Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/desisterende vrouw die zich bijna de helft van mijn leven als transjongen identificeerde maar nooit hormonen nam of een operatie onderging, deels omdat mijn moeder het niet toestond en deels omdat mijn twijfels groeiden. Ik besefte dat ik niet zozeer een man wilde zijn, maar serieus genomen wilde worden door een familie die me behandelde als een zwak, dom meisje, en ik onderdrukte ook een vrouwelijke kant om mijn identiteit te bewijzen. Mijn identiteit loskoppelen van mijn gender, afstand nemen van transitie-inhoud online en een lange ziekte waardoor ik meer dan een jaar aan huis gebonden was, veranderden mijn kijk. Ik worstel nog steeds met een identiteitscrisis, rouw omdat ik mijn gekozen mannelijke naam moest opgeven, schaamte over het vertellen aan mijn moeder en therapeut, en woede over een ernstig misvormde borstkas (scoliose, kyfose, kielborst) die ik deels toeschrijf aan het dagelijks binden vanaf mijn 12e. Ik raad anderen nu aan om hormonen of operaties niet te overhaasten, en ik blijf kritisch over hoe gemakkelijk hormonen te krijgen zijn en over de druk in de gemeenschap die gedetransitioneerden de mond snoert.
Volledig verhaal
I first started questioning things publicly in April 2021, when I posted that I wasn't sure transitioning was worth it. For a long time I had been certain I was trans — I spent most of my time fantasizing about living life as a man, convinced that "being female" was what stopped me from doing all the things I wanted to do. I wouldn't do them at all rather than do them as a woman. I remember dating a gay guy who wanted to introduce me to his friends, and I ended up crying and staying home because I thought I didn't pass that day and felt so dysphoric. Another time we went to a lake in summer — it could have been a great vacation — but I wouldn't go in the water because of my breasts and hid in my tent for basically the whole week. That was probably the moment I began asking myself "why am I doing this to myself?" Why do I ruin everything just because I don't want to be seen as a woman by people to whom I'm only a faceless background character? Four years earlier I would have said my happiness depended on being seen as a man; I don't know what happened, but one day it stopped making sense. I was at a pride event, listened to trans speakers, and felt fake because I couldn't relate to anything they said anymore. Suddenly dating gay men felt like deceiving them.
I never actually started hormones. I was never on HRT because my mum didn't allow me, and by the time I was of legal age I already had those doubts, so I never began. I was 21 in April 2021. I did see a gender specialist in Germany — I was surprised that the specialist suggested HRT after seeing me only twice, though I had waited months for the appointment and had seen several other therapists before who weren't specialized and didn't want to help with my gender issues. I was still going to a "trans therapist" as of December 2022; I originally only went because I wanted HRT, but other issues took over and the trans topic got pushed aside. Whenever he brought it up I felt uncomfortable. Eventually he asked whether my chosen male name was still okay, and I think he no longer believed I was trans. I knew that admitting I didn't feel trans anymore meant it was over and I probably wouldn't ever go on HRT — but I didn't even know why that bothered me, because I really didn't think about transitioning anymore.
I saw myself as a man for almost half my life. I had a picture of my future and now it's gone and I don't know what it will look like. I miss how excited I was to finally be "him"; now "he" feels like a completely different person — I have his memories but can't relate to his feelings, which makes me sad and confused. I struggled a lot to find a male name I liked, and it's sad I don't get to use it if I detransition; I don't think I'll ever be okay with my birth name, and I don't want another meaningless name that feels like a lie. I wished I could just go by no name at all. I also told friends I was non-binary at one point, but explaining that to everyone seemed exhausting, so I stopped caring about it.
