Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw, als vrouw geboren, autistisch, die als tiener sociaal transitioneerde maar nooit testosteron nam of een operatie had. Ik identificeer me nu als gendernonconformistische vrouw en wijs labels af, al ervaar ik nog steeds terugkerend leed over vrouw zijn. Ik schrijf mijn transitie toe aan geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat uit conservatieve religie en online alt-right-/incelgemeenschappen, autisme-gerelateerd er niet bij horen, pesten, auto-androfilie, OCD-achtige religieuze obsessies (angst om non te worden) en escapisme in online transgemeenschappen. r/detrans heeft me geholpen te detransitioneren, en nu pleit ik op Reddit over autisme dat voor genderdysforie wordt aangezien, de schade van ‘gendercultuur’ voor jonge mensen en het verschil tussen toxisch transactivisme en oprechte transacceptatie. Ik ben nooit medisch getransitioneerd, dus ik heb geen operatiespijt, maar ik heb spijt van de verloren tijd en zelfhaat, en ik worstel nog met terugkerend leed, opdringerige gedachten en driften tot zelfbestraffing.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in a traditionalist Catholic household. Looking back, my discomfort started in childhood and adolescence, though I now describe it differently than I once did. As a teenager I was bullied severely, especially by other girls, and I never fit in with them. I also discovered online communities as a teenager that were openly hostile to women — one I describe as alt-right and neo-Nazi, telling us women were weaker and 'lesser men' to be sold like cattle. I later stumbled onto Christian online sites that expressed the same contempt for women under a religious veneer. I don't know if you can be traumatised through the internet, but I think I was, and it left me convinced that being female meant voluntary submission to all males.
Around the same time, a priest I idolised died, and I felt I had to somehow replace him — becoming male would do it, in my teenage reasoning. I also developed obsessions, which I now link to autism and OCD-like tendencies: I feared God wanted me to become a Christian nun, and I believed taking vows would seal my fate as a female forever. In my head, religious sisters were submissive, corresponding to old-fashioned patriarchy, and I did not want to lose my freedom. So I transitioned — socially — partly as a way to escape that fate and to punish myself for being a woman. I never took testosterone, and I never had surgery; I am grateful for that now. I experimented with names, deepened my voice, walked like a man, and enjoyed being referred to as male. I liked 'dude stuff', being aggressive, and fantasised about having big muscles and facial hair. I wanted to be Superman as a child and was fascinated by powerful men.
I also came to realise I have auto-androphilia: I have been sexually aroused by imagining myself as male or with a male body, wanting to see myself as an ideal, strong, good man. I have had kinks and have consumed porn, and I have noted that being addicted to gay male porn as a woman can be a sign of auto-androphilia. I identified as trans FTM at various points over the years, and at one point as non-binary while I was detransitioning, and I also identified as lesbian. I eventually stopped identifying as male, though the thoughts and fantasies have returned in waves — I have had nightmares about my femaleness, anger, and periods where I desperately wanted to be male again. In January 2023 I wrote a paranoid poem about needing 'the macho man pills', Vatican/CIA/KGB persecuting me, and God only loving me if I were Superman; I explicitly said I would not get my hands on testosterone.
What moved me toward detransition was r/detrans itself — it 'saved me' from transitioning by showing me there were alternatives for people who struggle with their gender. I also found the cartoon Steven Universe helpful in accepting myself as female, because it showed there isn't one way to be a woman. I came to understand that I wasn't truly uncomfortable in my body; I hated myself so much I thought transitioning would change that. My autism, my sensory dislike of dresses, make-up and heels, my difficulty making friends with girls, being bullied by girls, a lifetime of asking what was wrong with me, social disability, escapism, and finding acceptance in online trans communities all fed the decision. The rigid gender roles of conservative religion, incel/alt-right culture, and internalised misogyny did the rest. I now believe autistic people mistake autism for gender dysphoria, and that screening for autism should happen before medical transition.
I have never been diagnosed with OCD, but I have been diagnosed with autism (Asperger's). I still experience intrusive thoughts, self-punishment urges, and what I call 'dysphoria' returning, though I question whether it is truly dysphoria. I am still religious and say Jesus found me later, but I am angry at the conservative circles that taught me women are lesser. I have never medically transitioned, so I have no surgical regrets or fertility concerns from treatment; my regrets are about lost time, the self-hatred, and being pulled into trans identification. I now identify as a detransitioned, gender-non-conforming woman — I describe myself as a female cross-dresser who prefers to dress masculine and call myself 'masculine', but I reject the labels. I do a lot of advocacy on Reddit: I post and comment frequently about autism and trans identification, the harms of 'gender culture', non-binary identity, toxic trans activism versus trans acceptance, and I defend r/detrans against potential shutdown. I am critical of transition for young people and for people like me who had no true gender dysphoria, while saying trans people deserve rights and that genuine dysphoric transsexuals are different. I am supportive of gender-non-conforming people and of women, and I try to reassure others that there is no wrong way to be a woman.