Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde... nee, ik ben een autistische man, man geboren, die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd maar sinds ten minste eind 2024, toen ik 17 was, hevig worstelt met TOCD (transgender-OCD), HOCD en AGP. Ik identificeer me als cisgender heteroseksuele man, al is mijn zelfbeeld extreem instabiel en vrees ik dat ik tot transitie word overgehaald terwijl ik die niet wil. Mijn nood komt voort uit pesten in mijn kindertijd omdat ik gevoelig/onmannelijk was, een afwezige vader en dominante moeder, homofobie/transfobie van mijn ouders, autistische trekken en autogynefiele seksuele fantasieën die ik na twee sessies bewust stopte om te voorkomen dat 'het vrouwelijke deel het overneemt'. Ik heb opdringerige seksuele gedachten waar ik niet van geniet, chronisch laaggradig psychisch ongemak dat ik niet kan benoemen en af en toe suïcidale gedachten die verband houden met de mogelijkheid dat ik word overtuigd dat ik trans ben. Ik ben kritisch over het mainstream transdiscours en de eiercultuur vanwege wat ik zie als gedwongen herclassificatie van leed als lot, terwijl ik mijn eigen seksistische blinde vlekken erken. Ik wil leven als een enigszins gevoelige maar cis man en wiskundig onderzoek doen, en ik vrees dat hard onderdrukken om 'de ultieme cis gast' te worden kan omslaan in een vernederende transitie.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and I am 17 years old as of November 2024, when I first posted about this. English is not my first language. I currently identify as a cisgender heterosexual male, though that identification has become extremely shaky and unstable for me over the past year or so.
My difficulties started long before any of this gender questioning. I was a sensitive kid, not the aggressive macho type, and I had autistic traits that other kids picked up on immediately. Around age eight I was severely bullied by one kid in my class who called me a faggot nonstop and turned all my friends against me; the teachers who watched it happen did nothing. I resisted for a while and eventually just accepted the possibility of actually "being a faggot" — though what I really meant by that was viewing myself under the same prejudice I held toward gay men, which was never about them being attracted to men but about them being more feminine than straight men. I also had a dominant mother and a weak, emotionally absent father throughout my childhood and adolescence, which I believe contributed to my humiliation/femdom pornography addiction — I think I may have been eroticizing how low I felt about myself.
I developed HOCD (homosexual OCD) and dealt with it for a long time. With HOCD, the intrusive scenarios I used as reassurance never really focused on the sexual or romantic relationship with another man, but rather on how I portrayed myself in those scenarios — which was always as a more feminine identity. The only way I could plausibly imagine myself with another man was as a female. I think this is partly because I have an extremely heteronormative mind, heavily influenced by my parents' homophobia and transphobia that I was exposed to from a really young age. At one point I even vowed to myself I would commit suicide if I ever had homosexual or transgender urges. A couple of times I went as far as deciding to come out to my parents as gay, but right after saying "Mom, Dad, I'm gay" I knew I was lying to myself. Being gay wasn't related to my issue at all — I didn't want anything sexual to do with men. Ironically, the most "gay" I felt was when looking at women who appealed to me romantically and sexually. I projected my fear of being transgender onto homosexuality because I didn't even see trans as a real thing back then; I thought of it as a choice some gay people made.
The theme shifted from homosexual to transgender (TOCD). The main reason I started fearing being trans is that I bought into "trans egg" internet culture, which frames transness as a metaphysical internal entity waiting to be discovered. I used to not obsess over this because I confidently believed being trans was 100% a personal choice, but that belief has been completely shaken. The egg metaphor bothers me because I'm afraid the male persona I've identified with for so long was actually just a mask, and that's proving a negative — you simply cannot.
I like girls. I genuinely appreciate them for their beauty, feminine mannerisms and delicate souls. I used this as reassurance against HOCD, but now my brain uses the fact that I find girls cute as proof that maybe I might be trans. Sometimes it's really difficult to tell whether what I experience toward them is attraction or gender envy, and that's one I can't fight because attraction to females has always been very visceral to me. I highly relate to the experience some trans women and AGP-identifying people describe of wanting to "live vicariously through another woman's body." When I reflect on my masturbatory urges related to hyperfeminine bodies — curvy ones with big asses and big tits — I think perhaps there was some envy coupled with the lust. It's less "I wish I was her" and more "I wish I had that body so I didn't have to go after women in real life and could essentially experience both sides of a relationship within myself at the same time."
