Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich ongeveer zeven jaar als trans identificeerde, begon als FTM op mijn 17e en me later als non-binair identificeerde, en ik heb nu diagnoses van BPS, autisme en trauma waarvan ik geloof dat ze verweven waren met mijn genderdysforie. Ik ervaar mijn medische transitie en het door artsen en leeftijdsgenoten opgedrongen 'born in the wrong body'-verhaal als blijvend trauma dat mij en mijn familie achtervolgt, en ik heb het contact met de meeste van mijn online vrienden moeten verbreken omdat ze me daarover gaslighten. Ik blijf vervreemd van de transgemeenschap, die volgens mij haar rug naar me toekeerde, en ik vind detransitie-onderwerpen triggerend maar waardeer ook ruimtes waar onze ervaringen worden gehoord. Ik ben zeer kritisch over medische transitie bij minderjarigen en vergelijk het met grooming, terwijl ik probeer geen hele groepen te demoniseren. Ik werk eraan me te verzoenen met mijn lichaam en de aangerichte schade, al weet ik niet hoe lang het gaat duren om dit van me af te schudden.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and identified as trans for about seven years, starting as FTM and later shifting to a nonbinary identity when I felt the same way about men as I did about women — that I just didn't fit in. I was a mentally ill 17-year-old when I was convinced I needed to inject permanent, body-changing hormones to finally love my body. Doctors, and the trans people around me, agreed with the idea that I was born in the wrong body; they played into it, and I believed my body was a curse. Every menstrual cycle felt like a reminder that my body wasn't how it was meant to be. My mother loved me and supported me because she was convinced by doctors and people around her that I could kill myself if she didn't — I'm terrified she'll blame herself, though I know it's not her fault and not mine.
I have BPD, autism, and trauma, and I now recognize how easily those can be misdiagnosed as gender dysphoria, and how dangerous it is for someone with BPD to start HRT so soon. I also see gender nonconformity having been folded into 'nonbinary,' which is a real problem when it comes to medical transition, especially for autistic people who often feel isolated from everyone else. I consider what happened to me literal trauma that will stick with me the rest of my life and will haunt my family. I've been reconciling with the alienation of being a detransitioner — a community I'm far removed from, one that turned its back on me and won't accept me because I'm a bad look for them. On Trans Day of Visibility it was all over my social media, a constant reminder of that, and of the damage I believe this movement has done to me and others.
I had a long, hours-long discussion with my partner about my views and experiences with gender, and at one point I broke down crying when he pointed out how badly I still talk about my parts and body. I don't know how long it will take me to shake the mentality that was drilled into me, or if I ever will. I've tried to voice my concerns and my detransition experience gently to trans friends, sugar-coating it when the time felt right, but recently I had to cut off nearly all of my online friends because they became hostile about the topic — I won't associate with people who gaslight me or place the blame on me for my traumatic experience. I find it difficult to discuss my experiences in leftist spaces too (I'm a commie/marxist), so I keep to myself. The only trans spaces open to discussing detransitioners that I've found are transmedicalist spaces, which I find hostile and unhealthy. Videos and comments about detransition topics are triggering for me because of what people say about us, though I was refreshed to see people actually looking at what we go through and speaking up.
I'm critical of medical transition for minors: I compare it to grooming, arguing that if minors can't consent to other things because they can't comprehend consequences, HRT and SRS — permanently life-altering things — shouldn't be different, especially when minors are encouraged that it's what will 'fix' them. I also push back against blanket demonization of men, noting that even though statistically 98% of shooters are men, that doesn't make men inherently evil. I made a post about my experience with detransition and pinned it to my profile so others could understand what someone in my position goes through.