Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde biseksuele man die medio 2020 een maand lang een niet-medische sociale transitie probeerde met zij/haar en een nieuwe stem, nooit hormonen nam en zich weer als man ging identificeren nadat gedachte-experimenten lieten zien dat ik een ideaal mannelijk lichaam wil. Ik begrijp mijn gendertwijfel nu als geworteld in waarschijnlijke borderline persoonlijkheidsstoornis, ernstig trauma in mijn kindertijd, seks-/pornoverslaving en onzekerheid over een onderdanige biseksuele man zijn. De maand dat ik als ‘zij’ leefde is een verontrustend geheugengat met blackouts en meer suïcidale gedachten, en ik heb nog steeds af en toe nachtmerries over HRT en identiteitsverbrijzelende lege momenten die ik beheer met afleiding en grounding. Ik koester geen kwade gevoelens jegens transmensen, maar bekritiseer zowel transessentialisme als transmedicalisme, en ik pleit voor voorzichtigheid, therapie en respect voor zowel transitie als detransitie. Ik ben nu een gedesisteerde, gedetransitioneerde man die zich als man identificeert en biseksueel is.
Volledig verhaal
I am a 27-year-old man who is bisexual and who briefly socially transitioned before desisting. I never took hormones, and I am grateful for that. My gender questioning started around 2015 when I was coming to terms with my sexuality, and I had a cross-dressing phase as a teen. Between roughly ages 14 and 17 I was obsessed with Russia and claimed I was Russian, then became an obnoxious 'teaboo,' and in adulthood I molded myself into a grump alcoholic and did crazy things for attention — my identity has always felt fragile. I have a crippling porn and sex addiction, and in my early 20s I had female embodiment fantasies (FEF, sometimes called cross dreaming) that died down and then returned around 2019. I thought transition would fix my mental health problems and make dating and my submissive sexual role easier.
In July 2020 I started identifying as female and tried a very light social transition for about a month: I did voice work online, asked people to use she/her, shaved, grew out my nails, and started a diet. At first she/her felt great and I was excited, but my mental health took a massive hit — worse than before. I was constantly in a state of panic and only felt kind of nice about 20% of the time. I blacked out in parts, talked in a new voice, was 'kind of dead socially,' had increased suicidal ideation during that period, and experienced mental blackouts that felt like I was going insane. That month is like a black hole in my memory; weird thoughts like 'I want this dress' flood back and feel foreign, as if written by someone else.
What snapped me back was a hypothetical a trans person gave me: wake up as a woman with the option to return to being male. I froze and said 'sure I'd stay a girl, but it feels off now.' Then I ran my own reverse-button version — waking up as an ideal version of my birth sex — and realized I have an ideal male body I actually want, which made me conclude I am probably not trans. I also saw a gender therapist, who was intimidated by my situation and accepted that my issues were 'different.' I have been hanging around BDD and BPD communities and relate far more to those struggles; I likely have Borderline Personality Disorder, which explains my weak sense of self, identity disturbances, dissociative episodes, extreme temper, and paranoia about being abandoned. My mother left when I was 8, my youth from ages 8–11 was incredibly rough, I considered suicide as early as 10, and I plotted a school shooting at age 9. Both of my parents have bipolar, and my mother had an adverse reaction to psychiatric medication. I lost my career, which made everything worse. I may participate in a study drug for BPD.
Since desisting, returning to male roles has given me euphoria, and my FEFs are essentially gone and now disgust me. I still have nightmares about HRT and periodic returns of the empty, listless feeling where my identity seems to shatter and I grab for something to identify with; I manage it with writing, weed, games, and grounding techniques like looking in a mirror and splashing cold water. I could not afford a therapist without insurance. I hold no ill will toward trans people — the community actually helped me figure myself out — but I am critical of trans essentialism, which I see as equally harmful as transmedicalism. I give advice to others urging caution about medical transition, therapy for underlying conditions, and respecting both the right to transition and the right to detransition.