Alle verhalen

Twee jaar gatekeeping stopte de hormonen, en de dysforie

Man · Gedesisteerd246
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde (nooit gemedicaliseerde) man in de dertig uit Uruguay die zich in 2020–2021 identificeerde als pre-transitie transvrouw voordat ik het roer omgooide. Ik begrijp mijn cross-gender gedachten nu als voortkomend uit een levenslange crossdress-/autogynefiele fetisj, chronische angst met wortels in mishandeling in mijn vroege kindertijd en obsessieve gedachten over seksuele ontoereikendheid, en niet uit een echte mismatch van innerlijke sekse. Ik heb nooit cross-sekse hormonen genomen vanwege de strikte 2-jarige gatekeeping in mijn land en zorgen over gezondheidsrisico's, en de genderdysforie die ik kort ontwikkelde is verdwenen. Ik zie genderdysforie en genderideologie nu als sociaal geconstrueerde, religie-achtige overtuigingen en pleit tegen medische transitie voor anderen. Mijn huidige identiteit is die van een gedetransitioneerde heteroseksuele man die zijn fetisj accepteert en zich op zijn gemak voelt bij gendernonconformiteit zonder labels.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and from a very young age I felt different from other boys — less assertive, bad at sports, and bullied at school. My early childhood was traumatic: between the ages of 2 and 5 a babysitter, who had me during the day while both parents worked full time, beat me violently for a couple of years. One of my therapists later suggested this violence left me chronically anxious, with bouts of anxiety that explain my chronic insomnia. My father has some form of bipolar disorder but has never seen a therapist because he believes therapists are 'for girls'; he was violent when I was young and I vividly remember him beating my mother. My parents eventually divorced, which traumatized me further, and we moved frequently so I never formed deep friendships. I spent my childhood and teens isolated in my own world of video games and science books. During my teenage years I noticed other teenagers getting interested in sex and pornography and felt very uncomfortable: I never had sexual interest in another person. I am now over 30 and have still never felt sexual attraction to another person. I first considered being gay, but I was not attracted to males, so I settled on being a heterosexual uninterested in sex — an identification that made less sense by my mid-20s. Meanwhile my libido was in full bloom, and I realized it was self-directed: I had a cross-dressing fetish involving pantyhose, heels, corsets, and breast forms. My first erotic crossdressing experience was at age 13, wearing my sister's shoes; it felt intensely erotic and I understood it was something I must never tell anyone about — it took nearly 20 years before I admitted it to anybody, even anonymously online. I developed the idea of being transgender after watching the movie Transamerica as a teenager, when I noticed the trans woman lead was supposedly a virgin in her 30s. I was terrified the character would be like me — sexually inverted and unable to feel attraction — which would mean I was a transsexual too; but the film never discussed her sexuality, so I felt relieved I was not trans because 'it was not a sexual thing.' I first researched transgender topics online from 2016 to 2017, around the same time I adopted an asexual identity, largely so I could explain to people why I had no girlfriend and no interest in going out drinking. I noticed the transgender scientific literature is oddly Anglo-American and Western, which suggested to me that culture plays an important role in transgender identification. I also learned Ray Blanchard and Kurt Freund's concept of Erotic Target Location Error, which explained my inverted sexuality, and later scored 100% on their paraphilia tests for fetishism, autogynephilia, and transvestism — though I did not identify with most people claiming to be transsexuals at the time. Then came the 2020 COVID lockdown. Being asexual and single, I felt very lonely and spent too much time online reading claims from the transgender community. My mental stability began to break apart; my inverted sexuality, always a deep issue, became more pronounced as I reflected on aging with no prospect of a normal sexual life. I read accounts of trans people who said they were autogynephiles unable to feel attraction to others, but who after transitioning could have normal relationships. That made my brain short-circuit: maybe my sexual inversion was because I was deep down a woman who needed cross-sex hormones to function sexually normally? I decided I would become a transwoman to cure my erotic target location error. I began talking to gender therapists and exploring this topic and its connection to my paraphilia. At first I identified as a pre-transition transwoman. My gender therapist described the symptoms of gender dysphoria, and after a few weeks I began feeling all of them — it was like magic. I had never felt anything was wrong with my body before, but almost instantly I became disgusted by the large size of my hands, ribcage, and arms, and felt sad when a grocery-store cashier called me 'sir.' I recognized I had managed to develop gender dysphoria out of my own obsessive-compulsive thoughts about feelings of sexual inadequacy. Thankfully, my country (Uruguay) has stricter gatekeeping than the US: a patient needs 2 years of specialized psychological counseling before starting hormones and surgery. I was informed of the serious health risks of these treatments, and my therapists told me they advise radical medicalization only in extreme cases, preferring to fix issues of the mind before tinkering with the body. I also began carefully considering the social realities of living as a transsexual woman. Over about a year I read extensively on gender identity disorder and reached a definitive conclusion: GID is a social construct, something society invented to medicalize gender non-conforming people. As a rational person I understood that cross-sex hormones would not cure autogynephilia and turn it into normal sexuality — they only lower libido while sexual orientation stays the same. Cross-sex hormones are no cure for autogynephilia, which I now consider a normal sexual orientation in some men. After that year I overcame the period of deep uncertainty; even though I was never medicalized, for a few months I had felt I was surely on track to sex reassignment. Now I understand I am not a typical heterosexual man but someone with ETLE, and that is okay — it does not mean I need medicalization or must conform to the stereotype of having a sexual relationship. The feelings of disgust and distress regarding my masculinity vanished; I concluded that distress regarding one's natural anatomy is socially constructed. Although I never started cross-sex hormones, I was on the track to do so within the 2-year gatekeeping window (had I been in the US I would have been taking hormones for nearly a year), so I consider myself detrans. Reading stories of informed-consent clinics in the US gave me relief that I was not born in a country that fast-tracks gender-questioning people to hormones. Since detransitioning I feel comfort in knowing I have a fetish and that I have actualized my fetishistic dreams as well as current technology for costumes and external latex prosthetics allows — I like wearing corsets and breast forms. Because I know I have these 'toys,' I do not feel the need to constantly wear them; on average I wear them once a week, which I consider the rational approach. I also came to believe that gender ideology is essentially a religious belief system: I was convinced it was real for years, then did my research and figured out it is a belief in an inner essence misaligned with the body, a Greco-Roman-Christian metaphysical idea rather than a scientific one. I compare gender dysphoria to anorexia — a culturally constructed mental illness in which people channel distress into perceived inadequacy about sex characteristics rather than body mass, a phenomenon that did not exist a thousand years ago. I have argued publicly that cross-sex hormones are cosmetic experimentation with severe health risks and no robust RCT evidence of benefit, that gender dysphoria is not a well-defined condition, and that taking HRT purely for cosmetic reasons is very stupid. I also believe crossdressing fetishism is common in heterosexual men (3–5%) and explains roughly 80–90% of male-to-female cases today, with late-onset cases (developing cross-gender identity after 30) being close to 100% erotic cross-dressers. I did not take hormones because I read about their health risks, side effects of lowered libido, and possible negative cognitive effects — and because the type of crossdressing I enjoy would look ludicrous in public even on a woman. I now advocate for accepting reality and ourselves as individuals so we can stop feeling the need to use labels.