Alle verhalen

Een cis man die nooit transitioneerde en vecht op r/detrans

Man · Gedesisteerd95
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een cisgender man die nooit is getransitioneerd; ik post en reageer op r/detrans om medische transitie tegen te gaan, vooral bij minderjarigen, en om rechtszaken tegen artsen en therapeuten aan te moedigen. Ik omschrijf mezelf als hypermasculien en comfortabel in mijn mannelijke lichaam, en ik geef botte adviezen aan twijfelende jongeren: twijfel betekent dat ze niet trans zijn en dat ze therapie nodig hebben. Ik geloof dat blokkers voor kinderen een misdaad tegen de menselijkheid zijn en dat het najagen van gendereuforie is als het najagen van een drugshigh. Ik heb zelf nooit dysforie ervaren of ben gedetransitioneerd; mijn betrokkenheid is activisme en steun. Op dit moment identificeer ik me als cis man en blijf ik kritisch op transitie terwijl ik detransitioners steun.

Volledig verhaal

I'm a cis man — born male, and I've never had any reason to think otherwise. I've never experienced gender dysphoria, never questioned my sex, and I've never transitioned or detransitioned myself. My involvement in r/detrans comes from a strong conviction that transition is being pushed on people who don't need it, especially minors, and I want to use my perspective as someone who has always been comfortable in a male body to push back. I think puberty blockers for children are, in my words, "a crime against humanity" and I believe they should never have been allowed. I'm furious at the doctors and therapists who I feel "fed the delusion" to vulnerable kids and parents — I say things like "you need to sue these psychologists that convinced you to maim and sterilize yourself." I've repeatedly suggested that people on the subreddit should file lawsuits, including a class action lawsuit, because "things won't change until people's wallets start to take a hit." I posted a thread asking whether anyone had considered filing lawsuits, and another about confronting my gender therapist, describing him as "extremely well-spoken." I give blunt advice to posters who are questioning or considering transition. I tell young women "You're a girl, be proud of your femininity. All the gender stuff is bullshit" and warn that transitioning is "close to ruining your life." To someone questioning their gender I say that if you don't care about gender like 99% of people, then you're not trans, you're normal — and that actively telling people "I know I was born a girl but I'm actually a boy" is the abnormal thing. I believe any doubt at all means you're not trans and need psychoanalysis: "If you have any doubts AT ALL you are not trans." I also argue that only trans people worry about gender — as a cis man I never think about it, and my girlfriend, a cis woman, agrees she never thinks about it either. I'm critical of parents who won't say no to their kids, and I'm skeptical of suicide-risk arguments used to justify medical intervention: "Put your kid in therapy and you'll find out quick if they're gonna take a dirt nap anytime soon — don't put them on chemical castration drugs." I compare chasing gender euphoria to chasing a drug high — unhealthy and unnatural — and say you have to play the hand you're dealt. I do believe therapy is valuable: I say people need therapy rather than transition, and I mention that I see a therapist myself. On a personal level I describe myself as a hyper-masculine, stereotypical jock-type guy, aggressive, who used to make jokes about trans people but now wants to hold the medical establishment accountable. I've mellowed in some tastes — I used to be into IPAs and now drink Smirnoff Ice or white Sauvignon Blanc. I'm in a relationship with a girlfriend (a cis woman). I recall that when I was 13 I had a bad month feeling depressed, my parents took me to a therapist, my mom and I wanted antidepressants, but my dad refused, and after a few sessions I realized it wasn't that bad — I use this to argue that ordinary adolescent distress gets medicalized now. I also recall being told to "man up" as a boy. Overall I'm supportive of people detransitioning and critical of transition as it's currently practiced, especially for young people, and I advocate for legal accountability through lawsuits.