Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde man die sociaal transitioneerde in een 'transmaxxx'-poging om alt-meisjes aan te trekken, maar nooit medisch is getransitioneerd, en ik leef nu als man met een verloofde. Het keerpunt was dat mijn vader ziek werd en ik besefte dat ik jaren had verspild aan queer/ideologische bezigheden in plaats van een leven op te bouwen. Rond mijn 27e heb ik mijn leven omgegooid, kreeg ik een IT-carrière, en ik schrijf het aan mijn vader toe dat hij me 'out of the gender stuff' heeft gehaald. Ik heb nu sterk kritische opvattingen over genderideologie, transitiegeneeskunde en bevestigende therapie. Ik heb het gevoel jaren te hebben verloren aan 'gender-BS', maar mijn spijt is te dragen en ik richt me op mijn carrière en het stichten van een gezin.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and grew up in a conservative, traditional family that expected me to present normally and even decently if I wanted to keep living in the house. I joined a goth/emo phase first — what I now call the 'goth/emo to trans pipeline' — and had a very strong, cringe leftist activist phase where I was raised on the belief that males and females were the same. Before trans identity really caught on culturally, my parents pushed back on my alternative presentation and stopped my goth phase, which was probably easier for them back then.
I ended up socially transitioning in what I now describe as a 'transmaxxx' attempt — I wanted an easier way to get with the 'alt girls' in my social circles and internet communities, thinking I could somehow be like the emo-girls I desired and be passive in dating. I had a kind of self-hate as a guy: a combo of feeling that guys are bad or shunned and every girl would think I was gross, plus a wish not to have to be the active part and just be 'rescued' by a woman if I was somehow 'cute'. I was also a quite small, feminine guy, and I had OCD-like 'transmaxxx' ideas, including the thought 'Oh I had estrogen during pregnancy, that must mean I should be a woman'. I delved into a neo-pronouns rabbit hole of abstract theories, postmodernist redefining and 'word magic' that reminded me of obsessive-compulsive rituals I had as a kid channeling stress about real-life problems. I was lucky no one really reinforced those ideas, and I never changed anything permanent physically — no hormones or surgeries that I describe.
What moved me away was my dad getting sick. I realized I had squandered my parents' hard work on complete nonsense and had to grow up fast, way past 20. I replaced my left-leaning, non-competitive ideology with things like Jordan Peterson's 12 Rules for Life — 'Yes you need to compete, but you can do it nicely and not be evil' — because being a 'good' lefty living on welfare while unable to provide for my sick father made no sense. My father was a key support: he 'got me out of the gender stuff'. I was afraid of taking responsibility and of rejection from employers and girls, and my friend group reinforced a hatred of economic success in a real race to the bottom. I stopped staying in contact with lots of previous friends, realizing many weren't good for me.
I reorganized my life around 27, having wasted years in queer movements, an emo phase, poly sleeping around, and neglecting loved ones, a job, and a partner. I got an IT education, started working, and dated a lot, realizing men didn't need to be macho to be 'real men' — just a few hobbies and a solid economy. I also had bad experiences with poly people pressuring others into that lifestyle. I now have a fiancee from a completely different culture that barely understands trans, poly, or queerness — 'it's like a spa for my brain' — and we have tried to have a child (she had a miscarriage). I describe myself as a soft guy who combined softness with some muscle mass, male hobbies and a career, and I've never felt a need to be anything else.
I now identify as a detransitioned/desisted man living as a man. I feel I wasted years on 'made up gender-BS' but try not to complain. I still feel like 'a baby pretending to be an adult, like I was born 5 years ago' — I'm 32 now — and I'm building a career for my future kid. I'm skeptical of therapists (who in many places must affirm or risk 'conversion therapy' labels), critical of transition especially for minors, and I've had a sexual experience with a post-operative trans person that I found sad and off-putting. I don't believe in 'trans' as a medical condition, viewing it instead as AGP/fetish, body dysmorphia, unhappiness with gender roles, or an escapist alter-ego response to trauma.