Alle verhalen

Tweeënhalf jaar oestrogeen om te leren dat er niets veranderde

Man · GedetransitioneerdEerste dysforie 19 → Transitie 22 → Detransitie 24817
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die als non-binair en daarna als transvrouw identificeerde, ongeveer tweeënhalf jaar oestrogeen en spironolacton nam van mijn 22e tot 24e, en op mijn 24e detransitioneerde na een gezondheidsschrik door anti-androgenen. Ik identificeer me nu als cis man met genderdysforie, en ik heb geen spijt van hormonen omdat ze me lieten zien dat ik in de kern hetzelfde was, ongeacht mijn lichaam. Mijn dysforie verbeterde dramatisch na het detransitioneren, al duikt die af en toe nog op, en ik heb geen significante spijt behalve dat ik soms de feminiene esthetiek mis. Ik ben momenteel 25 (bijna 26), bi (voor de transitie identificeerde ik als homo), lichamelijk gezond, train en ben grotendeels vrij van de obsessie over mijn uiterlijk die mijn leven voor de transitie beheerste. Ik heb kritische opvattingen over transitie als identiteit, non-binaire identiteit en op trans gerichte sociale media, terwijl ik toch erken dat dysforie echt is en dat HRT voor sommige mensen een legitieme behandeling kan zijn.

