Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon, als man geboren, die me ongeveer 16 jaar als transvrouw presenteerde en ongeveer acht maanden voordat ik deze berichten schreef met HRT stopte, terwijl ik me in het dagelijks leven nog als vrouw presenteer. Ik ben 40 jaar, getrouwd met een man, heb mijn eigen bedrijf in Duitsland en ik pas door. HRT bezorgde me osteoporose en hartziekte, waardoor ik levenslange medische zorg nodig heb, en ik heb diepe spijt van de transitie en wou dat ik er nooit in was getrapt. Ik geloof nu dat geslacht niet kan veranderen, dat transitie een laatste redmiddel moet zijn en niet een eerste, en ik betoog dit actief op Reddit, terwijl ik volhoud dat ik niemand anders' keuzes probeer te stoppen. Ik heb in mijn eigen geval geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I was born in Croatia and now live in Germany; English is not my first language, and I also speak Croatian, German, Italian and Spanish. I turned 40 in September 2023, and I had been in transition for about 16 years before I stopped. I presented as a woman, I pass, and I am married to a man I describe as a "cis" man; I also run my own business with all employees being "cis."
I went through medical transition, including cross-sex hormones, and I stopped HRT around eight months before writing these posts. I now describe myself as a detrans person — at one point I wrote "I am a detrans man who was presenting himself as a trans woman for 16 years," and elsewhere "I am detrans mfttm," while also saying I am "still living as a 'woman' but quit hrt." I still present as a woman in daily life even though I have stopped hormones.
The medical side has been serious for me. I developed osteoporosis and heart disease because of HRT, and I now need medical care for the rest of my life as a result of being on cross-sex hormones. I have said plainly that a man's body cannot function under estrogen in a safe way. I also raised fertility concerns, telling others that HRT will make you sterile.
What moved me toward detransition was a long accumulation of experience rather than a single event. Over 16 years I met many trans people and saw things that disturbed me: my best friend had SRS seven years ago and cannot use her neo-vagina for sex and hurts every time she goes to the toilet; I saw people with beards and silicone breasts; I saw young girls without breasts and with big scars on their chests; I saw people in 12- or 15-year heterosexual marriages who wanted SRS and were angry their partners had problems with it. I also saw what I considered absurdities like people referring to pets by "them." I came to feel that once makeup, heels, soft skin, long hair and silicone breasts became everyday, it was no longer special and became a burden — a lifelong fight you cannot win.
I also feel that no one told me hormones would change my personality, my sexuality, my mood or my priorities, and I think medical professionals are far too quick to put people on hormones before trying other solutions. I believe transition should be the last option, not the first, and that a person must be very stable and grounded before transitioning — being destructive or suicidal is definitely not a reason to put someone on hormones. I have been critical of the phrase "born in the wrong body" being said to children, and I think children should instead be told they are perfect and should love their bodies.
I have not described formal therapy as having helped me; my change of view came from my own long experience, from观察 of the trans community, and from reflection. I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm in my own case, though I have told others that if someone is suicidal they simply need mental help, not hormones, and I have urged people not to take black-market hormones.
I have been very active in arguing my position on Reddit. I posted a thread titled "No body is borne in wrong body!!!!" criticizing a medical professional for using that phrase, and another post criticizing a trans activist named Blossom. I argue that sex cannot be changed — that a trans woman is a man on estrogen and a trans man is a woman on testosterone — and that neo-vaginas are not vaginas and gynecomastia is not breasts. I accept that people may transition and I do not try to stop anyone, but I want the freedom to express my view without being harassed for it. I have said I do not consider my views transphobic, that having an option does not make me transphobic, and that people have a right to perceive others through their own perspective.
As for my happiness now: I have concluded that transition is not what made me happy. What makes me happy is peace in my soul, my partner, my travels, my career and the people around me. I have come to the conclusion that I was always perfect, that I was not born in the wrong body, and that all the energy, money and time I spent on transition could have gone to other things. I regret the transition — I have written "I wish I never fall down in to the traps" and "get away as fast as you can" — and I feel I lost a great deal to it, though I also say that going back has no point for people already transitioned and that they will need medical care for the rest of their lives. I do not argue that all trans people must detransition, but I believe most of them are not happy.