Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik kwam in 2011 uit, dacht al van jongs af aan dat ik een jongen was en begon in 2014 een paar maanden na mijn 16e verjaardag met testosteron, na twee jaar therapie, waarbij ik drie uur moest reizen om een arts te vinden. Ik zat een paar jaar op hormonen en het kostte me jaren om te accepteren dat ik als tiener voor medische transitie koos, maar nu koester ik geen wrok. Ik ben nu een gedetransitioneerd/gedesisteerd persoon die comfortabel is in een lage-druk non-binaire identiteit, gender begrijpt als sociale constructie, en de meeste mensen lezen me als vrouw. Therapie en gender loslaten hielpen me uit de ergste depressie die ik heb gehad, en ik heb meer spijt van antidepressiva dan van hormonen, omdat ik tot de eerste onder druk werd gezet. Ik steun transrechten en informed consent voor volwassenen, terwijl ik kritisch ben over wat ik zie als transfobie en verkeerde informatie in deze subreddit.
Volledig verhaal
I came out in 2011 and was always male-presenting and thought I was a boy from a young age. I started testosterone a couple of months after my 16th birthday, in 2014. Getting on hormones was difficult for me — I had to go to therapy for a couple of years and could only find a doctor who would give me T three hours away, and I noted that it was decently rare then, though it became more common in the years following. Both my mother and I were given clear informed-consent talks and papers when I started hormones, and I hold no ill feelings toward my prescribing doctor or those around me. I was on hormones for a few years.
The biggest hardship of my transition, I've said, was that once you come out, people and society try to fit you into a box — "Oh, you want to be a boy/girl, then you can't do this or that" — and this happened within the trans community itself with truscum gatekeeping: "you need hormones to be trans, you need surgery to be trans." I described trying to be "trans* enough" as a huge issue that affected me. I experienced pressure from the gatekeepy trans community and from general society, but not from doctors when it came to transitioning.
I went through a period where I thought my life was ruined and pulled myself out of the worst depression I've experienced; I still struggle at times but I am okay. I saw several therapists, and some were significantly worse than others and not suited to help me with what I was going through — I've said personalized therapy with a therapist experienced in gender dysphoria is important. I've said I was forced to grow up quick because of some stuff in my life, and that trauma should be brought up more when someone expresses gender dysphoria, because I've seen a lot of detrans people who later say they transitioned because of trauma. I also noted that some people may be a little dishonest about some things and feelings when trying to get on hormones.
It took years for me to accept myself and the fact that I did choose to medically transition as a teen, but I now hold no resentment and describe that as a very freeing feeling. What helped me was therapy and, though it took a long time, letting go of gender — I now present how I feel comfortable and work every day toward not letting others' perceptions of me cause a negative impact. I've said I used to literally obsess over my voice and gender, and these days I feel decently okay with myself, or at least have come to terms with what I cannot change. Most people clock me as female, even with a buzzcut, and I'm passive about it — I didn't say anything but most people around me just caught on, some haven't, but I don't care because I've mostly let go of any ill feelings toward pronouns and gender as a whole. I'm now comfortable in a low-pressure non-binary identity, understanding gender as a construct.
I regret taking antidepressants more than I do taking hormones, primarily because I was endlessly pressured to take antidepressants, which was not the case for hormones. I've said I've been doing research on this topic for over a decade.
My views on transition for other people are broadly supportive: I believe trans people exist, can be happy, and live their entire lives without regret; I believe adults should have informed-consent access to hormones and surgeries; I think 16 should be the minimum for medical transition other than puberty blockers, with 18 for surgery, and that young kids under 16 should be given plenty of time and therapy. I've argued repeatedly within this community against what I see as transphobia and misinformation, defending trans rights because trans people "deserve to be in control of their body and life." I've criticized detrans people for spreading skewed stats that set back LGBT rights, and I've said detrans experiences are used by the far right to try to rip trans rights to healthcare from people — while also saying I don't want to be silenced in my own experience. I've recommended the "actualdetrans" subreddit as a far more welcoming and helpful place than this one, which I've described as full of transphobes and "cult like," and I've said other members have asked for me to be banned for my differing opinions while the mods have refused. I believe trauma should be discussed more in relation to gender dysphoria, that doctors who treat very young children should be investigated, and that there should be some national age requirement. I also believe sex and gender are different things — gender is a social construct — and that male and female brains don't have major differences.