Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een cisgender zwarte man van in de veertig die niet gedetransitioneerd is, maar actief werd op r/detrans door relaties met trans mannen, waaronder een huidige trans vriend en een FTM-ex. Ik steun het recht van volwassenen om te transitioneren na grondig onderzoek, maar geloof dat veel jongeren bevestigend richting transitie worden geduwd zonder de blijvende gevolgen te begrijpen, en ik denk dat beslissingen minstens tot de leeftijd van 25 moeten wachten. Ik ben van meerdere transsubreddits geband en met zijn allen aangevallen, bedreigd en beledigd omdat ik vragen stelde en feiten noemde, wat mijn opvatting heeft verhard dat de online transgemeenschap sektarisch en vijandig tegenover detransitioners is. Ik besteed veel tijd in de gemeenschap aan het aanmoedigen van zelfacceptatie, therapie en voorzichtigheid bij onomkeerbare medische beslissingen.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and I am a cisgender man — I've never transitioned myself, so I'm not detrans. I'm in my forties now; I've said it took me "many moons 40 years to be this comfortable" in my own skin, and I remember being younger and struggling with acceptance myself, though for me that was just ordinary adolescence rather than anything trans. I'm a Black man, 6'1" and around 250 pounds, and I've noticed people tell me I can come across as intimidating.
I ended up in the detrans community because I've been in relationships with trans men. I had a partner who is a trans man — he's my boyfriend — and I also mention an ex who is FTM. I went into trans spaces originally to better learn and understand, out of love for my partner. What I found instead was a lot of hostility: I was banned from the ftm subreddit after being dogpiled just for asking questions, and I've been banned from two other high-profile subs for stating things I'd seen and researched. People dug through my profile to try to discredit me as a person, called me transphobic and ableist, made fun of my dog dying of cancer, and threatened me with violence. I've had people wish death on me. I don't take it too personally — most people who meet me in real life don't have the guts to come at me like that — but it still blows my mind.
My perspective is basically this: I support any adult's right to transition if that's genuinely what they want and they've done the research to understand the risks and permanent effects. But I think a lot of what I see now isn't real dysphoria — it's people who are lost, who don't feel accepted, who can't accept themselves, and who are being affirmed instead of helped through their trauma. I've watched a pattern in my own life: men I've talked to, mostly smaller FTM guys, who asserted they were men and wanted to compete with me, but then when things turned sexual they wanted to be submissive and treated like a woman. I found that confusing and it fed my conclusion that a lot of this is about something other than gender. I think the medical side is driven by money — providers handing out interventions like candy while people in the UK can't even get testosterone, and then the community shuns anyone who detransitions. I think nobody should be allowed to make these decisions until at least 25, because the brain isn't finished developing. I also believe no amount of estrogen will give a male body a womb or reproductive organs, and that it's offensive to women to claim otherwise — while still respecting people's pronouns and expression.
I've spent a lot of time in r/detrans encouraging people. I tell them to find themselves again outside of being trans, to love and accept themselves, to get into therapy that actually addresses the underlying feelings, to work out and eat healthy, and to set short- and long-term goals. I've told people not to make permanent decisions about temporary problems. I've also pushed back on the idea that being called "woman" or "female" is an insult, and I've defended detransitioners' right to tell their stories. I've offered my DMs to anyone who needs to vent. I'm aware my opinions aren't always wanted — I try to be upfront that I'm a cis man speaking from the outside — but I care about people not screwing up their lives, and I'd rather tell the truth than let someone bully me into silence.