Alle verhalen

De puberteit van haar zus en een lichaam waaraan ze niet kon ontsnappen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd130
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde (heridentificerende) vrouw die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd maar jarenlang ernstige genderdysforie had en op weg was te transitioneren, tot therapie, medicatie, een liefdevolle verloofde en later een traumagerichte therapeut me hielpen inzien dat mijn dysforie een traumareactie was met wortels in de puberteit van mijn oudere zus en in geïnternaliseerde misogynie. Ik begreep dat je ongemakkelijk voelen in je lichaam een veelvoorkomende cis-vrouwelijke ervaring is, gevormd door objectivering en misogynie, en hoewel ik me soms nog onprettig voel over vrouw zijn, weet ik nu dat die gevoelens geen genderdysforie zijn. Ik worstel ermee mijn ouders, die me naar therapie stuurden om me te 'fixen' toen ik uitkwam als trans, te vertellen dat ik cis ben, uit angst dat ze zullen triomferen, en misschien neem ik het mee mijn graf in. Ik steun transitie voor mensen bij wie het dysforie echt helpt, maar ik ben kritisch over wat ik zie als hypocrisie en anti-cis-vijandigheid in delen van de transgemeenschap, en ik kom vaak in 'truscum'-ruimtes waarvan de opvattingen over gender bij de mijne aansluiten. Ik pleit voor betere wetenschap om te begrijpen wat mensen tot transitie brengt en om te voorkomen dat potentiële detransitioners überhaupt transitioneren.

Volledig verhaal

I had severe gender dysphoria for years and was fully on my way to transitioning, but through a combination of therapy, medication, and the support of a loving fiancée, my dysphoria was resolved. I'm careful to say that this is true for at least some people — maybe some people's dysphoria isn't curable — but it was true for me. I never medically transitioned; I desisted (or 'reidentified,' as I sometimes call it). I came to a key realization around May of 2019 that it is absolutely a cis female experience to feel weird about, in, or with your body, because of objectification and misogyny. I also recognized that I had a lot of internalized misogyny — I didn't want to be seen as weak, and I associated female words with being weaker. I'm still working through that mishmash of bullshit fed to me by society. I try to reinforce to the people who care that I go by 'she,' even if it makes me uncomfortable, because I am the possibility of a woman. I tell that to myself too: 'woman' — like YES you can be strong and butch and also a WOMAN. It's hard even conceptually, and I can't imagine how hard it is for those who did medically transition. As someone who'd been reidentified for about three months by late August 2019, I still had doubts sometimes and still felt uncomfortable at the thought of being a woman. But I know now where those thoughts stem from, and it's not gender dysphoria. My advice to others in similar situations is not to force yourself to be feminine or masculine — just do you and say 'fuck it' to people who say whatever you're doing invalidates your gender status. I also found that well-fitting bras (I recommended r/abrathatfits) made me feel much more comfortable about my chest, greatly diminishing that dysphoria. On the family front, my parents sent me to therapy to 'fix' me when I came out as trans; they accused me of being severely mentally ill, and so on. Years later I'm afraid of proving them 'right' and reinforcing their idea that trans people can just be 'fixed' to be cis. I don't want to talk to them about it or see their judgmental and/or self-righteous stares. They were wrong to send me to therapy like that — it's not therapy that changed my views of myself, but gender theory, a different philosophy, and a bit of feminism. It feels shameful to have to address my parents about this; I feel like they'll gloat 'I told you so.' I might just take this to my grave, like maybe I'll never be able to tell them that I'm cis. My most recent therapist was actually the one who helped me recognize the trauma I'd been through, which I hadn't recognized before. My trauma was mostly caused by my older sister when she was entering puberty, and my therapist said something like 'that must have made your own puberty very scary, because you only had this one example of what going through puberty was like.' That was eye-opening about my 'dysphoria,' which is actually a trauma response. This therapist helped me realize I'm not trans — not through any conversion techniques, but just through making me think. I fully support people transitioning to ease dysphoria and respect their preferences to be referred to as their transitioned gender. I recognize trans people are treated roughly by most people, though I see that changing for the better. But I'm frustrated by what I see as hypocrisy: I hate the fact that many trans people have what I perceive as a huge victim complex and judge all cis people harshly, while simultaneously saying 'it's okay to question your gender and realize that you're cis.' I feel they're the ones making it not okay, and that they contribute to gender confusion. People are allowed to be cis. I don't think all trans people act like this, and I tend to hang around 'truscum' areas of the internet because those trans and cis people have a similar philosophy of gender to mine. I hope those who think the way I described eventually stop being so hateful. I also believe that being positive about the fact that transition works for SOME people is not anti-detrans — the two can coexist. Because detrans people exist, we need to make the science around trans people better, understand more what makes people transition, and prevent potential detransitioners from transitioning in the first place.