Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I am a 37-year-old lesbian woman who briefly considered transitioning to male in my early twenties and has since become an outspoken critic of what I call trans ideology. My trans period was very short — around 2015, when I was about 23 — and it began because I was desperately lonely as a young lesbian in a small town that did not accept me. I got the idea that becoming a man was the answer. That period lasted less than a year, and it ended when a woman I had a crush on told me I was beautiful the way I was; I have described that as curing me of the belief that no woman would ever love me unless I became a man. I never medically transitioned and was never on testosterone — I have said repeatedly that I never went on T — and I only told a few people at the time because being trans was not popular back then. I have also said I was never around trans spaces before the age of 30, so gender dysphoria never really entered my mind even though I did feel uncomfortable with my body and my place in society; I found other ways to understand that discomfort. Around age 25 I had a realisation that there was nothing wrong with me — the problem was people believing there is a right and wrong way to be a woman.
I have always looked butch — I have described myself as looking like a "butch dyke" ever since I had agency over what I wear — and I have a naturally deep, gravelly voice that people sometimes read as male or describe as gender-neutral. I used to be self-conscious about my voice but now I see any perceived judgement was in my head, and I joke that when I wake up in the morning I can sing an old man country song. In recent years I get they/them pronouns more often, which frustrates me, especially since a trans-identifying male in my friend group consistently gets she/her because he uses a cute voice while mine is gravelly.
My troubles with trans discourse really started around the COVID pandemic, when a YouTube creator I liked went from being a shy guy to presenting as a lady who shows off her breasts and calls herself a lesbian. Since then I have tried to subject, but being in left-wing and gay spaces meant it constantly came up. I only started paying attention to trans issues in the last eight years or so, and around 2020 the dominant messaging I saw was essentially "I like girls' clothes and makeup so I'm a woman" — I looked in many trans spaces and talked to trans people I knew and they agreed it was sexist. More recently I have noticed trans channels shifting their messaging away from gender-nonconformity and toward claims about deep feelings of wanting the opposite sex, which I find scarily convincing enough that I have occasionally questioned myself again, asking whether I am actually trans or whether I obsess over this because I am fighting it. I always conclude that I am just a gay woman and that having envy for men does not make me a man.
I have been against trans ideology being presented as a solution to distressed people ever since I realised I am not the only sad gay person who got caught up in it. In May 2026 I tried to talk to my trans sister to make sure she was doing this for the right reasons and not being manipulated, and to explain that changing sex is impossible. She blocked all contact with me, as did my other sister, and I was called a "delusional bitch" even though I never used wrong pronouns and told her I did not mind if she stayed trans. I posted asking whether I should try to contact them again. By July 2026 I described being abandoned by my last two family members because I dared to ask if I could talk about the trans topic. I moved out of the small town but still struggle to find connections; I am severely lonely, with no offline friends and no relationship. I believe this movement preys on people like me.
I have depression. I also mentioned dating a woman who had a mental breakdown with hallucinations a few months before August 2026. I have a friend with ADHD who does not take her medication because it keeps her up at night. I grew up in a time when "lesbian" was used as an insult in school, and I did not identify as one for years because I hated the word; I eventually got used to it. I have been temporarily banned from platforms for expressing the view that being trans is a belief rather than a reality — I received a three-day ban and had earlier received a threat of ban, and I said I was documenting the mundane messages that get censored. I describe myself as a "country girl" who may not understand academic research but is willing to read papers on trans brains myself.
I now hold that being trans is not real as an identity but is a mental illness — that trans people are people who believe they want the opposite sex, that changing sex is impossible, and that dysphoria is something to fix rather than indulge. I advocate for therapy to understand why transition happened, for detransitioners to be honest with friends, and for women to be able to dress and act however they want without stereotypes defining femininity or masculinity. I consider "feminine" and "masculine" toxic descriptors. I think the movement preys on empathetic people and on lonely gay people, and I hope we get out of this phase. I have no regret about never medically transitioning, but I do feel distress about losing my family and about my ongoing loneliness.