Alle verhalen

Hypermannelijk, toen hypervrouwelijk, en toen klaar met toneelspelen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd162
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedesisteerde biseksuele vrouw die als tiener uit een trans-identificatie stapte nadat ik besefte dat ik eigenlijk niet trans wilde zijn. In eerste instantie probeerde ik vrouwelijkheid te overdrijven om te bewijzen dat ik een vrouw was, maar toen besefte ik dat dat dezelfde valkuil was als mijn eerdere hypermannelijkheid. Ik verwerp nu patriarchale definities van vrouwelijkheid en geloof dat vrouw geboren zijn is wat mij een vrouw maakt. Ik ben kritisch over hoe transitie wordt neergezet en over de medicalisering van dysforie, en ik geef de voorkeur aan een gesprek van persoon tot persoon boven publiek aan de schandpaal nagelen om mensen van mening te laten veranderen. In wat ik heb gedeeld beschrijf ik geen operaties, hormonen of lopende medische behandeling.

Volledig verhaal

I am a desisted woman who is bisexual, and I have thought a lot about how internalized homophobia and societal pressure shaped my earlier identification as trans. I recall my teenage self wondering whether I really wanted to be trans, and I remembered the trans community's line that "if you think youre trans or want to be trans, then youre trans" — which led me to reason that if I didn't want to be trans, then I wasn't, and I began to come to terms with being a butch girl/woman. When I first desisted, I hyperfocused on being feminine because I wanted to prove that I was a woman. I eventually realized this was the same pattern as when I had hyperfocused on being masculine while I said I was trans. I noted that it was a tough pill to swallow, because it meant people had been pretending to go along with my identity since there was no way I was masculine like a man. I am tall, toned, and have short hair, so I'm not traditionally feminine, but I came to believe those traits aren't innately masculine. I stopped trying to fit with femininity, reasoning that anything I do in a female body is feminine — whether I'm working in the shop, digging in the dirt, or using the bathroom — because I am a woman with a female body. I also noted that spending lots of money on makeup and clothes is expensive. I hold a critical view of patriarchal definitions of femininity. In an exchange with another desisted person, I argued that if femininity is defined as "acting like how women should be," then accepting that definition just reproduces patriarchal thinking — that treating femininity as a performance traps you in the same mindset you were in before, only with a detrans/desisted spin. I pushed back on the idea that we "owe femininity" in order to be women, while also maintaining that being born in a female body is what makes someone a woman. On the question of transition itself, I have commented that when someone says trans is "not rooted in reality," they don't mean it isn't real, but rather that literally changing sex isn't a realistic thing and being trans encourages you to believe that. I've also argued that heterosexual messaging is inescapable — in music, TV, advertisements, books, seeing couples on the street, and family asking "do you have a boy that you like??" — comparing it to a fish not realizing it's in water, and noting that discovering you're gay doesn't make you immune to those pressures, especially as a teenager. I believe a lot of bisexual women and lesbians have a hard time coming to terms with feelings for women because of that bombardment, and can conclude "there must be something wrong with me and i must be a boy." I have been critical of how r/detrans was slandered by others who then made r/actual_detrans because our community was "a bit too spicy for them." I've also taken a moderate view on activism, arguing that publicly calling people out on Reddit rarely changes minds and that the best way to change someone's mind is a one-on-one conversation, or at minimum a DM. I asked critical questions about medical practices, including questioning a clinician's remark that seemed to imply a patient was having sex with a dog, and questioning a claim that SRS causing sterility is "very beneficial to society at large."