Alle verhalen

De lichaamsdysforie die eigenlijk trauma was

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd204
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die mezelf een tijd transmasculien noemde maar nooit medisch is getransitioneerd. Mijn lichaamsdysforie kwam voort uit seksueel misbruik in mijn kindertijd door een vrouwelijk familielid, kritiek van mijn familie op mijn figuur, chronische pijn en PTSS-gerelateerde dissociatie, en niet uit genderidentiteit zelf. Door introspectie, therapie en psychologie studeren concludeerde ik dat gender een sociaal construct is en stopte ik me druk te maken over hoe anderen mijn geslacht lezen, waardoor ik me op mijn mentale gezondheid kon richten. Ik worstel nog met voorovergebogen lopen om mijn borsten te verbergen en ongemak bij rechtop staan voor de spiegel, maar ik heb mijn lichaam grotendeels leren accepteren. Ik steun transitie voor een klein aantal mensen, terwijl ik kritisch ben over hoe het wordt gepusht, vooral bij kinderen en trauma-overlevenden, en ik pleit voor traumasensitieve zorg en gelijke steun voor MtFtM-detransitioners.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I have never had a definitive 'trans' identity, but I spent a period seriously considering whether I was transmasculine, and I have thought about gender more deliberately than most people. I was molested by an older female family member when I was young, and I later learned what 'lesbian' meant. When I hit puberty, the part of my body I most identified as female was my breasts. In high school I slouched and wore baggy shirts essentially all the time, and I told everyone I knew that I didn't like to be touched that much. Touch is my primary love language. It took me many years of introspection and therapy to realize that I avoided touch with everyone in order to not be touched by women, and that I slouched and wore baggy shirts to hide my breasts. I also connected the molestation to my female shape at the time it happened — I made the connection that it must have had something to do with my female body — and I spent a long time trying to hide what I thought was quintessentially female about me. I was criticized by family any time I dressed in a way that showed off my figure; skirts and dresses were fine if they didn't look good on me. So my body dysphoria came largely from how people I cared about and respected talked about my feminine body. I have dealt with chronic pain, dissociation, and PTSD/complex trauma. I have serious trust issues, and the only thing that helped was years of seeing various mental health professionals combined with studying psychology in college. I did not start getting help until much later in life, and no one told me I could do my own research or help myself until just a few years ago. I thought I might be transmasculine, but I came to realize I felt a certain amount of social pressure at the time — I was dating a trans woman and living with three trans individuals — and that because of pain and PTSD I didn't feel like my body was right. I spent some time doing serious introspection, looking at non-binary resources (almost 5 years before 2019), which were the ones talking most about how gender is a social construct. I accepted and embraced the idea that gender is a social construct and therefore does not matter, and that helped with the psychological aspect. I decided that gender is absolutely meaningless without societal contexts, and I have been able to focus on my mental health because of this. I now genuinely do not care whether people read me as male or female; I try to be more comfortable with myself so that others are comfortable around me. Physically, I cannot hide my feminine features. The military taught me how to walk like a woman (learning to march correctly with a 1-2 inch heel is essentially how to walk like a woman), and my breasts didn't stop growing until I was about 25. Before that I wore more androgynous clothing I was actually comfortable in — sometimes a baggy men's T-shirt and men's Tripps, other times a flattering dress. I still slouch to this day out of habit, and standing up straight in front of a mirror still makes me uncomfortable. I have learned to accept my body, even if it still makes me uncomfortable sometimes. I also think most people experience body dysphoria to some degree — it drives most eating disorders, self-esteem issues related to physical appearance, and reasons people go to the gym or get plastic surgery. I suggested to one person that a breast reduction might be worth looking into. I have never had surgery or taken hormones myself as far as anything in my posts indicates. I have a biological sister with whom I maintain no contact because staying in contact puts my mental health at risk. My mum is nearly 70 and has offered me the metaphor of the pendulum: on this issue the two ends are 'suicide' and 'many detransitioners', or 'increased death' and 'increased infertility', and neither extreme is good, but before the pendulum can settle into the middle ground it has to go through both extremes. We have already been through the extreme of 'treat no one'. With each pass the pendulum swings less far, so we are headed toward a middle ground, though it won't be perfect. I know there are trans people for whom the only option is gender affirming care, but I also know there aren't very many of those people, so I support a methodical approach. I have met two people for whom transition was the right answer — one is a trans woman I'm fairly close to who spent 58 years living as a man, about 55 of those feeling like she was living a lie and terrified of the consequences if anyone found out; at 58 she said 'fuck it' and began social transition, and she is much happier and more comfortable now. I've met many more for whom it just wasn't working out, with many other issues at play. I think most people who claim to be 'trans' suffer from dissociation and/or chronic pain, and that a lot of people are trying to solve psychological problems by changing their bodies. I believe transgender is a real thing and that there are degrees of transition, but I don't think it's particularly common. I think there should be more oversight regarding children and young adults who aren't fully done growing yet (20-25ish), and I believe parents are being misled about the full long-term effects of blockers and HRT. I have advocated for trauma-informed mental health care as an alternative path for people with body dysphoria rooted in trauma, and I have advised people to approach mental health professionals describing 'body' dysphoria rather than 'gender' dysphoria because of how the DSM-5 frames treatment. I have also advocated that the detrans community should support MtFtM detransitioners equally and not treat them with scorn, and I've suggested that homogenous support groups (e.g. only detrans men) can be helpful. I have no interest in sharing my own story when evidence indicates I'd be treated with scorn for it. I was studying psychology in college and considered making a study of breast development in trans women my senior project. I currently identify as a woman (cis) and do not identify as trans.