Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die ongeveer acht jaar als trans leefde en die ervaring nu omschrijft als het verlaten van een sekte. Ik ben autistisch en geloof dat mijn moeite om contact te maken met mannelijkheid en andere mannen bijdroeg aan mijn transitie, die me nooit compleet deed voelen als vrouw. Ik stopte met HRT nadat ik besefte dat ik vóór HRT veel gelukkiger was geweest en dat het me dood deed voelen; mijn lichaam geneest nu en ik voel me tevreden. Ik voel me psychologisch misbruikt door de „koste wat het kost”-steundynamiek van de transgemeenschap, die ik vergelijk met het stockholmsyndroom, en ik geloof nu dat mensen hun geboortegeslacht zouden moeten omarmen in plaats van te transitioneren. Ik vind dat transitie niet zou moeten bestaan, vooral niet voor kinderen, al steun ik het recht van transmensen om te bestaan.
Volledig verhaal
I spent about eight years involved in what I now describe as a cult — the transgender community — and leaving it has felt like walking out of a cult, though I'll admit I enjoyed parts of it while I was in. I was born male, and my body has been developing as male since the womb, with male genitals, chromosomes and bones; that reality is something I now accept rather than fight.
I was autistic, and that shaped a lot of my experience. I've always found it hard to connect with other people of my same gender, and I felt separated from masculinity in a way that felt humiliating rather than liberating. Seeing trans women triggered sensory issues for me — it made me feel less like a man, and I felt I couldn't criticize or dislike it because of the cultural moment we're in, which sent me into obsessive loops over the whole matter. I now think that feeling separated from masculinity or femininity is fairly common among autistic people.
Transitioning did not make me feel complete as a woman. I was on HRT, and for a long time I was afraid to admit to myself that I had been much happier before it — that it kind of made me feel dead compared to before. I finally admitted that to myself, and since stopping, my body is healing and I'm pretty satisfied with how things are going. I don't recall stating specific dates for when I started or stopped hormones, or whether I had any surgeries, so I'll leave those details out.
What moved me toward detransition was a mix of self-reflection and reading. I came across an old post by a post-op trans woman who regretted SRS, in which she said other post-op trans women glorified SRS as a way of coping with their own bad decision — that they lied about being happy because they wanted to feel less alone in their suffering. I started applying that logic to HRT too: I think many people lie about being happy on it as a means of coping with what they've done to themselves. I also read about a post-op trans woman who regretted surgery and believed others lied about being happy for similar reasons.
I also came to see the community dynamics as psychologically abusive. The strange part is that the only people who have been sweet and nice to me about what I did while identifying as trans is the trans community itself — which left me feeling alone, like the only people who understand me are the same people who would tell me to transition at all costs while my life got turned upside down. I described that dynamic as involving Stockholm syndrome and 'god level manipulation tactics.' I said I mean 'cult' partly as a compliment — I can acknowledge their power and influence while choosing to take care of myself. I'll miss the cult; they're kind of cool, but manipulative and sick.
I've also reflected on the paranoia trans people develop — being vigilant everywhere for people reckless toward transness, blocking possible threats — and suggested maybe they should just detransition and be free. I think the trans community is also a convenient scapegoat for people managing their own bitterness and anger, and I don't want them to stop existing: trans people deserve to exist, but I wouldn't recommend that life. I'm not against the idea of transition existing as a legal option, but I do think it became a market that exploits the vulnerable. My core view now is that it's always better to embrace the gender compatible with your whole body — you'll be happier living as your birth sex than chasing the impossible, since transgender people are usually unhappy with their incomplete bodies. For kids especially, I think the damage is severe.
I've been blunt online about this: 'A penis is a penis ya know sweetie.' I feel I've learned to love myself again and no longer want to be a cult member.