Here is where the AGP (autogynephilia) lies for me. I once felt extreme pleasure masturbating while fantasizing about being a girl. My mindset was something like "Oh, I can't get bitches so I might as well become my own." I even tried recording myself playing the female role while doing the sexual stuff I'd like a woman to do to me in bed, then tried masturbating to it. I relate to the strong feeling of being two separate people in the same body, as if I knew there was masculinity and femininity in there but it's difficult to tell which one I have the most ownership over. I ceased this behavior after the first two sessions because deep down I intuitively felt that if I didn't stop immediately, the feminine part of me would take over more than I'd like to admit and I'd have a rough time getting the genie back in the bottle.
I've been bullied as a kid for what I believe is mainly autistic and schizophrenic behavior. I have vague memories of being called sensitive by a female friend in fifth grade after crying, but no similar occurrences that I recall. I've been consistently rejected by most girls I've tried to make an advance on for being too ugly, according to them. Even my previous girlfriend told me she'd chosen me because she wanted to give an ugly duckling love. After the pandemic, when I started socializing with school peers again, I felt increasingly uncomfortable with being unmasculine on a psychological level, and even more so after being exposed to transgender content online and witnessing how many AMAB people who were carbon copies of myself had transitioned. I published posts about TOCD on six or seven different subreddits, and on each one at least one transfeminine individual DM'd me saying there was a high degree of similarity to my experience. Some told me to consider transition because it would make me happier; others suggested all my crushes on girls were just gender envy, which felt like a punch in the gut.
I've been in a really dark place after watching a YouTube video about "transmaxxing" — the phenomenon of incel or extremely socially withdrawn males who spend their time gaming and masturbating in their rooms and eventually seek transition as a means of attaining embodiment of their love for femininity and a gateway from being a failed male. I couldn't relate more. It's not that becoming a girl is something I particularly crave, but the feelings of being unmasculine have always been there. I long for a positive male role model who's been through the same experiences so I can build a masculine identity that makes me feel whole again, but none seem to exist — everyone who shares my specific life experiences and has found peace with their identity is now a trans woman, and those who haven't are socially withdrawn males like me. To get the feeling of having a masculine identity I usually resort to toxic masculinity behavior and try to enjoy "being the villain" for people who deem me as a non-male. I place a lot of value on people's opinions regarding my gender.
I'm stuck in an awkward place between genders where I don't want to be a girl but feel like I don't have what it takes to be a man. I might as well label myself as some sort of male with a defect on masculinity, which is frankly what I see AGP as — a way to acknowledge feelings of inadequacy about not feeling "male enough" without fully giving up my sense of self, like a tree trunk sticking out of the walls of an abyss.
I have OCD and have had trans women personally tell me I'll end up feeling dysphoria and transitioning someday based on personal accounts I've given them. The mere possibility is overwhelming. I've also been exposed to MtF-in-denial memes and stories that depict the "chestburster" aspect of transition as a destiny one shouldn't run from unless they want to intentionally suffer by repressing uncontrollable transsexual desires arising from a genetic predisposition. It seems nonsensical to worry about, but it successfully gets to me.
I have intrusive thoughts I don't enjoy — sometimes when my father comes to my bed while I'm still sleeping to give me my morning medication, I catch a glimpse of the idea of myself giving him a blowjob as a sissy, and it feels vivid at times. I don't have a good relationship with my father; I don't believe he fulfilled his role as a paternal role model and it angers me that he compels me to treat him as if he did. Last year I had a dream in which I violently beat him in the kitchen until putting him into a coma, which I believe reflects how I can't stand his cocky presence sometimes. I also have some form of Oedipus complex due to which I can only portray myself as male in sexual scenarios if I'm being sexually dominated by a woman who is at least somewhat a representation of a maternal figure. My mother was very domineering while my father was practically absent, and I believe my futanari fetish and projection of the phallus onto women I'm attracted to has to do with this.