A lot led up to this. In July 2021 I wrote a post titled "I never wanted to be a man, I wanted to be taken seriously." I was never taken seriously by my family — always treated like a stupid child even as an adult. My dad would ask my boyfriend or other guys for help about everything even though I could have given better answers; he didn't want to listen to me. My mother always treated me as a weak, fragile little girl needing male protection. I envied my older cousin because the family respected him. I still felt I'd be taken more seriously as a man, and I hated that my female body implied I was weak, vulnerable, and incompetent. My mum also constantly pointed out any glimpse of femininity — my period, makeup, women's clothes, my figure — and wouldn't stop even when I told her how uncomfortable it made me; she also believed I couldn't go anywhere alone at night without a man. I forced myself to be overly masculine around her. I came out to her as bisexual too and she didn't get it and changed the topic. When I was young I told her I didn't want to wear a dress to my communion and she wasn't happy; I didn't go at all in the end.
I also dealt with a serious illness that left me housebound for more than a year, during which all I wanted was to recover. That experience made me value the little things and changed my views on many things, including the whole trans topic — it was a kind of realization similar to what others describe. I have a lot of sensory issues and I'm almost certain I'm on the autism spectrum, though I don't know for sure. In my teenage years I was really into anime and BL, and I was in cosplay spaces where lots of girls cosplayed as male anime characters and eventually came out as trans guys — many later desisted. I used to think T would turn me into a cute anime boy when I was 14. I also repressed a "feminine" side while transitioning, pretending not to like girly things so no one would question my identity; I cut my hair short to pass even though I didn't like short hair on me. That contradiction was one reason I started questioning: if it was about being my true self, why was I fitting into another box? I was never really "manly" — I always wanted to be androgynous.
As for physical effects, I never took hormones, but I wore a binder almost every day of my teens starting at age 12. My upper body is severely deformed — I have scoliosis and kyphosis and my chest is deformed (I think pectus carinatum) — and I believe the binding contributed. I hate it. I also gained a lot of weight later, so I couldn't wear my binders anymore even if I wanted to. In February 2022 I was decluttering and had a big pile of old men's clothing and binders on my floor; I decided to say goodbye to most of it because it didn't feel like "me" anymore. I still wear old men's jeans because women's jeans are hard to shop for.
On the process of detransitioning: it's been hard to commit. I still had moments where I felt I'd be happier as a man, but calling myself a man doesn't feel right — like another box I can't fit in. My trans friends said my concerns about transition and about having children weren't justified; one said if I were a gay cis man I couldn't have my own children either, which technically is right but made me sad because I'd be doing it to myself. I was scared of being on hormones for the rest of my life and of looking in the mirror one day and not recognizing myself — I saw my trans friends becoming hairy, bald, with different faces. I hadn't even told my therapist I was considering detransitioning because I stupidly thought I'd ruin my chance of ever getting HRT. Detaching my identity from my gender helped — asking what I'd want to experience if gender weren't a thing. Distancing myself from online spaces also helped: watching transition videos is a catalyst for dysphoria for me, and I'd stay up at night bingeing them and thinking "maybe I'm trans after all," which felt like some kind of OCD. When I stay away, I don't feel that dysphoric — I just exist and don't care about my gender. I also noted that society will always put you in a box, and that I sometimes wish I could just be genderless.
As of January 2022 I felt my mom probably knew I no longer identified as a trans guy — she watched a documentary about trans people that showed a detransitioned woman and said "people just want to escape their trauma by becoming someone else" while looking at me. I felt totally called out, ashamed, and didn't want to hear "I knew it was just a phase." I said I probably didn't want to medically transition anymore and didn't feel like a man, but neither necessarily like a woman. I've also dealt with an ex-girlfriend (bisexual) telling me about sleeping with a guy after me, which made me feel like I didn't count because I don't have a dick, and like I'd never be enough — I wished I were a cis male she could introduce to her homophobic parents. A person who used to be my best friend called me a radical rightist when I said I disagreed with their views. My best friend came out as trans and I saw red flags but wanted to support them. I've said publicly that most trans people I know think detransitioners are just repressing and that some think we shouldn't talk about our experiences, which I find hypocritical. I've advised others not to rush medication or surgery if unsure, and that it's okay not to know who you are right away.