Volledig verhaal

I never really experienced dysphoria growing up, other than looking up to a group of YouTubers who were all androgynous males who wore makeup and wanting to be like them. I was born male. Around high school I was already fascinated with plastic surgery and had wanted work done. When I was 19 I moved to another city for college and was severely depressed, feeling completely directionless and confused about the path I was taking. One day I looked into Adam's apple reduction surgery and was exposed to facial feminization surgery, and thought that was something I wanted. That led me to discover the transgender community online, and I immediately became convinced I was trans and that transitioning would rid my depression and give my life purpose. I obsessively thought about this for two years before I finally had the courage to start hormones. At the time I identified as nonbinary, but as I started hormones I quickly identified as a woman. I started hormones at 22. I was honestly addicted to the positive attention I was getting as a woman and felt happy every time a straight man hit on me. I later realized my womanhood was largely dependent on straight male validation. The first six months I was living as a trans woman I experienced a lot of harassment, but that went away as estrogen made me more passable. I liked being able to have a feminine aesthetic without ridicule, receiving male attention, that men didn't assume I was attracted to women anymore, and that my ability to connect to men improved because it wasn't in a 'bro to bro' way. I didn't transition because of those reasons; they were just happy consequences. Before I transitioned I identified as gay. After about a year and a half on hormones I started wearing less makeup and more androgynous clothing. My boyfriend, who had previously identified as straight, told me he was bi, which changed my whole view of myself. I slowly stopped hanging out with trans people, started using they/them pronouns again, and came to terms with the fact that I am male and always will be. The next major shift was a health scare. I started having severe symptoms from my spironolactone (testosterone blocker) and after researching learned how dangerous a drug it is. I went to the hospital out of fear for my health. I talked to my doctor about switching blockers; the one she prescribed (finasteride) also has severe symptoms, and she said she didn't prescribe bicalutamide because of side effects, which I found odd given how many side effects spironolactone has. I couldn't stand antiandrogens anymore. Injections weren't an option for me and you can't really do oral estrogen by itself, so my options were estrogen injections hoping they'd block T by themselves, or bottom surgery. I didn't want an orchiectomy because that sounded emotionally exhausting. I just accepted that looking like a man was worth feeling better. I decided to embrace the full package of being a man. I weaned off estrogen over the course of about a month and a half. I went from man to NB to trans girl, but part of what inspired my detransition was admitting you can't change your gender, so nonbinary wasn't a stepping stone on the way back because I don't think it's real. I stopped hormones at 24, after about two and a half years of HRT. Detransition side effects I experienced: night sweats from dropping estrogen, hot flashes, fatigue, moodiness, and what I called a 'third puberty' — acne, crazy horniness, anger, and moodiness; I felt like a 16-year-old again. My pheromones became masculine very quickly and my breasts (probably only an A cup at their largest) halved in size in the past month and a half. I already 'stink like a boy' — I used to be able to go without deodorant for a day or two. After a few months off I bounced right back to being full of testosterone. My penis is back to the size it was before hormones, and I never had trouble getting erections while on hormones. I'm ten months off hormones now and besides some persistent breast fat I look and feel like before HRT. I started working out as soon as I went off hormones and I think it gave me a helpful boost of testosterone. My face softened and feminized on hormones with fat distribution to my cheeks; it isn't entirely reverted, but I look essentially the same as I did at 22 — it's kind of like my aging process froze for a few years. I'm 25 (almost 26) now. Going cold turkey can make you really depressed for a while, which might increase the chance of going back on estrogen to feel normal again; I have a hard time climbing out of depression, which is part of my cautiousness about others tapering. On therapy: I've been to therapy in the past, but the only time I talked about being trans was to a therapist I saw twice for the exclusive purpose of getting a letter to take hormones, and I don't think she was convinced by my story. I started really thinking therapy was the right course of action for me during detransition. My parents never expected me to be anyone but myself, but since my dad was almost never home I felt I couldn't rely on a man and therefore couldn't rely on myself. The rocky relationship I had with my dad growing up has since been completely fixed. On dysphoria: I had horrible dysphoria when I was 19 and was convinced the only way to fix it was through hormones. Before I thought I was trans I had mild dysphoria, but after I decided I was trans my dysphoria became horrible and I was obsessed with figuring out what gender I was. After two years on hormones I realized I was still obsessing over my appearance — the more feminine I looked the more shame I felt around my masculine qualities. Transitioning legitimized my dysphoria instead of helping me grow past it. I reluctantly made the decision to detransition and actually found my dysphoria drastically improved. I detransitioned nine months ago as of January 2021, and while I still have dysphoria here and there, for the most part I don't think about it. Four months after stopping I had no regrets at all and found it easier to love myself. I still have dysphoria, and it can be hard sometimes, but it no longer has power over me in the same way. I also noted that while transitioning in some ways helped my dysphoria, in other ways it made it worse — there is no end result of HRT where dysphoria is finally gone, and the initial excitement can be replaced with frustration. It's a catch-22: you don't realize transitioning isn't what you think it is unless you do it, but by then you have irreversible changes you may regret. I discovered things about being perceived as a woman in public: when you're a woman you can never be invisible. Sometimes that's nice — living in the anonymity of the city can be lonely and the attention helps combat that — but it's often annoying. I found myself policing my body language more, was more nervous around men, and couldn't ride the bus or go to the bank without being self-conscious that a guy might hit on me or be a creep. I always had the privilege that if I was too emotionally tired to handle that I could just go in 'guy mode.' On regret: I don't regret going on hormones, because doing so made me realize I was fundamentally the same no matter what I did to my body, and that I needed to focus on unconditionally accepting myself instead of changing myself with hormones. I still get sad every once in a while that I'm not as cute or attractive as I was a few months ago, but I realized I was just looking at femininity as a standard for attractiveness — I think this comes down to our cultural understanding of men being the 'base' human with women as beautiful accessories, which skewed my idea of attractiveness in favor of femininity. I'm trying to retrain myself to acknowledge that beauty isn't gendered and that detransitioning has no impact on my attractiveness. I recently started finding my broad shoulders attractive for the first time since I first thought I was trans five years ago. Off hormones I'm way hairier now and I've been working out and getting muscles; while I sometimes miss the skinny feminine aesthetic, it's really not that big of a deal. I definitely present more masculine now that I'm off estrogen, but largely just because I'm having fun with it. Sexuality: before transitioning I identified as gay; after detransitioning I realized I'm actually bi, which probably played a role. When I first detransitioned and was still presenting femme I still labeled myself as trans on Grindr and said in my bio that I was a guy, and I still got a lot of positive attention. I think the majority of men into trans women are either gay or bi, not straight as I had believed at the beginning of my transition. On Tinder I'd label myself as a guy because most straight men wouldn't be open to a trans woman not on hormones. Current identity and views: I don't identify as a man in an identity sense — I just am one according to our historical understanding of what that means. I took hormones and now I don't. One of the most valuable things I learned from IDing as trans is that worrying about my identity will never make me happy; identity is an illusion. I am 'he' not because of how I feel, but because of my biological reality and other people's ability to perceive that; my sense of self now stems from other things. Detethering my name and pronouns from my identity was a positive turning point. I'm a cis man with gender dysphoria. Being trans is an identity, therefore a choice, whereas gender dysphoria is something without a clear reason. I don't go around feeling bad about my gender any more often than I felt good about being a trans woman. I went from liberal before and during transition to something along the lines of anarchist; I think identity politics are a distraction and part of the reason why so many people transition now. I hope people will realize that hormones and surgery don't change your gender, and that people use those medical tools to express themselves as gender-nonconforming people. I think HRT can help with gender dysphoria — for me the problems were more in identifying as transgender; I abandoned the label and felt liberated, and stopped hormones because of a health scare more than anything else. I'd advise people to stop IDing as trans first and see how that goes before deciding about hormones. I think dysphoria is largely induced by being overwhelmed with puberty. I think gender dysphoria is often caused by overexposure to trans-centered social media and worsens the more you pay attention to it. I don't think you can become female by transitioning. I think most people with gender dysphoria were probably exposed to the wrong sex hormone as a fetus, but having a development atypical for men is not the same as having a female brain; going off estrogen caused a surge in testosterone and actually made me more masculine and heterosexual, so I think these things are malleable and there is no innate gender identity. I don't think nonbinary is real. I think it's important to understand that even if you transition you will still have dysphoria, and that if you don't transition you can deal with your dysphoria in other ways. There is no end point of transitioning because you will always be dissatisfied with how you look if you have an impossible ideal. I believe you have a lot more control over how much your dysphoria affects you than you think. I don't think elective surgery that isn't to improve physical health should be covered by insurance, trans, detrans, or otherwise. I also argued against claims that all men have power over women as a class, and made critical remarks about certain trans community narratives and about how some young trans people model themselves after gay men.