I had a phase of wishing I was an asexual psychopath — it was really just hardship admitting I might be a guy who envies women for their feminine features and isn't really that masculine at all. Sometimes the way I feel about being male is like having a shirt you really like but that prickles your skin on the inside. It feels like part of society is slapping me in the face to say the masculine identity I developed since childhood is a psychotic consequence of the autistic-unfriendly socialization process I was forced to endure and that I'm actually a very feminine individual.
I graduated from school in 2024 and began university in a mathematics program. I'll most likely choose the bachelor's track and pursue research. If I get to the end of my life being regarded as a genius at something I genuinely love, even if only a small group of people appreciate my hard work and intelligence, and also end up not transitioning, that would be a huge win for me. I'm just not sure if I can get there.
I want the suffering to stop and I don't want transition to be the answer. But I also don't want to be one of those people who hard-repress trying to become the ultimate cis guy and end up going through a humiliating process of demasculinization followed by gender transition to become someone I don't see myself as — that would be worse than death itself. I struggle deeply with the cognitive dissonance created by messages I receive from trans people online and in life: again and again I'm told I might be transgender, that my story mirrors theirs before they transitioned, almost as if I'm a carbon copy of their pre-transition selves. Yet when I look inward, I don't see myself in that light. At the same time I can't deny a persistent, vague psychological discomfort — a low-grade suffering I've tried to interpret as related to gender issues, but if I'm honest I don't truly know where it's coming from or what it means.
By questioning myself I feel like I've been renouncing my social status as a man because of the notion that "real men don't question their gender." Acknowledging I'm not hypermasculine, and instead a more sensitive guy, has brought some sense of realness, even though I'd joyfully embody hypermasculinity if that were genuinely true for me. Still, there's an unspoken belief that I'm not as much of a man as a cis guy simply because I questioned my gender and found some comfort in embracing a slightly more feminine version of myself while still identifying as cisgender. But the idea that I'm fully cisgender feels false to me, and that's what I can't stand. My extremely unstable sense of self is preventing me from returning to the mental state I was in before I began questioning myself this way. I really miss my life before I started questioning myself and how I used to get around life as a cis guy just fine without ever questioning anything. I genuinely wish I could go back, even though I know it doesn't work that way.
I've become critical of mainstream transgender discourse. I'm not hostile to transgender people as individuals, but I am hostile to incoherent definitions that appropriate experiences like mine and then treat resistance as further proof. I've argued that modern trans discourse operates with two incompatible axiom sets treated as if they can coexist: one holds that gender identity is a first-person, self-authenticating fact; the other asserts that certain psychological traits and life experiences — distress around masculinity, autism, trauma, boundary issues, social anxiety, sexual shame — are indicators of latent transness, with resistance reframed as repression. These can't both be true. When someone says "if you're thinking about this, you're trans," they've abandoned self-identification for compulsory classification. I've also pointed out that the transgender community sends confusing signals, indirectly encouraging both gender essentialism and gender nihilism — two inherently contradictory concepts. I've been called out for being sexist without realizing it, painting myself as victim while being disrespectful toward women, and I acknowledged that these experiences have very little to do with actually being a woman and more to do with how idealized femininity is experienced from the male gaze. I see misogyny arising when women are first seen as a gateway to idealized femininity rather than as fully fleshed-out independent people, which usually happens because of poor socialization as a child — perhaps due to being raised by my parents as more special than other kids — leading to frustration when desires aren't instantly satisfied.
I sometimes resort to imagining what it would be like to become something like an asexual psychopath — shutting off vulnerabilities as a kind of relief. If I didn't feel sexual attraction, I wouldn't have to deal with the frustration of wanting affection and not knowing whether anyone genuinely wants me back. If I didn't crave emotional closeness, I wouldn't have to risk opening my heart and having it used against me the way it was when I was younger. Reducing emotional sensitivity altogether would strip the humiliation, rejection, and ridicule of their grip — a fantasy about being invulnerable, someone who cannot be humiliated for caring, mocked for reacting, or hurt by wanting affection.
I've asked others whether chemical castration could help alleviate intrusive sexual fantasies. I feel extremely alone with these issues — for the female equivalent of me, there's a whole feminist movement centered around mutual support and validation of femininity despite nonconformities, but that doesn't exist for men. Either you swallow the insult silently without a community, or you accept what they're telling you and become just another sheep in their community.