Alle verhalen

Vijf jaar binden, één beha die haar aan het huilen maakte

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd423
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde biseksuele vrouw die ongeveer vijf jaar als trans identificeerde en ruwweg een jaar vóór het voorjaar van 2024 desisteerde, nadat ik besloot dat transitie een keuze was in plaats van iets waarmee ik geboren was. Privé weer als vrouw leven — inclusief het kopen van mijn eerste beha, waar ik van moest huilen omdat ik me voor het eerst als vrouw mooi voelde — maakte me comfortabeler, gelukkiger en zelfverzekerder, al worstel ik nog steeds op sommige dagen. Ik lijd aan ernstige neuropathie in mijn armen, borst en handen door binden, plus chronische pijn en chronische slapeloosheid waardoor ik me echt gemarteld voel in mijn lichaam, en ik zat jarenlang in een cyclus van zelfbeschadiging. Ik heb nu kritische opvattingen over transitie, ben tegen vrouwenruimtes inclusief niet-vrouwen, en pleit ervoor dat jongeren wachten met medische beslissingen; ik heb een steunende vriend die mijn verleden accepteerde. Ik ben actief in detrans-gemeenschappen en verdedig ze tegen trans-geïdentificeerde posters.

Volledig verhaal

I have always struggled with not feeling normal and hated gender roles, and in hindsight that definitely contributed to me identifying as trans — at the time it just made sense that transition was the solution, when in fact it wasn't. I spent about five years identifying as a male before I desisted. Looking back, I decided I didn't want to be trans because of how it had negatively affected me and would continue to do so the further along that path I went. I saw it as a hard path where you spend so much time, energy and money on something that never really makes you the opposite sex. It made dating hard, it was awkward to handle at work, it strained my relationship with my parents, and it made me feel miserable in my body. I came to the view that no one is trans — people just choose to live that way — and I didn't want to live that way. I decided to try going back to living as a woman privately at first, with a completely open and willing mind. Every time I had put on a bra or makeup while identifying as trans I went into it expecting to be uncomfortable, not really open to the idea that I might be okay with it, because I was scared to think about being wrong when I had been so sure for years that I was right. But I went into it wanting to be okay as a woman. I know not every woman likes feminine clothing, hairstyles and makeup, but I decided to try and see if there was anything I'd be comfortable doing. The first bra I bought from Target made me cry because it was the first time in my life I'd ever felt beautiful as a woman. That made me seriously think about everything I'd been through that led me to where I was, and I decided it would be very hard to go back but I had to try, because I wanted to live life without the judgment from others and the struggles I had up until then. I've been desisted for almost a year as of spring 2024. I still struggle some days, but I'm definitely a lot more comfortable, happy and confident since I've accepted my birth sex. I don't try to make myself fit into a box — I still have a lot of my men's clothing and I still have all the same hobbies that align with what people think of as male activities, but I've also started doing more feminine things I held back from while trying to live as a man because it made me feel not trans enough. I feel so much more free now, and I feel like I was more trapped in gender roles back then than I am now. I recently wore a bikini for the first time since I wasn't allowed to when I was younger, and it was a liberating experience. I also grew my hair out from being bald to decent length in about 18 months, and I get compliments on the layers now. A major health consequence of my time binding is severe neuropathy in my arms, chest and hands. I had been prepared for potential back issues and potential damage to my breast tissue, and I justified that in my head, but I was not expecting to develop severe neuropathy. I hadn't been binding for over six months when I wrote about it and I was still suffering — I barely sleep a lot of nights, I wear heat pads on my arms almost daily at work, and I only started getting my pain taken seriously and seeing a doctor recently, though it still interferes with my life daily. I have never been in pain this intense in my entire life and it is damaging my life and my mental health in a lot of ways. I wasn't even overdoing it based on what is recommended for binding, but I still pay the price with pain and numbness daily. I also have chronic health issues not related to testosterone, chronic pain conditions and chronic insomnia that make me truly feel miserable in my own body — much more than I could ever comprehend when I had gender dysphoria. I feel as if I am being actually tortured in my own body. What really triggered me recently was a friend's partner (a trans man) complaining about an inconvenience getting help from doctors regarding their gender-affirming care while I fight for my own healthcare from these same doctors. I was so angry at the American healthcare system for prioritizing the wrong things, and that person's entitlement struck a nerve — I wanted to tell them they are so lucky to have good health and should be thankful for the body they have. If anyone is trapped in their bodies, it's people like me. I've pushed myself further and further away from interacting with trans people because it triggers a lot of negative emotions about my own five years of identifying as a male and my own different perspective on trans people generally. I have a friend I've been close with for about seven years who has supported me through all my decisions regarding my gender presentation; she goes to school in another state and comes back in the summer, and this year she's bringing her new trans boyfriend whom I haven't met. I feel turned away from the idea but I've missed her and want to spend time with her, and I also feel concern for the relationship based on what she's shared with me. I am a bisexual woman who has romantically dated men and women, and I think it's likely I'll end up settling down with a woman. I have serious queer relationships and don't appreciate being told I don't belong in queer spaces. From my experience, bisexual people tending toward opposite-sex partners generally comes down to some type of internalized homophobia or not wanting to publicly have a gay relationship — if society didn't treat queer relationships differently than straight relationships, more bisexual people would choose same-sex partners, but a lot of people will choose the easier path when given both options. I now have a boyfriend who is not conservative at all. He fully accepted me because he didn't blame me for the years I spent in a cycle of self-harm; he was impressed with my honesty and my ability to be critical of myself and my choices and to admit I was wrong even after my experiences and trauma. I believe partners need to be more compatible than friends because they create a life together, and politics are often moral issues that matter for long-term relationships. I am against women's spaces being for anyone aside from biological females. I don't believe anyone is trans — I think transition is a choice and, for most people, a mistake. I think bringing awareness of what I see as a train wreck of transgender ideology is the best thing we can do to keep other people from making the same mistake, and I feel it's our right as detransitioned people to feel however we feel about transgender issues given our lived experience. I would never advise someone to alter their body in ways that could have complications and regret the way medical transition does, especially anything surgical; my advice to younger people is to wait until their brain is more developed and they have more adult life experience before making medical decisions, because so many people live with crippling regret. I also feel that people end up giving themselves issues that could have been avoided if they'd been treated differently or understood the gravity of their choices at the time. I've told a young person considering transition that it's okay to change your mind later and to try to love yourself where you are.