Alle verhalen

Zeven jaar dysforie, beëindigd door een grap over wiskunde

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd194
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde (heridentificerende) lesbische vrouw in het VK die zeven jaar af en aan als trans identificeerde voordat ik rond 2017 besloot mezelf weer vrouw te noemen. Ik heb nooit hormonen of operaties gehad, maar ik was ernstig dysfoor en overwoog bijna een borstoperatie; mijn ‘peak trans’-moment was een vriendin die uitlegde dat ze zich ‘vrouwelijk voelde’ omdat ze passief was en slecht in wiskunde. Ik date nu een transman op testosteron en voel soms afgunst als ik hem zie geprezen worden voor de veranderingen die ik bijna zelf doorvoerde, al overweeg ik niet te transitioneren. Contact met andere gedetransitioneerde vrouwen en dagboek bijhouden redde me, en ik steun nu actief anderen in deze gemeenschap terwijl ik de poortwachtersrol van de NHS en genderidentiteitsverklaringen van vrouw-zijn bekritiseer.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I identified as trans on and off for about seven years, during which I was severely dysphoric. I never felt like I 'was' a boy or a girl — I described myself as agender for a stretch — I just felt dysphoric and deeply confused about what gender even was, especially since all my friends claimed to feel it so strongly while I felt nothing except unhappy. The turning point for me — my 'peak trans' moment — came when my best friend, a trans woman, told me she 'felt female' because she was passive, emotional, and bad at maths. It was like everything came crashing down in an instant. Around that same period I found out detransition wasn't just a myth (this was before the media got interested in detransition, when trans people constantly claimed nobody ever regretted transitioning and I'd seen no evidence otherwise), and I encountered radical feminists arguing that gender identity was just gender roles in rainbow packaging. I got curious and started asking my trans friends how they knew they were male or female; they were forthcoming and honest with me because I was questioning. In the five years since, I've never heard a single person explain 'gender feelings' in a way that wasn't totally regressive and stereotypical. It took about two years between my first real doubts and deciding to start calling myself a woman again. The moment I knew I needed to reidentify was watching a post-top-surgery video by a trans guy: even though I'd wanted that surgery for so many years, I didn't feel jealous or find his results aspirational. I realised what I actually wanted was to feel at home and confident in my body, and I didn't have to have surgery and be a guy to do that. I use the term 'reidentified' because that was the word people used when I started questioning around five years ago, and I'm attached to it. I started identifying as a woman again three years before early 2020 (so around 2017). In terms of how I experience gender identity, nothing has changed since then — I'm still just me, a human being who happens to have a female body. Being a woman affects my health, rights, social standing and the assumptions people make about me, but it has nothing to do with what sort of person I am, what I wear, what I'm good at, my hobbies, or how I feel about my body. I've gone back and forth in my mind constantly and have almost come out as non-binary a dozen times in the past few months, barely stopping myself each time. I still experience dysphoria and dysmorphia. What helps me is learning about the patriarchy and how unrealistic beauty standards are imposed on women — it helps me internalise that the problem isn't me or my body, it's the world we live in and specifically the corporations that profit from our hatred of ourselves. Naomi Wolf's The Beauty Myth was an eye opener for me. I also found that quitting binding absolutely does re-firm breast tissue, sometimes very significantly — from personal experience. I've dealt with insecurities about my genitals that I trace to porn culture, patriarchy and the male gaze rather than anything actually wrong with me; I felt like my body was weird and 'not like other women's' throughout my whole teenage and part of my adult life, and still do sometimes. I'm a lesbian. I've described myself as female, usually lesbian, and I've said that as a lesbian I wouldn't think twice about a partner having a larger clitoris. I've also noted I always hated being called a 'girl', but it got easier as I grew up and could use the word 'woman' instead. I'm in the UK and I've criticised the NHS as useless for anyone who doesn't follow a linear trans narrative, saying the lack of talk therapy for dysphoric people is so isolating. I also think the gatekeeping process is sexist as all hell and just reinforces the idea that being gender non-conforming equals being trans (and vice versa), and that how long someone has been dysphoric and how well they fit diagnostic criteria doesn't correlate with whether they detransition. I'm currently dating a trans man who has been on testosterone (10 months as of early 2020). When we started dating I didn't tell him I was reidentified and he couldn't understand why a cis girl knew everything about FTM transition. I've struggled with envy around the physical and social changes (attention, respect) he's been experiencing, and with insecurity about my decision to reidentify — it's hard to watch someone be praised for doing the thing you almost did. But I knew what potential feelings I was signing up for, my partner is incredibly understanding about both my dysphoria and my reasons for not pursuing transition, and I'm definitely not in a place where I'm actually considering transitioning. The shared experiences mean a lot to both of us. I've also reflected that most people in my life don't have much confidence in me and make me feel like everything I do is wrong while ignoring my actual achievements — I'd been looking for shallow validation in the wrong places instead of believing in myself. Connecting with other detransitioned and reidentified women is what saved me. I also journaled extensively for the first year or two to help put words to what I was feeling. My advice to detrans women is always to connect with others going through the same thing — write about your experiences, read about others', reach out and make friends. I've told others that recovery isn't a linear process and that everything feels like a struggle going nowhere until you look back and realise how far you've come. I've been active in this community offering support: encouraging others to focus on who they are as a person independent of gender, telling a teenager not to hold themselves back because of gender identity labels, reassuring a detrans person about their body and genitals, and pushing back against trans people's opinions being imposed on detransitioners. I'm critical of transition as a solution for dysphoria but not opposed to people experimenting — I've told younger people it's okay to experiment and follow their heart, and that stopping hormones for a while to figure things out is fine. I have no stated regrets about specific medical interventions because I never went through with them; my near-miss with top surgery is the clearest marker of how close I came.