Alle verhalen

Een tienerjongen online, daarna een gedetransitioneerde vrouw met een gezin

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd4,6K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben als vrouw geboren, en als tiener presenteerde ik me online als het andere gender en haatte ik mijn lichaam, maar ik groeide er zonder medische transitie overheen: ik transitioneerde alleen sociaal en identificeer me nu als gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die zich prettig voelt in mijn geboortegeslacht. Ik schrijf mijn genderleed als tiener toe aan groepsdruk, omgeving en ontevredenheid met mezelf in plaats van iets aangeborens, en ik heb spijt van de tijd die ik besteedde aan obsessief bezig zijn met genderidentiteit. Ik heb beschreven dat ik oude wonden te boven kwam door tijd, zelfreflectie en het heroriënteren van mijn doelen, en ik heb nu een gezin. Sinds 2019 ben ik een productieve reageerder op r/detrans, waar ik betoog dat transitie een onomkeerbare gok is gedreven door financiële en politieke prikkels, dat medische professionals worden geprikkeld om te affirmeren in plaats van te helpen, en dat open discours en detransitie-stemmen beschermd moeten worden. Ik heb geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging voor mezelf beschreven.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and grew up in what sounds like a fairly traditional household; my parents were willing to tell me bluntly when I was wrong, which I now appreciate deeply — I've written that it 'really makes me appreciate that my parents had the guts to tell me i didnt know everything about the world and that I'm dead wrong.' I don't recall ever having unlimited internet access as a kid, and I explicitly say the internet and online 'hugboxes' were never my source of escapism. As a teenager I struggled with my body and with gender identity. I presented as the opposite gender online and hated my body, but I grew out of it: 'Your story is identical to mine in a way. Presented as an opposite gender online, hated my body. And I grew out of it. I became comfortable with myself because I realized there's nothing wrong with myself.' I also say I was influenced by peer pressure as a teen: 'In hindsight, its real apparent just how much i was influenced by peer pressures as a teen.' I have referred to myself as having 'only socially transitioned' and, in a debate about lived experience, defended that: 'Should i open each post with all the pain and hurt of my personal life, and those who medically transitioned in it to try and give some additional credibility to my opinion so that I'm not just written off?' — implying I did not medically transition. I have never described hormones, surgeries, or puberty blockers for myself. I also reference having had therapists I was critical of: 'Much like i criticized the feedback of the therapists and doctors i went to, with their "extensive knowledge" and expertise.' I don't describe a specific diagnosis for myself. I do describe having parts of myself I can't get back and mistakes I've made: 'There are things and parts of myself i cant get back. It hurts to remember. Its painful to self reflect. But at the same time, its in the past. Whats done is done, and i am what i am now.' I've written about 'the time i had to spend making myself get over old wounds' and that 'time, self reflection, and reorienting my goals and perspectives made the feelings and memories less oppressive.' I've also mentioned 'my mental instabilities' in passing when discussing whether such things come up in long-term relationships. I've described myself as a '29 year old boomer' in September 2021 and as a 'Boomer here. My joints have been poppy and clicky since hitting my mid 20's' in February 2022 — both self-deprecating shorthand for being older than the typical poster. I've said 'I'm old enough to remember when being offensive wasn't the greatest sin a human could commit.' I came to view my teenage gender distress as escapism and as something shaped by environment rather than something innate. I've written that I realized 'being trans wasn't solving any of my problems, and just created new ones,' and that 'Looking back, i cant help but feel like a fool for having wasted so much time even thinking about gender identity.' I now describe myself as having desisted/detransitioned socially and as being comfortable in my birth sex. On sexuality and relationships: I've said I 'never desired or cared for casual sex' and that my dating goal was 'something long term and family oriented.' I've written that being blunt and direct when dating 'Saved me a lot of time in starting a family,' and that I have a family — I refer to 'the number of kids this will help in the long term versus those it will hurt in the short term' when discussing policy, and elsewhere reference having children in the context of family life. I've described myself as having been blunt and direct in dating, which 'prevented the month long guessing games.' I don't describe my orientation explicitly. I have not described suicidal ideation, self-harm, or attempts for myself. I have, however, counseled someone else who was suicidal: 'You shouldn't kill yourself, and i hope you don't.' I became a very active commenter in r/detrans from late 2019 onward, writing hundreds of comments. My overall framework is that gender distress in most people stems from environmental factors — trauma, bad parenting, peer pressure, online echo chambers, internalized dissatisfaction — rather than something innate; that transition is a permanent, irreversible gamble pushed by financially and politically motivated actors; that doctors, therapists, and institutions are incentivized to affirm rather than help; and that the culture around trans issues is engineered to create 'victims' for political and monetary gain. I'm strongly critical of puberty blockers and hormones for minors, of 'informed consent' as a legal shield, and of censorship on Reddit and other platforms. I advocate for free speech, open discourse, and detransition/desistance voices being heard, and I've argued against 'lived experience' hierarchies in the sub itself, defending the right of anyone to comment regardless of flair. I've said I'm willing to be blunt and take backlash if it convinces even one person not to make 'a terrible mistake.' I've also expressed sympathy for people who transitioned, urging self-forgiveness: 'You need to forgive yourself, and learn to accept and live the new normal.' I've described my own approach to self-worth: 'I got away from thinking about my body entirely. Out of all the things i've done in life, or wanted to do: the number of times my body directly got in the way or hindered me can be counted on one hand.' I've said I'm naturally skeptical of mainstream opinion and drawn to fringe viewpoints: 'I dont trust other people to tell me right from wrong, or good from bad.' I've mentioned being a conservative ('T. Conservative here for the show') early on, though I later push back on dismissing detrans voices for being right-wing. I've said I work ('i gotta get back to work') and I've given career advice about volunteer work. I've expressed concern about my own joints since my mid-20s but no medical crisis. I've said I live somewhere with no local detrans or free-speech communities: 'Nothing like that here in my locality.'