Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik kwam op mijn 14e uit als trans, leefde 6 jaar als man en nam ongeveer een jaar testosteron op mijn 19e-20e voordat ik een week voor de operatie terugkrabbelde van een mastectomie en detransitioneerde. Ik detransitioneerde omdat ik besefte dat mijn dysforie was vervaagd, ik omgekeerde dysforie ervoer, en ik geloofde dat ik nooit zou zijn getransitioneerd als mijn homofobe, religieuze familie mijn lesbisch zijn had geaccepteerd. Ik ben nu een gedetransitioneerde vrouw van 20 (een butch lesbienne) die haar naam wettelijk heeft teruggeveranderd, haar haar laat groeien en in het openbaar voor een man wordt aangezien, wat me leed en angst bezorgt in damestoiletten. Ik heb soms diepe spijt van de hormonen en noemde de spijt 'volkomen verwoestend', maar al met al heb ik meer gemoedsrust dan tijdens mijn transitie. Mijn lichaamsdysforie is weg, maar ik worstel nog met sociale dysforie, mijn onveranderde stem in het mannelijke bereik en resterende gezichtsbeharing.
Volledig verhaal
I came out as trans (FTM) at 14 and everyone took me at my word except my parents; my psychiatrist and therapist just went along with it. I socially transitioned and lived as a man for 6 years. I waited until I was 19 to start testosterone, and I was on a high dose for about a year (I've also said 50 weeks, and 'a little less than a year'). I was preparing for a mastectomy/top surgery and was about a week before the surgery date when I realized it wasn't the path for me, so I backed out at the last possible second.
What pushed me toward detransition was realizing that if my family had been accepting of my sexual orientation, I probably never would have transitioned in the first place — my family was homophobic and religious, and I had identified as a straight trans man until I fell for a lesbian, which made me question myself. I also felt that my original body dysphoria had stemmed from internalized misogyny and what I thought a woman 'had' to be. I started feeling reverse dysphoria and couldn't live with it; the thought of detransition calmed me down and made me happier. I questioned my transition for about a week before socially detransitioning — I described that decision as somewhat impulsive, though I don't think impulsive means it was bad.
My detrans process: I made the decision to detransition, stopped testosterone cold turkey (I didn't want any more facial hair to grow), told friends and family, and applied to legally change my name back to my birth name. I re-came out to friends as a lesbian and not trans, first on a private Snapchat story of about 30 close people, then with a long Instagram post to about 200 followers, then a concise version back on Snapchat. I had not yet come out to everyone else as of mid-2021. My court told me they normally don't allow second name changes done a year apart and that I'd probably never get a third, but they were understanding and I got it changed back. I was waiting on my name change hearing and telling everyone I could at school and work.
I'm currently 20 years old and getting my undergrad in social work, where I've been doing research on nonbinary individuals and discrimination against them — I said this research actually grounds me from becoming bitter about my own experience, 'because at least it worked out for others.' I've surrounded myself with 'super woke' people since starting college, which made me nervous about going into a new semester as a detrans woman instead of a trans man.
On hormones and physical changes: I went cold turkey off T about 3 months before writing this (later '7ish months off T'). Changes I noticed: my appetite lessened significantly — I was barely eating, which became an issue, though it's slowly returning toward pre-T levels; my period came back at 2 months off T but wasn't regular yet at month 3; my receding hairline seems to be growing back in slowly; my face is slowly going back to its old shape; I have a little facial hair (about 10 chin hairs) that I shave, mostly on my legs; my boobs haven't really changed; my voice hasn't changed at all. I tried talking in a higher register and found it surprisingly easy, though it sounded like I was mocking women — I still have to go through voice training. A voice pitch analyzer puts me at best in an androgynous range, usually male range. I have a very androgynous face even prior to transition, and with short hair I have a '100% passing rate' as male. I'm growing my hair out because I want to give people a visual that I'm actually a woman; I never plan on wearing makeup or dressing super feminine — mostly tank tops and basketball shorts.
On dysphoria: my gender dysphoria faded over the 6 years I transitioned, and by the time I decided to detransition it was gone — that fact played a part in my decision. My body dysphoria disappeared when I had the realization I wanted to detrans. I still struggle with social dysphoria and thinking of myself as female instead of a man, and I sometimes get reverse dysphoria because of my voice, though not very often. She/her pronouns never bothered me too much — I just feel like an imposter when people use them, and I tell myself they're using she/her because it's an accurate descriptor of me. Early in detransition I was still uncomfortable with she/her but told everyone to use them anyway, hoping it would be like exposure therapy.
On blame and medical care: I voted that the fault for my transition was mostly my own, but also to an extent affirming medical professionals, because when I expressed hesitation the doctor said 'just because you MIGHT regret HRT isn't a good enough reason not to try it.' I thought that was BS and now believe if you have hesitation you shouldn't do it, but at the time I believed that reasoning. When I stopped T, my doctor didn't even ask why, saying it happened all the time with her patients for financial reasons. I have a therapist, though she was on leave at one point.
On adversity and social fallout: I've been lucky not to be on the receiving end of much in person, but I've seen invalidating comments from trans people all over the internet — I view those as people projecting their insecurities. I went to a conservative-ish bar with friends (all but one of us LGB) and had a bad experience; I'm not one for conflict and in the moment think 'what if they have a weapon?', which keeps me from standing up for myself, though afterwards I wish I had. I live in a very progressive area. I'm afraid of confrontation and said I will never go into the women's bathroom unless I have someone with me because I'm always read as male and afraid of getting yelled at.
On sexuality and identity: I re-came out as a lesbian. I don't view myself as a man, woman, or nonbinary — 'I just am, and I'm a female with dysphoria,' which I find comforting because it's grounded in reality. I can see myself either living as a detrans woman or as a trans man and it doesn't have that much effect on me either way; I know I'd figure out a way to be happy either way. I never saw myself as a guy even while living as one for 6 years.
On regret: I don't really regret my transition overall, although I do go through points where I really do regret it. At one point I said I now deeply regret it, and that the regret I've felt has been 'completely devastating (especially because of my mental health issues).' Overall, though, I have a peace of mind I never had when transitioning. Detransition made me happier yet caused a lot of distress, largely because my presentation doesn't match how I want to be perceived — I'm still read as male — and I'm hoping therapy and growing my hair out will help.
On advice I give others: don't transition unless you're certain; it's okay to just be gender non-conforming; you can always choose to transition in the future but there's no takebacks, especially your voice; sit with doubts and don't let people on the internet tell you to ignore them; transition changes appearance, not biology. I find comfort in viewing detransition neutrally rather than as a catastrophe. I've told people to keep a list of their reasons for desisting as reassurance and to build resistance to 'egg culture.' I called out friends' double standards about being 'woke except when it comes to detransitioners.'