Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde man die zich nu agender identificeert, nadat ik ben gaan geloven dat het denken dat ik trans was mijn dysforie veroorzaakte. Ik werd beïnvloed om me als trans te identificeren door het browsen op r/egg_irl, en ik stopte met geloven in gender zelf, waardoor mijn dysforie verdween. Ik richtte r/Scrambled_Eggs_irl op als omgekeerde egg-memegemeenschap en vergelijk transideologie vaak met religie en sektes, waarbij ik Steven Hassans BITE-model aanhaal als iets wat op mij van toepassing was. Ik ben sceptisch over onderzoek naar bevestigende zorg en detransitiestatistieken, en ben politiek meer centristisch geworden. Ik heb een partner en kom ermee overweg door memes te maken.
Volledig verhaal
I created r/Scrambled_Eggs_irl in early June 2021, a meme subreddit that works like egg_irl but in reverse, and I started crossposting to the detrans community because making fun of myself in memes is how I deal with my feelings — they let out pent-up feelings remarkably well. I'm a desisted male. I don't have a gender, so I use agender for myself.
My central claim, which I've repeated many times, is that thinking I may be trans is what gave me dysphoria in the first place. I got brainwashed into thinking I was trans by browsing r/egg_irl, where they suggest that very common things make you think you are trans. In my experience the belief you are the wrong gender for your body can be a trigger for dysphoria, and when you stop believing it, it goes away a lot — once I stopped believing in gender it went away. I don't think innate gender is a real thing for humans; to me gender is a role, like a character role which I practice daily, and the more you practice the more confidence you have in it. What made me realize gender isn't intrinsic was observing r/agender, where people claim to have none. Once you start to doubt your identity you can form a new one, and since you're forming it in a trans-positive space you're likely to acquire a new trans identity.
I've thought a lot about how this happens and I compare it to religion and cults. I posted about Steven Hassan's BITE model of cult mind control and said the thought-control and emotional-control sections applied to me when I was identifying as trans. I've described gender transition as being a lot like a religious experience where you seek out and find your 'true self,' with lots of euphoria and self-discovery, but only because it's selling you a solution to a problem it itself created. I've compared the trans community to Jehovah's Witnesses repeatedly, and I've noted that a lot of detrans people immediately become religious after detransitioning — it's like they have to plug the religious hole in their heart left from the trans ideology, and I warn that people exiting cults often join others to fill that hole. I've also said the internet has enabled decentralized cults like QAnon, where you don't need a centralized censoring force if it censors itself.
I'm skeptical of the medical and research side. I've posted that the evidence in favor of affirmative care is very shallow and based on esteem theory, which failed to replicate during the replication crisis. I've shared studies on detransition rates — including a Cambridge University study finding a minimum 6.9% detrans rate among UK gender clinic patients — and I've argued the reported 'detrans rate' doesn't mean much anyway, comparing it to Jehovah's Witnesses having a 0.3% deconversion rate: it just means those people are still trapped in that mindset. I've cited research suggesting the average time to detransition is around 5 to 6.5 years, implying people spend considerable time transitioning before realizing it wasn't what they wanted. I've also argued that people reach their goal and realize they overhyped it in their head — during transition you keep telling yourself one more surgery will make you happy, and then it's basically nothing interesting and you sacrificed everything to get there.
I've engaged with psychological concepts like the nocebo effect, the placebo effect, and the Barnum effect, posting videos demonstrating how the nocebo effect can cause real physical pain and how you can cause euphoria with nothing but a cup of water and conformity. I've argued transition can help people the way essential oils 'help' people — 100% placebo, high approval rate because people believe in it. I've also posted about comorbidity conditions among detrans people and about false memories of self-identity from a Mind Field episode.
On bodies and gender roles, I've posted that wanting to be bulky isn't proof of being trans, it's proof society has a narrow view of acceptable bodies for each sex — lift weights and bulk up if you want to. I've said the male body has been portrayed as the 'gross and gritty' body while women are portrayed as beautiful and desirable, and men who feel ugly may envy women because they want to be the center of attention and be pretty. I've also noted from a biology perspective that males are more expendable evolutionarily.
I've become more politically centrist over time and I'm not a rightist — I'm just a person who was misled. I've said once you see through the illusion it's kind of ruined and gets very creepy, like growing up Christian and realizing the church is wrong about God. I've told people that when you stop believing you are the wrong gender, the dysphoria weakens until it dies. I've also posted reading recommendations on combating undue influence in your own life, which I started listening to on Audible, and I've noted the shrooms thing seems very common among people questioning their identity.
I have a partner. I occasionally go out in drag. I describe myself as a chronic worrier. I've said I don't have the answers but wish I did. I've posted 'A note to my past self' and memes comforting people who feel like they lost themselves to transition — 'you are still you no matter what.'