Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, gedesisteerde biseksuele autistische vrouw die ongeveer vijf jaar als trans man en als non-binair leefde voordat ik in 2008 desisteerde, zonder ooit medische ingrepen te hebben gehad omdat medicijnen destijds niet voor mij toegankelijk waren. Mijn transitie werd gedreven door geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat, een jongensachtige kindertijd en een stiefvader die me voortdurend ten nadele vergeleek met mijn mooie, vrouwelijke zussen en me mannelijke rolmodellen opdrong. Bij mij werden OCD en autisme vastgesteld, ik beviel van een dochter en voelde me later sterk vrouwelijk, wat voor mij bevestigde dat ik nooit trans was. Ik ben kritisch over de huidige transbeweging en over uitsluitend bevestigende therapie, en ik pleit voor grondige therapeutische beoordeling vóór transitie. Ik heb geen blijvende medische effecten en meld geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in the 1990s and early 2000s with three sisters. My father told me he had only ever wanted daughters, yet later began lamenting that he had no son, which stung because my stepfather had made it clear that an 'ugly tomboyish stepdaughter was the same as a boy.' My stepfather reinforced the idea that I was not really a girl: he pointed out that my sisters were pretty and feminine while I was not, gave me '700 books on boys doing cool stuff and 300,000 male role models from history,' and told me that mostly boys liked all my hobbies and that women could not succeed at my career goals. A 'helpful' teacher once gave me the book about Deborah Samson, which I now recognize as not well thought out. I internalized the message 'if I'm not traditionally girly, I must be a boy.' I came of age in 2001. I spent about five years living as a trans man and more time thinking I was non-binary or genderqueer, living 'en masc,' before desisting in 2008. All my friends and my mom's side of the family knew about my gender journey at the time. I never had medical interventions: I have said repeatedly that medications were inaccessible when I socially transitioned and then desisted, and I consider it 'sheer luck.' I was diagnosed with OCD and autism; my grandmother paid for my screening and it cost 'an absolute fortune,' which I described as evidence that inaccessibility of care is a travesty. I have mild compulsions related to limited object permanence, such as checking my wallet multiple times after putting cash in it. I also believe I had a lot of internalized misogyny: because my sisters were extremely beautiful and feminine and I was not, I somehow thought that if I wasn't pretty, I must not be a girl. I later gave birth to a daughter and started feeling extremely feminine, which convinced me I was never actually trans. I also have a son and other children — I describe having 'both boy and girl children,' including a daughter who is 'sword fight in a dress and fix cars in a ball gown feminine,' two other daughters who are less feminine, sons who are 'rough-and-ready goers and doers,' and a youngest son who wears pink sparkle shoes, unicorn shirts and sometimes tutus but loves camping, fishing and trucks. I am autistic and bisexual. I have worked doing renovations for a living, which I did when I thought I was a man, and I note that this career was 'specifically caused by these exact attitudes.' I got sterilized through a tubal ligation in New Mexico, where doctors are liberal about services; my doctor told me that if I was ever unhappy with the ligation I could request a hysterectomy and he would do it, and I later advised someone else to go to New Mexico for a hysterectomy that removes only the uterus, not the ovaries, so as not to disrupt hormones. I have no lasting medical effects from my transition. I wear a skirt over my bottoms out of insecurity or modesty, and no one looks. I have described my health issues as causing me to be a little fat rather than the reverse, and my very thin sister's health issues causing her thinness; we have both been told that gaining or losing weight would fix our problems, which I call inaccurate. I have been open about recommending that people who think they may be trans see a therapist without affirmation-only practices to determine whether they are really trans or have other issues going on, as I did. I believe the Real Life Test was beneficial and that the older, clearer standards for transition were better for both the patient and the community. I am critical of the current trans movement, saying it is not facilitating trans people living peacefully, and I have criticized 'trenders,' children transitioning, and self-identification into transness. I also believe social media and the desire for attention, 'brave and fabulous' praise, and 'oppression points' drive many young people toward transition, alongside puberty discomfort, identity-seeking in adolescence, and separating from parents. I have criticized toxic positivity and the weaponization of therapeutic language, and I view much of the current discourse as sociocultural engineering conditioning people to accept outrageous ideologies without speaking up. I have no record of suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts.