Alle verhalen

Twee transities, één therapeut, en het trauma eronder

Vrouw · GedesisteerdEerste dysforie 9 → Sociale transitie 11207
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een volledig gedesisteerde, niet-dysforische vrouw die voor het eerst sociaal transitioneerde op mijn 11e en nogmaals als volwassene, met in totaal ongeveer 7 jaar trans-identificatie en zo'n 10-15 jaar dysforie voordat het oploste. Mijn dysforie en autoandrofilie kwamen voort uit een gewelddadig gezin, een conservatieve gemeenschap en onverwerkt trauma; ik gebruikte een mannelijke beschermerspersona als ontsnapping en zelfbescherming. Door therapie die de onderliggende PTSS aanpakte en mijn trauma verwerkte, zijn mijn genderdysforie en AAP nu in volledige remissie. Na het desisteren bouwde ik mijn identiteit opnieuw op via hardlopen, krachttraining en het leren van talen, en ik maak deel uit van een traumaherstel-steungroep voor gedesisteerde vrouwen. Ik blijf kritisch over AGP/AAP als niet-aangeboren ontsnappingsmechanismen, terwijl ik individuele keuzes respecteer, en ik ben verbannen uit een trans-Discord omdat ik iemand bedankte voor een verhaal van spijt over transitie als minderjarige.

Volledig verhaal

I first remember feeling dysphoria around age 8 to 10, shortly before puberty. I grew up as an androgynous, dysphoric kid — I was entirely gender non-conforming, looked like a boy, acted like a boy, and dressed like a boy from about age 11. I began changing my presentation around 11 and socially transitioned for the first time as a child at 11. Looking like a boy changed how I was perceived and drastically changed who I was attracted to and who was attracted to me. I desisted in my teens, then retransitioned at around 21, socially transitioning for a second time as an adult at 19 (I've described both a first social transition at 11 and a second at 19, with a period of desistance in between, and separately said I retransitioned at 21 or so). In total I was trans-identifying for a span of about 7 years starting in childhood, and dysphoria persisted into adulthood — roughly 10 to 15 years before I reached any resolution. The core driver of my dysphoria, I eventually came to understand, was unresolved trauma. I grew up in an abusive household in an extremely conservative community and was shamed for not fitting in. I felt poorly equipped to deal with life as a female and had no one in my corner, so I took on another persona — I effectively 'became' the strong, stoic male protector I so badly wished I had, romanticizing that ideal man in myself to shield myself from ongoing trauma. My second transition was also driven by traumas experienced as an adult. I've described this pattern as escapism, and compared it to dissociation. Alongside this I developed autoandrophilia (AAP), which I've said began extremely young — in middle school or thereabouts — with no outside influence such as porn or internet exposure. I've described AAP as being into yourself as a man, contingent on being a biological female, and noted that no biological male has an element of it. My AAP was tied to trauma and misogyny — seeing men upheld at my detriment at a young age. I've said my AAP is now in complete remission after fully unpacking why I needed to develop that side of myself. My sexuality was complicated and muddled because the phenomenon started so young. I would lean much more strongly toward being attracted to women during my periods of male identification and be almost exclusively attracted to men during my periods of desistance. I've identified several factors: growing up in a homophobic environment where I felt it was 'more correct' to be heterosexual when presenting as a man; more attention from women during periods of male identification; and the traumatic female experience needing AAP as a method of self-protection. While I was in a relationship with a man during my first desistance, the female-attraction element went away completely because he was fulfilling that protector role. As a fully desisted and now non-dysphoric woman, my meta-attraction to women has faded considerably; I suspect I'm not purely heterosexual but also not 'bisexual enough for it to matter.' I ended up with a man (now an ex, but we have a cordial, warm friendship) who loved the masculine aspects of me. I've described transition as an effective but maladaptive coping mechanism for depression and trauma, much like an eating disorder — a distraction that gives you a list of defined goals to pursue. For me, transition was covering up underlying PTSD that I ended up seeking therapy for. Working through why I developed gender dysphoria in the first place and fully processing my trauma brought my GD into complete remission. I've framed GD as both a condition and a symptom, comparing it to how an anorexia patient both has anorexia and uses it to control their environment. I've also said OCD, eating disorders, depression, anxiety, and gender dysphoria are all different manifestations of trauma. After desisting I felt down and directionless because I had based so much of my identity on transition. I found it helpful to find avenues of self-development to replace transition escapism — I got into running, working out, and language learning, and defined myself outside of my former trans identity. On community: I'm based in the Boston area on the East Coast. I ran into another desister in the wild at a small writers group at my local library and believe we're at a tipping point. I'm part of a group where everyone is at a similar stage of trauma recovery with the difficult processing mostly behind us, which has worked well; I've noted that when trauma is the foundation of friendship things get messy, and that groups should be vetted based on processing stage. I've observed many people leave the detrans community once they're healthier, while others stay and benefit. I've been permanently banned from a trans Discord for emoji-reacting to and sending one message gently thanking someone sharing their story about transitioning as a minor and how they were harmed by the experience. I've also told others to correct flair misuse on the subreddit. On transition for others: I've argued that there is no difference between a trans person and a detransitioner until the point of detransition, and criticized people who haven't actually listened to detrans people. I've been critical of AGP/AAP as not innate and not something to base one's life on, describing it as a dysfunctional escape mechanism, while also saying the decision about what to do is entirely the individual's own. I've recommended Call Me Sam's YouTube videos on detransition after 25 years of transition, focused on CPTSD recovery. I've also been supportive of post-op trans people in dating contexts, saying I wouldn't exclude post-op men from my dating prospects and that I'm more concerned with who someone is as a person.