Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een therapeute in Ontario, Canada, getrouwd met een man, met een masterdiploma in mijn vakgebied. Ik heb in deze berichten niet beschreven dat ik zelf ben getransitioneerd of gedetransitioneerd; in plaats daarvan ben ik een actieve, kritische stem op r/detrans, die verkennende therapeuten aanbeveelt (beyondtrans.org, therapyfirst.org), CGT gericht op OCD, en bronnen zoals het Cass-rapport en de WPATH Files. Ik heb betoogd dat trans „een keuze” is, dat sociale besmetting de stijgende transidentificatie onder tieners aandrijft en dat sociale transitie en het wisselen van voornaamwoorden niet neutraal zijn. Ik ben kritisch over genderbevestigende zorg, over activisten die therapeuten en advocaten beïnvloeden en over professionals die een „leef of sterf”-framing gebruiken, en ik heb overwogen een blog te schrijven over de tegenreactie die ik kreeg omdat ik therapie voorstelde voor een 13-jarige. Ik heb geen persoonlijke spijt, zelfbeschadiging of suïcidale gedachten gemeld.
Volledig verhaal
I am a therapist working in Ontario, Canada, and I hold a master's degree in my field — I once had to write a paper about my own experience of gender as part of my master's program, and my professor pointed out that I never defined what a woman is. That moment stayed with me and shaped how I think about gender questions now.
I am married to a husband; we have had numerous conversations about the inadequacy of pockets in women's pants, and I wear capris under my skirt, including swim pants that help keep me cool when wet on hot days. I have a family cultural nickname I have used since childhood, and as an adult I also use an English nickname, which my family uses when they meet my friends.
I broke my wrist in early 2024, which limited my typing for a while and delayed plans I had to write posts on coping with gender dysphoria. I have a phone call scheduled with a lead researcher on treatment of gender dysphoria, because most training I have seen focuses on treating comorbidities without directly treating gender dysphoria, and I want to ask questions about that.
I have been very active in the r/detrans community, offering therapeutic-style advice, resources, and referrals. I regularly recommend directories such as beyondtrans.org and therapyfirst.org for finding therapists who explore rather than push. I have recommended CBT for body dysmorphic disorder (the Wilhelm/Phillips/Steketee treatment manual), Dr. Tracy Marks' YouTube videos on intrusive thoughts and Pure O, Therapy in a Nutshell for OCD and cognitive defusion, DBT for coping with distressing emotions, the downward arrow technique for uncovering core beliefs, values checklists from ACT, and articles on internal versus external validation and on 'should' statements.
I have a professional interest in OCD and its overlap with gender concerns: I have said that body dysmorphia is a subtype of OCD and the type most similar to gender dysphoria, that there is 'transgender OCD' (a fear of being trans), and that autism tends to obsess over special interests while OCD obsesses over fears. I have cited research suggesting 33% of those with gender dysphoria have autism and that it should be routinely screened for. I have repeatedly suggested people see an OCD therapist, a sex therapist, or consider anti-depressants, and I have noted that looking for reassurance ultimately makes anxiety worse.
I have been critical of gender-affirming care and of trans activism's influence on professionals. I have said that denial of reality is a symptom of some mental health conditions, that social contagion explains the increase in trans teens and young adults, that switching pronouns and social transition are not neutral and significantly impact identity and development, and that children aren't capable of understanding these issues so the focus should be on educating adults. I have shared the WPATH Files, the Cass report, the NYT opinion piece on people who detransitioned, an FP article on dangers of transition in Finland, and Mayo Clinic pages on puberty blockers and hormone risks. I have said that any professional using a 'live or die' option should be reported for malpractice, that vulnerable people are less likely to report to ethics boards or file lawsuits, and that trans activist groups have 'educated' therapists and lawyers in ways that have caused numerous problems. I got extremely downvoted on a therapist subreddit for suggesting therapy for a 13-year-old and was accused of not being a therapist because GAC is 'life saving care'; I have been thinking of writing a blog about it. I have also noted that some detrans people have found lawyers to help with lawsuits.
I have described trans as actually being a choice — 'a choice to live according to how someone feels' — and that the choice to detrans is complicated because people often still feel the same but make a different choice. I have cited Zucker 2021 showing that boys who aren't socially transitioned mostly grow out of gender dysphoria in their teen years, and argued that there is evidence that not transitioning can be more beneficial than transitioning. I have said the results on transition as treatment 'aren't impressive.'
I have experience with therapy from the professional side and have been sympathetic to people who had bad therapists, saying that manipulating vulnerable people is fairly easy and that telling someone what to do is not within ethical standards. I have also noted that a client's therapist and psychiatrist had contact with WPATH, and I was curious what WPATH said to them. I have suggested that someone whose birth name causes dissociation should explore that with a good therapist.
I have been open about my own views on self-acceptance: I have asked people what it would take to accept themselves instead of thinking they need to modify something, and I have said I find it curious that trans/detrans individuals seem to have a strong focus on altering the body, and that learning to let go of control and focusing on self-acceptance is equally valid. I have also said that I don't know what will make my clients happy, but I can usually figure out what therapy questions to ask to help them understand who they are and what they need.
I have commented on confidence and validation, arguing that people sometimes underestimate how confidence impacts treatment from others, and that confident people set boundaries and don't tolerate poor treatment. I have also cautioned people not to generalize their own experience to others, noting I know men who have never experienced attraction to women and are attracted to men.
I have been cautious about commenting on posts with vent flairs because I don't want to upset anyone, and I have appreciated having a flair that identifies me as a therapist so my feedback might be more helpful. I have also said I'd like to talk further with people in Ontario about education policy, mentioning a previous education minister who was a lesbian and changed how teachers approach these issues.
I have not described undergoing any transition myself, nor any detransition, in this transcript. My engagement with the community appears to be as a therapist offering guidance rather than as someone recounting a personal transition or detransition story.