Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die jarenlang in therapie zat en medische transitie nastreefde voordat ik een stap terug deed. Ik denk nu over genderidentiteit als iets waar veel cis mensen vragen over hebben, en ik ben op mijn hoede voor obsessieve denkpatronen zoals OCD die zich eraan vasthaken. Ik heb er spijt van dat ik wat ik wilde wegredeneerde om anderen te plezieren, en ik dring er bij mensen op aan keuzes voor zichzelf te maken in plaats van uit angst voor oordeel. Ik wil dat detransruimtes gericht blijven op eerlijke verslagen over de keerzijden van transitie, zonder af te glijden naar ophitsende anti-transinhoud. Ik richt me op beheersbaar gedrag — verzorging, zelfzorg, sociale vaardigheden — in plaats van stil te staan bij onomkeerbare veranderingen die ik niet meer ongedaan kan maken.
Volledig verhaal
I've always been a people-pleaser, and looking back on my life I can point to so many moments where I rationalized away what I actually wanted in order to keep other people happy — my parents, fraternity brothers, friends. I've told others plainly: it's your body and your life, and none of those other people will be present in your life as long as you will be.
I think about gender identity more than most people assume cis people do, and I've had those conversations with friends and family too. When I read someone describing an obsessive, repeating question about not wanting to be a woman that creates existential dread and anxiety, my instinct is to think OCD — I know there's an official subtype of OCD around sexual obsession, and it makes complete sense to me that the same machinery could latch onto gender identity. I also push back on the idea that people never think about their gender: who even knew the phrase 'gender identity' ten years ago? And nobody I know adheres perfectly to their ostensible gender role.
I've been in therapy myself and I ask others whether they are too. When I see someone say they were 'just fine' while pursuing therapy and hormone treatment, I push back: if you didn't feel you had anything to treat, you wouldn't have followed the doctor's recommendation. You still had agency, even if the doctor recommended it. I'm pretty indoorsy myself, and spending months indoors doesn't sound 'just fine' to me.
I've also been on the other side of this — I've read accounts from people who pursued medical transition and then had to reckon with what it did to them. One person described starting to have dysphoric and anxious episodes again after the physical and mental changes testosterone brought back, avoiding mirrors and showering, barely leaving the house, missing the friends they made when they presented as female, and feeling like 'a miserable zombie' rather than a real person. My response was blunt: it doesn't matter whether the path is transition or detransition — do what you have to do to be happy and functional instead of staying where you are. Don't make choices because you're worried about what other people think. I like the phrase 'Don't be influenced by people you wouldn't go to for advice' — you wouldn't take advice from either the people online who want ostracism and violence against trans people, nor from the people who make up the most extreme parts of the mainstream trans community, so why let either group shape your choices?
I care about this sub staying a space for people to talk freely about the negative aspects of transition and their detransition experiences. What I don't want is content calling 'transgenderism' a mental illness or advertising petitions against drag queen storytime — I called that 'deliberately inflammatory language and a clickbait title,' and I got downvoted for it. My point wasn't to quibble over whether gender dysphoria is technically a mental disorder; it was about the framing.
I've engaged with people worrying about what they could have had if they'd never pursued medical transition, and I tell them to stop: it's hypothetical, you don't actually know, and it's unproductive to waste time on something you can no longer change. Instead I focus on what's actually controllable. When someone worries about coming across as 'creepy,' I point out that creepy isn't a physical appearance, it's behavior — grooming, self-care, dressing better, working on picking up social cues, all of that is within your control and all of it is behavior. I've also talked with people about dating after transition-related changes, including someone whose appearance I described as 'male but with gynecomastia' with a pelvic 'V' that reads male, and I've said there are definitely women who would be into it — finding a partner into an unusual fetish is tricky, but people manage it. I've also pushed back on the idea that pale skin is unattractive; many cultures prefer it.
I don't describe myself as detransitioned in these comments, but I've clearly spent a lot of time in detrans spaces, thought hard about the medical and psychological sides of transition, and I have direct experience of being in therapy and considering or pursuing medical intervention myself.