Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich van 14 tot 19 als trans man (FTM) identificeerde maar nooit met hormonen begon of medische ingrepen had. Mijn transitie-identificatie werd gedreven door online Tumblr-vrienden die allemaal trans waren en me richting FTM duwden, geïnternaliseerde misogynie, haat tegen de genderrollen die me werden opgelegd, pesten door jongens en de wens een knappe, krachtige man te zijn, en niet de wens echt man te zijn. Ik kwam tot het besef dat ik gewoon een masculiene, butch lesbienne was die het haatte een meisje te zijn en niet echt trans was. Nu pleit ik tegen de censuur van detransitieverhalen en vind ik troost in de detrans-gemeenschap, al presenteer ik me nog masculien en vind ik het moeilijk mijn ervaring met mijn transvrienden op de kunstacademie te bespreken.
Volledig verhaal
I first identified as trans — specifically as a trans man, FTM — at age 14, and I kept that identity for five years before realizing it wasn't right for me. I never actually started hormones or any medical transition; I chose not to begin HRT, partly because of the risks, chances, and expenses involved, and partly because I came to understand what was really driving me.
My path toward identifying as trans started in my freshman year of high school, when I was friendless. I found community on Tumblr through fandoms and later through an art community. My friends there all began identifying as trans, and anti-cis jokes became the norm for them to make. At the same time, I had a deep hatred of being a girl because of the gender roles being forced on me, and I felt pressure to fit in with my online friends. I started clinging to the label of being a trans man because it gave me community and made me feel safer — somebody was accepting me. But I later realized I wasn't being accepted for just being a girl who was really butch and masculine; I was being pressured to start transitioning ASAP by my friend group. My only online friends growing up on Tumblr were all trans, and none of them allowed me to accept just being a masculine female and lesbian. They constantly pushed me into identifying as FTM. I've said that had I never met them, had I never heard about the concept of being trans, I never would have cared.
A big part of it was internalized misogyny — I saw women as inferior and weaker, and it angered me to be one. I realized that if I really was trans, I would happily take the body of any man, no matter how he looked. Instead, I was persistent on thinking being trans would make me the hot dude I wished I could be, with the power and respect that came with it. I never wanted to be or look like the very greasy boys who bullied me growing up. I didn't want to be male; I hated the way I looked, I hated being a teenage girl — I wanted to be handsome and have the power I never had. I was riddled with anxieties about my self-image, especially when so much media tells me I can't be masculine as a woman. I've also described being jealous of good-looking trans guys, and I asked myself whether I would still want to be a guy if I wasn't attractive — and realized it was a hard no. It was only recently that I started to accept I'm not a trans guy; I just love the thought of being a good-looking guy.
A turning point came in my final year of high school when someone told me: "I realized I wasn't trans because I realized I really just hated the concept of being a girl, and hated being me. So I tried becoming someone else." That struck me deeply. I realized I was just a cis girl who didn't fit in with "normal girl" things, and that I didn't have to transition — I realized I wouldn't be any happier in a man's body. I've admitted I'd love a beard and a deep voice, but just as much as I'd like a fancy condo: it'd be cool to have, but I can live and be happy without one. I fully "jumped ship" on the trans identity at age 19.
Coming out of this, I've found the experience uniquely lonely. It sucks that even now I have a bunch of trans men friends in real life — I go to an art school — and this is an impossible subject to bring up when I need to vent about it and understand myself through talking, because I know I'm going to step on toes. I've also talked to a lot of trans people who want to censor detrans stories because they "feed conservative propaganda" or are "so rare they shouldn't matter," and I think that's shameful and incredibly guilt-trippy — the idea that you should silence yourself because others might take your story and speak for you instead of you speaking for yourself. I've argued that there's something to learn from everyone's journeys and that our experiences are not any less valid. I've also commented on the irony that the same community that preaches "love and tolerance to all" also hates people who might make them question themselves, and that it's all about listening to minorities until someone's even smaller than you.
I've been comforted by finding this subreddit and others' stories — as someone who identified as FTM for five years only to realize otherwise, I always figured I was in such a specific and isolated situation that I'd never find anyone to openly talk to about it. Seeing other people in similar circumstances makes me feel oddly comforted. I've also related strongly to others' accounts of being pressured into transition by online trans friends, saying it's scary how much I relate. Currently I still present in a masculine way — I described myself as still very male-looking, which is still the norm for me, though I don't really care since small talk is a bitch anyway. I have not described any surgeries, hormones, mental health diagnoses, or suicidal ideation.