Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, heteroseksuele vrouw. Na maanden van privé kritiek op de transgendertheorie vertelde ik mijn transgender beste vriend van zeven jaar dat ik gedetransitioneerd was, en hij maakte binnen een week een einde aan de vriendschap. Ik transitioneerde omdat ik me niet kon herkennen in conventionele vrouwelijkheid en androgyne heteroseksuele vrouwen niet zag vertegenwoordigd in de media. Nu bespreek ik openlijk wat ik zie als een veelvoorkomend patroon onder mensen die ik van school ken — trauma door seksueel geweld, problemen thuis en een obsessie met yaoi/fujoshi — in samenhang met transitie, en ik bekritiseer wat ik zie als alledaagse sociale druk om trans te zijn. Het verlies van die vriendschap deed pijn, maar ik blijf kritisch posten over transgenderisme en geef online advies aan jongere twijfelaars.
Volledig verhaal
I have been questioning and then coming out as detransitioned over the past few months, and I've been open about how I got here. Looking back, I realize I decided to transition largely because I couldn't relate to conventional femininity — I told someone that '90 percent of women look like these fem standarts' and that I had decided this was 'TRUE WOMANHOOD' and that I 'wasnt related to this at all.' I explained that I don't see beauty in long hair, makeup, or big lips — 'i honestly think that long hair, make up, big lips are ugly' — and because of that 'i decided to transition.' I also noted how hard it is to find representation: 'There is no andro/masc women in media..but if they Do look not fem they are always lesbians(im straight so i just cant find anyone whom i relate to).' I've been trying to look at womanhood differently, but I said 'its hard when almost every woman in this earth either look fem either look masc but claim herself queer.'
I've also been critical of what I call 'transgenderism theory' for months. I talked about this a lot with my best friend of seven years, who is trans, before I came out as detransitioned: 'he was all agree, then when i came out he suddenly started talking, how weird am i cuz im Obssesed w sex.' He told me I was pushing him into sex even though he identifies as aroace, and then 'he just dropped me in a week and said that all our friendship ACTUALLY i was an asshole person and he glad that he dropped someone so cruel.' That friendship ending was painful for me.
I've also observed a pattern I see repeatedly among people I know from real life — not people I found through detrans spaces, but people I 'just knew them from school' — of 'SA trauma, family troubles and yaoi obsession.' I've said 'this pattern is so common that i dont undertstand, people really dont see this all have a connection or they dont want to tell, cuz its so obvious.' I'm frustrated that questioning someone's identity is treated as off-limits: 'no one can ever doubt peoples identity, like when trans people have experienced SA no one could ever ASSUME THAT IT COULD BE CUZ OF THAT.'
I wrote a post criticizing how people casually link things to transgenderism: 'they still perceive JUST the idea of fetishising gays as the sign of transgenderism' and then say 'No ones pushing anyone to be trans' while simultaneously connecting 'the most random thing to transgenderism and make it clear that "it can be the sign!so just be trans".' I've also called out a trans TikTok creator who is 'obviously just fujoshy but transitioning' and complains about cis women fetishizing gay men. I've been giving advice to younger people online, telling one person they sounded young and that their fixations were 'just ur interests which are not smt more than obsessions,' and I complimented someone's art reference photos. Right now I'm still working through my detransition publicly and processing the loss of a long friendship.