Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw (vrouw geboren) die van mijn 16e tot 27e als trans identificeerde, vanaf mijn 25e ongeveer 18-22 maanden testosteron nam, op mijn 26e dubbele-incisie-topchirurgie had en op mijn 27e detransitioneerde nadat ik met antidepressiva begon. Ik transitioneerde vanwege ernstige, tien jaar durende seksdysforie geworteld in emotionele verwaarlozing in mijn kindertijd, een alcoholische vader, waarschijnlijk CPTSS, piekeren en een verslavend denkpatroon — niet omdat ik me vergiste over mijn dysforie, die echt en extreem was. Ik detransitioneerde toen ik besefte dat transitie me slechts cosmetisch masculiniseerde en me nooit man kon maken, en toen ik het geloof in het ‘verkeerde lichaam’ niet langer logisch kon verdedigen. Ik ervaar nog steeds af en toe dysforie en wat suïcidale gedachten (passief, minder intens dan voorheen, vooral gekoppeld aan angsten over relaties en kinderen krijgen), maar het gaat mentaal veel beter dankzij SSRI's, een stabiele woonsituatie en de steun van mijn beste vriend(in). Ik heb vooral spijt van de topchirurgie vanwege het verloren vermogen om borstvoeding te geven, chronische pijn en blijvende stemveranderingen, al is mijn spijt milder dan mijn dysforie was; ik identificeer me momenteel als gedetransitioneerde vrouw die niet gelooft in genderidentiteit.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in the American South. The first time I wanted to be a boy was before I was 10 — in pre-K I was always the dad when we played house, and when puberty started around 9-11 I genuinely thought I was turning into a boy. The desire really took hold then. I first learned that FTM transition existed at 16 (around 2007, after seeing a documentary) and immediately saw myself in the concept. I told my friends and mom between 17 and 18. I went to a rural college in 2009 where there was no trans support; I bound a lot and tried to pass when I could. I saw a couple of counselors who were barely aware of trans issues.
Around 2011 I discovered gender critical radical feminism and started hate-reading GC Tumblr blogs, eventually agreeing with them, which created a lot of cognitive dissonance. I identified as a transmed/truscum FTM but also wanted to desist. I reluctantly went back to wearing bras and pretended it didn't upset me when people called me 'she' — a 'fake it till you make it' approach — but internally I still felt truly trans. During this period I had severe anxiety and depression, barely left the house except for work, and only got groceries every couple of months because I couldn't go anywhere alone. This desist attempt lasted maybe two years and failed because I was doing it because ideology told me to, not because I believed I wasn't trans.
At 25 (2016) I had what I call a quarter-life crisis, went into panic mode, and transitioned. I got a letter from a therapist after 2-3 sessions; when I saw my GP (not an endocrinologist) I apparently didn't even need it because they used informed consent. I started testosterone cypionate on 6/26/16 at a standard dose, injected every other week. I had top surgery (double incision with free nipple grafts) about 8 months later, at age 26, paid out of pocket, roughly 3 months from first consult to procedure at my own request. I did NOT have a hysterectomy or any lower surgery — I considered metoidioplasty but it seemed pointless and I didn't have the money; I never wanted phalloplasty because the results didn't look or function real to me.
I was on T for about 18-22 months total. I was excited about the changes — I recorded videos, took hundreds of photos, tracked everything religiously, sang to test my vocal range. But I developed a severe phobia of doing my injections after the first 2-3 months; my best friend started doing them for me, and 'shot night' became a whole evening every other week that brought guilt and resentment. My doctor brushed off my request for non-injectables. Eventually my psyche presented the option 'I think I'm okay with just being female' and I took the easier route of simply stopping T rather than dealing with another shot night. I stopped cold turkey; my doctor said it was fine. My period came back within about 2 months and has been regular since. I started an antidepressant/anti-anxiety medication around the same time I decided to detransition (at 27), and about 2 months later I detransitioned socially.
I changed my name again about 5 months after detransitioning — I feminized my male name so I could keep my nickname, reverted to my birth middle name, and took my mother's maiden name for my last name. My driver's license still reads a female name with an 'M' because the DMV won't change my sex back without another surgical procedure; my birth certificate was never changed so it reads birth name + F.
