Alle verhalen

Drie jaar Tumblr, nooit een dosis T

Vrouw · GedesisteerdEerste dysforie 13 → Sociale transitie 14 → Desistance 18184
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedesisteerde, gedetransitioneerde vrouw die me ongeveer drie jaar, van rond mijn 14e tot bijna mijn 18e, als trans man identificeerde, zonder ooit medisch te transitioneren. Mijn dysforie hing samen met onontdekt autisme, depressie, anorexia vanaf mijn 13e, geïnternaliseerde misogynie en veel invloed van Tumblr en sociale media vanaf mijn 12e. Ik had suïcidale gevoelens tijdens mijn trans identificatie, maar begon nooit met hormonen, mede dankzij het verzet van mijn vader. Ik omarm nu vrouw zijn, verwerp de transgemeenschap als giftig en heb kritische opvattingen over transitie en over de geestelijke gezondheid van mensen die zich als trans identificeren.

Volledig verhaal

I identified as trans male for about three years, from roughly age 14 to nearly 18, and I have now desisted. I was born female. I have a long history of depression and other mental illnesses, and I was undiagnosed autistic, which left me feeling outcasted and unable to relate to other girls my age. I had always been masculine and tomboyish. When I was about 12, I started using social media like Tumblr, where I found people I could relate to, and I began identifying as nonbinary. I wish I could go back and tell my younger self that it is okay to be a gender-nonconforming girl. Around age 13, I developed anorexia, which I never told anyone about. I began to hate the curves and fat on my body even though I was a very average, actually pretty small person. Online influence led me to believe that this, combined with my tomboyish mentality, meant I was actually a male in a female body. I was clearly just a young, mentally ill person, but being given a simple solution seemed so appealing to younger me. Looking back, I feel angry at the trans community for making me feel more confused during my developing years. I believe there is nothing wrong with being gender-nonconforming or not feminine as a girl, but the community made me feel like I must be male because I had 'all the symptoms' — though most of those symptoms are common parts of puberty, and being uncomfortable with bodily changes is something everyone goes through, which can be worse for autistic kids who hate change. This extreme desire to be something impossible led me to become even more depressed and suicidal. I feel I was lied to when told transitioning would make me happy; instead it made me miserable and lonely. I feel I missed out on a lot of my youth being stressed about something that doesn't matter. I came to believe the transgender community is toxic and unhealthy and I don't want to associate with it. I used to be angry at my dad for not letting me medically transition, but I'm honestly glad I never started hormones. I eventually thought, 'I don't want to be trans, but I don't want to be a girl,' and realized it doesn't matter — I just need to be myself. I feel lucky I didn't make any harsh decisions, though I have empathy for those who did. I'm still learning to love myself as I am rather than strive for the impossible goal of changing my sex. My therapist never questioned my gender dysphoria at all, which bothers me in retrospect — I believe therapists and the community should look at the root causes of dysphoria instead of automatically accepting it. Later I realized that gender doesn't matter and I can dress and express myself however I want, and that being a man won't cure my problems with my body and myself. I recognized a lot of internalized misogyny — I had internalized sentiments that women are bad and stupid and can't do as much as men. Another key realization was that no matter what I identify as, I will always be female, so I should embrace what I was born with and unravel why I hated being female instead of running from it. I hold critical views of transition: I've expressed the opinion that nobody is actually trans, that people have problems with self-image and hate being themselves so they try to be somebody else to cope, and that everyone I've met who identifies as trans is mentally ill (not meant as an insult). I also view medical transition negatively — 'just living as somebody else' with a constant feeling of lying to everybody even when stealth — and believe it's better to learn to love yourself as the sex you were born as because that will never change. I have been critical of doctors who I feel don't question patients and just prescribe medication, comparing it to doctors prescribing addictive benzodiazepines to women. I have offered encouragement to others in the community, telling one person they look like a young average guy, telling another their voice is androgynous but may become more female-pitched over time, and reassuring someone who felt 'ruined' by medical interventions that many differences can be restored to near-original condition over time.