Alle verhalen

Nooit getransitioneerd — maar toch op r/detrans beland

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd765
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde... nee — ik ben een gendernonconforme vrouw die nooit getransitioneerd is, en ik kwam op r/detrans als gender-kritische supporter om mensen die detransitie overwegen of doormaken aan te moedigen. Ik betoogde dat sekse onveranderlijk is, dat dysforie net als andere lichaamsdysmorfieën met therapie behandeld moet worden, en dat medische transitie (zeker voor minderjarigen) overhaast is en slecht onderbouwd. Ik vertelde dat ik op jongere leeftijd mijn voornaam op mijn geboorteakte sociaal veranderde en later terugzette, een pijnlijke breuk meemaakte en een therapeut zag die me hielp mezelf capabel te voelen. Ik verdedigde de moderators van de sub tegen wat ik sektarische, onethische bans noemde, en ik blijf detransitioners steunen terwijl ik me verzet tegen medische transitie van kinderen. Ik heb zelf geen spijt over mijn lichaam of identiteit; mijn grootste verdriet is hoe de medische industrie kwetsbare mensen in de steek laat.

Volledig verhaal

I am a woman — an adult female human — and I have never transitioned myself; I came to the r/detrans community as a gender critical (GC) feminist who wanted to offer support to people detransitioning. I was born female and have always identified as female, though I describe myself as gender non-conforming: I like building things, I am the boss at work, I wear masculine clothes, and I don't act feminine at all. I don't worry about labelling myself, because for me sex is a biological fact rather than a feeling. I first became active in these discussions in June 2020, arguing with a trans advocate who I felt was being cruel to detransitioners. My core position is that sex is immutable, that every other form of body dysmorphia (anorexia, BIID, BDD) is treated with therapy rather than surgery, and that gender dysphoria should be treated the same way — with kind, humane support to help people accept their bodies. I was particularly critical of medical transition for children, pointing to research suggesting only about 15% of childhood gender dysphoria persists into adulthood, and I repeatedly criticised a widely cited study on medical transition as poorly designed (no control group, self-reported outcomes, no control for comorbid psychiatric illness, convenience sample). I also engaged with people who described autogynephilia (AGP) as a motivation for transition, arguing that a fetish should not be the basis for irreversible bodily changes, while still saying adults should be legally free to do what they want with their own bodies if they pay for it. I pushed back hard on an incel activist who was messaging people a 'manifesto' arguing incels should transition to get partners and that they hated women — I stopped engaging with them once I read it. I was clear about my own position in the community: I said I don't post or comment on r/detrans except to offer words of support or gently correct misinformation, because I know nothing about the specific experience of detransitioning. I explicitly said GC people should stay out of detrans spaces otherwise, and that detransitioners and trans people need their own space free of GC opinions. I supported the sub's rules about tone rather than policing who is or isn't a detransitioner, and I worried that accepting posts from people claiming to be medical professionals could turn the sub into a brigaded debate forum and risk getting it banned. I offered practical and emotional support to many people considering or going through detransition: encouraging therapy (especially CBT), warning against getting trapped in online transition bubbles, telling people they don't owe their families or communities an explanation, and reframing 'The Gender Disaster' as a normal life experience that people grow from. I shared that I had changed the name on my birth certificate socially when I was younger and later changed it back, and that I had recently gone through a painful breakup with a partner and started seeing a therapist who helped me see I'm powerful and capable on my own. I also mentioned having a 'fairly plain/ugly face' that used to make me unhappy until I worked through those feelings rather than getting surgery, and that I've had some success with home IPL for dark body hair. I was a vocal defender of the sub's moderators when they banned a popular mod in July 2020, saying it felt like they were 'running this sub like a cult' and calling the moderators' handling of the situation 'completely unethical and wrong'. I also asked whether it was acceptable to post an Abigail Shrier/Posie Parker interview, and agreed not to post it when others raised concerns about giving bad-faith actors ammunition. I don't regret anything about my own identity or body — I've never wanted to change either. My main sorrow, as I put it, is 'the way the medical industry fails people who are vulnerable'. I remain supportive of detransitioners as people, critical of medical transition especially for minors, and I continue to believe the kindest thing is to help people love and accept the bodies they were born with while being free to dress and present however they want.