Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die als trans identificeerde, de trans-diagnose kreeg tijdens een actieve psychose en ongeveer 1,5 jaar oestrogeen nam voordat ik stopte vanwege cardiovasculaire risico's, gewichtstoename, een knobbel in de borst, verhoogd prolactine en nooit doorgaan voor vrouw. Ik identificeer niet meer met enig gender en ben nu 100% aseksueel. Ik geloof dat mijn transitie werd gedreven door psychose, trauma waaronder aanranding in mijn kindertijd en post-orgasmisch ziektesyndroom, AGP en fetisjgemeenschappen, en dat psychodynamische therapie en IFS mijn dysforie hielpen. Ik ben verbannen uit online gemeenschappen omdat ik mijn detransitieverhaal postte en ben een 'gendersverrader' en 'TERF' genoemd. Ik spreek nu kritisch over transitie, AGP en de online transgemeenschap, terwijl ik de beslissingen van anderen om te detransitioneren steun.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male. I first wanted to be a woman and never really felt 'male', but I also never really felt female — I don't identify with any gender now and say it's no longer important to me. I transitioned while I was in active psychosis, and I got diagnosed as trans officially on my papers by two different endocrinologists, each of whom put me on a completely different hormone regime, which made me feel I wasn't 'in good hands' with doctors.
I was on estrogen for about 1.5–1.5.5 years (I rounded up to 2). I also describe transitioning as being caused by psychosis, and separately say I transitioned because of trauma: I have post-orgasmic illness syndrome (POIS), where I got sick after ejaculation all the time, and I was also molested. I now think trauma creates fetishes, and I say 'perverts are traumatised men.' I definitely had AGP. I also say trans people egged me on to transition when I was psychotic and had the mental reasoning ability of an 8-year-old.
Positives I experienced on estrogen: POIS disappeared — I could ejaculate without vomiting; I felt pretty and liked the changes in my body and felt more comfortable in my skin; I liked being treated like a girl; it significantly reduced fetishes I didn't like, specifically feederism and a few others; I got love-bombed a lot and everyone was nice to me, and I got a lot of male attention (I'm bi and that was really nice). I also had a community — I describe it as a 'cult' — where everyone wanted to be my friend and have sex with me, which was shallow but I had friends, which at that point was something for me.
Negatives: my cardiovascular health suffered a lot; I gained a lot of weight ('estrogen makes you gain like crazy'); I had a lump in my breast which disappeared after I quit HRT; I was at high risk for stroke per my doctor and estrogen increases stroke risk; I got signs of cardiovascular issues and early risks of breast cancer. My prolactin came back very elevated on bloodwork years after HRT and I was scheduled for an FMRI — I asked if anyone else got a prolactinoma. HRT also made my hemorrhoids bleed a lot; when I posted about it in a trans Discord server, most trans girls replied 'congrats! You're becoming a woman, you got your first period' when I was actually concerned HRT was weakening my blood vessels/circulatory system. I got lots of likes/reactions on Discord for showing bloody toilet tissue, and it felt affirming at the time — I look back and cringe at 'just how psychotic I was.'
People told me I looked like 'a dude with tits' and I couldn't disagree. I realized I'd never pass and no one would ever treat me like a female. If it wasn't for the health issues I would still be taking estrogen because I felt better on it. I stopped HRT because health issues are more important than identity.
I no longer identify as trans or female or male. I decided not to talk about this in public — once I lose weight no one will pretty much know. When I do talk about my detransition, which I think was pretty valid, people call me a 'gender traitor.' I got banned from an art Discord server (Ethan Becker's) because one non-binary girl who never plans to take HRT found my story offensive and created drama. I was also banned from a polyamory subreddit just for posting my story here. People call me a 'TERF' for even suggesting estrogen has heart-health side effects. I sometimes really beat myself up for wanting to transition.
I now think social constructivism is BS. I say a lot of 'trans' and 'queer' people never took HRT and never will — they just self-identify — and they bashed my detransition while only having transitioned 'socially' (putting on blue hair). I say there are more fetishists into being 'sissies' than people with a female brain in a male body, that many AGPs got their views on womanhood from anime/hentai, and that males are more likely to be controlled by fetishes and porn addiction to feminization porn. I say children classify things into absolutes good vs evil and that's why people attack detrans people, breaking their illusion that everyone innately knows if they're trans without diagnosis. I also say you cannot tell anything negative about trans people without being labelled a bigot, and that the shame element is gone so people are emboldened. I criticize the American therapy system as 'capitalist sycophancy' and praise the Polish system where you get a free therapist assigned who can be mean.
On therapy: psychodynamic therapy worked for my dysphoria, and IFS helped me too. I recommend university hospitals in Gdansk (UCK) and reading Google reviews. I say therapy for complex PTSD would be a better option than transitioning for trauma. I also say people underestimate how much it costs to transition properly and pass, and that they have an unrealistically idealized version of it in their heads — I sure did.
I'm 100% asexual now. I don't blame myself for transitioning given I was in psychosis. I'm working on getting my life together, losing weight, and my health. I congratulated someone else on detransitioning and said I detransitioned for similar reasons — I didn't pass — and think it's a valid reason.