Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een cis lesbienne die in 1978 uit de kast kwam en in 1979 op mijn 19e naar MichFest ging, een ervaring die mijn feminisme voor het leven heeft gevormd. In 1979 werd ik door een man verkracht en gewurgd en ik ben meermaals aangevallen omdat ik lesbisch ben. Ik ben scherp kritisch op wat ik zie als seksistische, regressieve trans-ideologie en op autogynefilie, en ik verdedig ruimtes alleen voor vrouwen. Ik heb mezelf nooit als trans geïdentificeerd, maar heb sympathie voor vrouwen die onder sociale druk zijn getransitioneerd, en ik begeleid online actief gedetransitioneerde en gendercritische vrouwen.
Volledig verhaal
I came out as a lesbian in 1978, back when, as I put it, "we could lose our jobs and have our children legally taken from us." I was 19 the first time I attended the Michigan Women's Music Festival (MichFest) in Hesperia in 1979, with 5,000 women there, and I went again in 1985 at the Hart location. That first festival was, in my words, "the best thing I ever experienced in my life" — seeing strong women building outdoor stages, running electricity, playing music, and showering together outdoors with all body types and no shame taught me that female does not equal femininity, and it set me on the road to understanding that sexism was a class problem women needed to fight together.
I have never felt particularly "feminine." I swagger when I walk, I was a good athlete as a kid, and I have only ever loved women. I have explicitly reflected that if I had grown up in today's ideological climate rather than with mentors like the women at MichFest, "would I have thought that made me a man? It is so regressive, but I can see how I might have fallen into that belief as a teen if that was the only ideology I was hearing." I have expressed sympathy for women who transitioned, telling one person, "I assume the pressure to be more masculine or feminine led you down this road in the first place. I am so sorry you didn't have the support and mentors you deserved," and elsewhere, "if I had been born earlier, I might have fallen for it too."
I have experienced serious violence. In 1979 I was raped and strangled by a man who believed I "just hadn't had the right dick yet" — a line I say I have heard dozens of times since. I have also been physically assaulted four times for being a lesbian, in one case beaten up along with three friends (two white women and two black women) by four men. I worked at a publication company in the early 1980s with three other women; a gay man we all trained was paid more than all of us, which crystallized for me that I was "more oppressed by my SEX than my sexuality."
I have been openly critical of what I call "trans ideology," arguing it is sexist and regressive, putting people into boxes based on stereotypes ("If a woman is strong and successful, she must be a man"). I lived with a transwoman for years who I said "believed in stereotypes, it was like being in the 1950s." I have been sharply critical of autogynephilia, saying "the AGPs are raving narcissists and have the most regressive/sexist attitudes I have ever encountered." I have also described an experience where a friend involved in an "inclusive" replacement festival found a transwoman's site "riddled with cum shots" and identified her as an obvious AGP, after which the transwoman threatened the friend with "I know where you work."
On healthcare, I have tried for six to ten years to get insurance to cover a breast reduction for documented back pain, rashes, and permanent bra strap indents, only to have it denied as "merely cosmetic" — while a roommate who came out as mtf less than six months earlier had breast implants approved as "medically necessary" under the same plan. I have framed this as an example of women being treated as less worthy.
I came out 40 years ago (as of late 2022) and identify as a cis lesbian. I am active in defending women-only spaces, MichFest, and lesbians, and I have been vocal about threats and hatred directed at lesbians from both the political right and from within queer-identified spaces, saying "The most dangerous place for a lesbian today is at a pride march." I am critical of bathroom policies that include biological males, arguing there should be male, female, and unisex options, and I have called out casual homophobia when I see it. I do not describe myself as detransitioned in this transcript; I appear to be an older lesbian offering mentorship and perspective to detransitioned and gender-critical communities.