Physical outcomes: no breast regrowth at all after nearly a year off T. Body hair diminished significantly back to about where it started. Facial hair decreased but hasn't gone — I shave daily with a safety razor. Voice did not change back to any significant degree — it's androgynous, cracks, I can't sing like I used to, it takes more effort to speak, and there's a persistent 'crunch' or lump-in-throat sensation in my larynx. Bottom growth is still present. I have chronic pain I assume is from surgery, rib flaring and breathing problems from years of binding, and my nipple grafts have essentially no sensation — they're hard scar tissue, painful to pinch, and I call them 'my grafts' rather than nipples. I lost about 50 lbs over 2 years during transition and am now 5'2" and about 100 lbs; my periods are now much less painful than before T.
Causes and contributors: I describe my childhood as 'not loved enough' with attachment and insecurity issues. My parents are divorced; my father is an alcoholic (I was estranged from him after a fight at 16 when my mom picked me up and I never went back). He was possessive, made me promise never to leave him, and there was covert abuse I only recognized in retrospect. My mom cared for me but didn't seem interested in me specifically. I have a high ACE score and experiences in line with CPTSD (never officially diagnosed). I was undiagnosed with depression and anxiety for years and feared diagnosis would prevent me getting HRT. I daydreamed constantly as a child and into adulthood — creating characters, stories, art — as an escape. I was an internet cartoon-artist-nerd into anime conventions, cosplay, OCs, and roleplay. I've never been diagnosed with autism but show traits. My father has diagnosed ADHD and is an addict; addiction runs in the family and I came to view 'being trans' as a form of addiction/compulsion. I also had a very high libido which I think contributed to thinking of myself as male. I experienced some pressure to be feminine but it wasn't a major part of my story; I'm probably heterosexual (attracted to men) and was never in a 'gay' relationship as a trans man because it wouldn't have felt real.
What moved me toward detransition: it was cognitive, not emotional — 'driven more by brain than heart.' I could no longer logically defend the beliefs I held (Wrong Body Hypothesis, Real Trans People, Body Map Theory, medical transition as necessary rather than cosmetic). The antidepressants cleared my head enough to access parts of myself I'd forgotten. Moving into a quiet apartment with my best friend above gave me safety and stability for the first time. My best friend's unconditional support through transition and back was the number one thing that helped. I also realized transition was 'anti-conservation' — it went against my own pre-existing values, since I had always decided cosmetic surgery was not for me.
Mental health: I had undiagnosed depression and anxiety for years, severe social anxiety (couldn't order food at a restaurant, couldn't post online at my worst), and what I now recognize as CPTSD. I started SSRIs about 2 months before detransitioning and they helped enormously — I went from barely functional to being able to call doctors. I still experience suicidal ideation, though less intensely than before: 'life is hard, being dead is easy, might as well skip it.' I made plans in the past but was too afraid of the permanence of death. Most of my suicidal feelings now stem from fear of not achieving what I want — finding a partner, having children. I self-harmed in frustration as a young person.
Regret: I would undo my transition if I could, though I've learned things from it I wouldn't want to unlearn. I regret top surgery most — not because of how it looks (I have no dysphoria about my flat chest and my results look good with zero complications) but because I can never breastfeed if I have children (a desire that emerged around age 27, after surgery), because of chronic pain, because of lost sensation, and because it was unnecessary. I regret the money, the lost time, the permanent voice changes, the rib damage from binding. Regret 'snuck up on me' gradually. It's less intense than my dysphoria ever was. I still experience dysphoria intermittently — I still sometimes wish I could be male, still feel jealousy when I see people who transitioned — but grounding statements and self-awareness make the episodes shorter and less severe.
Sexuality and relationships: I've never had a romantic partner or sex, and I'm 28. I turned down people specifically because I wanted to be someone's boyfriend, not girlfriend. I was in a relationship with a female once that was never physically intimate. I'm probably heterosexual but have basically given up labeling myself. My debilitating anxiety through adolescence and early 20s left me way behind socially.
Current status and attitudes: I identify as a detransitioned female/detransitioner — I don't believe in gender identity or that anyone can be born in the wrong body. I'm 'gender agnostic.' I still struggle to call myself 'woman' but accept it means 'adult human female.' I don't actively hide my detransition. I work in administration at a university. I have one close friend IRL plus a handful at arm's length. I created a detransition survey, wrote a blog ('Alternatives to Transition'), and post actively in detrans communities. I believe transition should be understood as cosmetic surgery, that better screening and genuine therapy are desperately needed, and that dysphoria is a treatable thought pattern rather than an innate condition. I'm critical of transition as a medical treatment but not hostile to individuals who transition. I was banned from posting on r/FTM for defending detransitioners.