Alle verhalen

Wilde een jongen zijn, nam nooit de hormonen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd231
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw in mijn 40er jaren die nooit medisch is getransitioneerd maar als kind wilde een jongen zijn, geworteld in familiale vrouwenhaat, de verlating door mijn vader en besef van de onderdrukking van vrouwen. Ik ben geregistreerd verpleegkundige en spreek me uit over de medische risico's van hormonen en ben kritisch over transitie als oplossing voor gendernonconformiteit of vrouwenonderdrukking. Ik steun actief anderen die desisteren, adviseer hen te praten met twijfelende broers of zussen en waarschuw tegen vijandigheid jegens mensen die inzien dat transitie een vergissing was. Ik heb ernstige maandelijkse menstruatieklachten waar ik mijn werk omheen plan, en ik had op jongere leeftijd een ongewenste zwangerschap. Ik heb geen spijt van medische ingrepen omdat ik die nooit heb gehad, en ik identificeer me momenteel als vrouw die zich prettig voelt gendernonconformistisch te zijn zonder te transitioneren.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female. I don't have a transition story of my own — I never changed my identity or my body — but I have spent a lot of time in this community because the questions people raise here are ones I've lived through in a different way. As a kid I was a tomboy. I went through a phase where I desperately wanted to be a boy — I wore boys' clothes and wished I were male. I've pinned that to two things: my parents' divorce and my dad abandoning us while my mom struggled to feed us, and the fact that my parents and extended family were, in my words, "very toxic towards women," with some Phyllis Schlafly influence there. I was about 8 years old. I was also acutely aware of the social inequities between men and women — my dad was living a comfortable, carefree life while my mom was scraping by — and wanting to be a boy seemed easier, like I'd be more free. It was more about not wanting to be a girl than wanting to be a boy. When we moved across the country with my mom after the divorce, I stopped hating being a girl and let myself do "girly" things in addition to the "boy" things I already loved. I grew out of it once I realized a woman doesn't have to be married, have kids, or depend on a man. I'm still not very feminine — I rarely wear makeup and don't have "feminine" hobbies — but I have a very feminine body and I've come to accept it. In my 40s I care much more about being healthy than anything else. I've told younger GNC women that when I was their age (the late 90s) gender nonconformity was common and none of the GNC girls I knew said they wanted to be men; they just didn't want traditional gender roles, and they seemed happier for it. I had phases of more masculine and more feminine presentation but never felt I had to change my identity. My best friends were a masculine girl and a feminine boy, both straight. Professionally I'm a registered nurse — I've been an RN for longer than a lot of redditors have been alive — and I lean on that when I argue about medical risk. I've said plainly that hormones are dangerous, that exogenous estrogen is not less dangerous to a man than endogenous testosterone, and that our bodies are so complex you can't just swap one element and expect the whole system to keep working. I've seen a 24-year-old woman die from fertility treatment complications — a clot running the length of her jugular vein from behind her ear to her chest — and I've argued that just because one option is worse than another doesn't make the second one safe. "Just because poison A is worse than poison B does not negate that B is still poison." On my own health: I get a menstrual cycle that hits me like the flu every month — body aches, crippling cramps, fatigue so severe it takes all my energy just to eat and use the bathroom for about two days. I schedule work around it so I don't have to call in sick. I also had an unwanted pregnancy when I was younger that would have been a disaster. I've been active here mostly in an advisory and supportive role. I've told people considering transition that it's a serious life decision being made rashly at an emotionally vulnerable time, and that they don't need surgery or hormones to be who they are. I've advised someone whose siblings were questioning to talk to them before they make permanent changes — to not go on the offensive, to offer a nonjudgmental place to talk, and to help them reach their own conclusions rather than being an echo chamber. I've pushed back hard on hostility toward people who are desisting, arguing that name-calling and hostility will just make others defensive and discourage them from doing the same. I've also told people who regret transition that they can grieve their losses but should remember there's tomorrow, and that there are a million ways to make a life happier. I've offered practical advice too — everything from how to wax a lip to reassurance that plenty of women have children without breastfeeding or without a partner. I don't regret anything medical because I never transitioned. What I carry is the ordinary wear of a middle-aged body and the memory of what it felt like to wish I were someone I wasn't.