Alle verhalen

2,5 jaar oestrogeen, en de autismediagnose kwam erna

Man · Gedetransitioneerd1,2K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde homoseksuele man die 2,5 jaar als transvrouw leefde op oestrogeen en progesteron, met stemcoaching en laserontharing, en afzag van geplande bottom surgery voordat ik detransitioneerde. Nu identificeer ik me gewoon als zachte homoseksuele man, en behoud ik mijn lange haar, gelakte nagels en liefde voor slechte romans als mannelijke expressie. Na mijn detransitie werd bij mij ADHD en autisme vastgesteld, wat me hielp mijn losse gevoel van zelf te begrijpen en wat mijn dysforie aanjoeg. Ik had topchirurgie gefinancierd en overlegd, maar besloot er uiteindelijk van af te zien en ben gaan accepteren dat mijn A-cup-borsten bij mijn lichaam horen. Nu zie ik genderidentiteit als ‘verzonnen fluff’ en ben ik kritisch over transitie, vooral voor minderjarigen; ik vergelijk het verlaten van de transcultuur met het verlaten van de kerk.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and lived openly as a gay man for nearly 20 years before I transitioned. Growing up in the 1980s and 1990s in Southern California, I was a gender non-conforming gay male — soft, feminine in my expression — and I went through conversion therapy in high school because of being gay, which I describe as awful and something that just made me feel terrible about myself and, unsurprisingly, never worked. I was also raised in a church, which I left about 20 years ago (around the time I realized I was gay) and I've been atheist ever since. I transitioned socially and medically as a trans woman for 2.5 years. I was on estrogen and progesterone, had voice feminization coaching, was getting laser hair removal, and had planned for SRS (bottom surgery) until I detransitioned. I passed well enough for a 37-year-old, helped by my voice work — I have a naturally very deep voice (I sing bass comfortably in choir) but with coaching I achieved a passing feminine voice and could sing alto and some soprano. I had sexual play with bi/straight men and got in with women's social groups, but I never felt like a woman — just 'a man that was getting really good at passing from a distance.' Dates dried up after one night; female socialization never fully connected, 'like there was always something lost in translation.' I backed out of bottom surgery shortly after realizing the realities of it not being a real vagina. I also came to see how unintentionally misogynistic and misandrist transition can be — I fell into the trap of thinking liking femme things made me a trans woman. Eventually I was just tired: tired of voice work, makeup, never finding clothes and shoes that fit my frame, painfully aware of my inability to blend fully with men or women, tired of looking like a drag queen. When I started doubting my transition I sought out a gender exploratory therapist rather than an affirmative one. It was helpful — she took my dysphoria seriously but explored what caused it (my trauma and being a gender non-conforming gay male growing up) rather than assuming transition. I still identified as trans when I finished GET; the counselor even affirmed my dysphoria at the end, and I didn't detransition until months after my last session. I distinguish GET from the conversion therapy I went through for being gay in high school. I detransitioned medically and socially. Around 8 months after detransitioning (October 2023) I said I finally felt myself as a soft gay man; by December 2023 I'd been back to male about 9 months. The early days involved real anger and grief, and I had to work on self-forgiveness and acceptance of what I'd done to my body with my counselor. I lost friends when I transitioned and lost some again when I detransitioned, and I spent time in a fog even among friends; it took at least half a year to get to any feeling of normalcy. Friends would awkwardly still call me 'she' then correct to 'he,' which made me feel ridiculous. Getting my ADHD and autism diagnoses after detransition helped me understand my lack of self-identity and gave me better expectations of the world. My personal theory of my dysphoria: my undiagnosed ADHD and autism drove it. I've had intense hyperfixations my whole life, and autism gave me a loose sense of self that was easy to mould. I loved labels and systems with clarity, and 2015 Tumblr ideology had plenty of both. I was a black-or-white thinker, so it was easy to trick myself into thinking that because I liked makeup, painted nails, and long hair, that had to equal woman. I also think I got dopamine from watching how well I progressed and how well I 'womaned' — once it became routine and I was gendered as a woman most often, I subconsciously hit a point of 'welp, I did the thing!' and the dopamine stopped; I just saw myself as a man again. It felt stupid having such a quick fall off for something that once seemed so central. After detransition I kept my long hair, my painted nails, my love of trashy romance (Twilight is 'my trash'), and my soft, nurturing personality — but as a man. I reframed things away from masc/femme toward soft/hard energy: I'm a soft guy and none of that needs to mean gender. I went back to the gay community and found many effeminate men feeling the need to be non-binary, which felt performative to me — I'd rather stretch the box I'm in than invent a new one. Medically: I never had breasts before transition and now I do — an A cup. They shrank a little after a year off HRT plus exercise, but the glandular tissue stays and I look like a fit guy with pretty obvious gynecomastia. Sensitivity was higher on E; now I don't care to explore them myself. Guys have played with them since stopping HRT but it doesn't feel as sensual. I had top surgery funded and consulted but not scheduled, then had a change of heart after the consultation — the surgeon seemed cavalier about how many trans guys she'd helped and I had to hide my disgust; I also didn't want more scars (I already have a large scar on my lower abdomen). It took me about a year off T to come to terms with my breasts and see them as part of my body. Now I go shirtless at the public pool, stopped wearing a binder because I'm too active, and I like my breasts as part of my body. I find it insulting when trans men make a big deal of losing breasts to be a man when men with naturally occurring gynecomastia already exist. I now think gender identity is 'made up fluff' — 'gender identity is to transgender theory as a soul is to Catholics.' I've compared leaving trans culture to leaving the church 20 years ago, including the deprogramming afterward. I've said I feel like I joined a cult and had to leave it when I saw the movement for what it was, and it left its mark on my body. I'm critical of transition for others, especially minors, and I posted asking whether transitioning kids has ever resulted in a drop in teen suicide. I'm wary of trans women entering women's spaces based on male socialization, and of gender identity overriding sex in sex-based spaces. I don't use the word 'cis.' I'm autistic so I'm not always good at reading social intentions, and I use 'dude/bro' indiscriminately. When people in the gay community use she/her/sister slang with me after detransition, it triggers an intense panic that they still see me as a trans woman.