I explicitly say I have not transitioned or detransitioned, and I acknowledge I may not belong in the sub, telling others I try to be careful about what I respond to and that I have tried to leave my 'militant radfem hat at the door and just listen.' I do not have dysphoria myself, but I say that if I had not grown up in a progressive house and community where non-conformity was encouraged, I am sure I would be struggling with dysphoria or something like it. I was anorexic from ages 12 to 30 (roughly 1990-2008, given I was born in 1978). Reading a young detransitioner's post about dread at the words 'becoming a woman' and feeling like 'meat,' that her breasts are meat, resonated with me deeply — I said I could see myself saying absolutely everything she said, and I was 'amazing to hear from someone else' but sad to hear it from someone so young almost 30 years later. I also have PCOS, and I noted that after several years without periods I actually came to love my period because it feels like my body is healthy and functioning. I visit the sub partly because it helps me, and partly out of solidarity. I try to be empathetic: I ask suicidal posters if they are okay and safe, I defend detransitioners against cruel comments from both sides, and I criticize other gender critical posters who pile on. I told one commenter 'This is why they think GC people suck. I am tired of being associated with people without a shred of empathy.' I also called out a GC poster who was only willing to support detransitioners as long as they agreed with her political opinion, saying 'Not every detransitioner is opposed to transitioning; not every detransitioner feels they were railroaded... Unless someone specifically asks, that doesn't belong here.' I agreed with a moderator-type request that GC political discussion doesn't belong in the sub unless specifically asked for. On substance, I believe gender roles are 'prisons, they are corsets' and that everyone should be able to be who they are regardless of their body parts. I am critical of the medical and psychological establishment: I said it 'blows my mind' that the APA's approach to dysphoria is to pass the buck to medical doctors and leave it to the patient to convince everyone they are something they aren't, and I think the APA should be included among those called unethical. I am skeptical of SRS, saying I understand the view that it is nowhere near advanced enough and frequently causes disastrous health consequences, while also acknowledging such posts can be hurtful to people who already had the surgery. I do not hate men — I say men are happier when they don't objectify women — and I wish there were a real men's movement devoted to fighting cultural proscriptions on males, not 'MRA poison.' I am critical of trans activism (whom I call TRAs) and of what I see as the hostility and threats directed at gender critical people, but I also push back on cruel or dehumanizing language from my own side. I have not done formal advocacy or activism described here beyond posting in these forums. I have not described any detransition process, hormone use, surgeries, or transition-related medical history, because I never transitioned. My relevant medical history is anorexia from ages 12-30 and a PCOS diagnosis. I have not described therapy. I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm. I have not described a specific current identity beyond 'gender critical woman, not a detransitioner.'