Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een cisvrouw die zich nooit als trans identificeerde, nooit medisch getransitioneerd is en me altijd als cis heeft geïdentificeerd. Ik sloot me bij r/detrans aan om detransitieverhalen te horen zonder de gebruikelijke eenzijdige framing, en ik herken me in vrouwen die uit hun lichaam wilden stappen vanwege angst voor seksuele aandacht die rond de puberteit op mijn 12e begon. Ik ben een linkse Democraat die privé bepaalde wetsvoorstellen steunt waarvan ik vrees dat ik er een TERF door genoemd zou worden, en ik heb kritische opvattingen over hoe mannen vrouwen seksualiseren en respectloos behandelen. Ik heb geen genoemde spijt over transitie omdat ik nooit getransitioneerd ben, en in dit transcript worden geen psychische aandoeningen, operaties of detransitieproces beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I have always identified as cis — I never identified as trans and I never went on testosterone. I'm a ciswoman, a Democrat voter who votes straight D down the ballot, and I'd describe myself as fairly leftist, though I'm unsure how liberal my views are. I ended up in the r/detrans community because I rarely get to see the topic of detransitioning without one side of the argument being strongly anti-trans or the other side acting like it's too rare to care about; I'm mostly there to listen and I usually give zero input.
My body and gendered self-perception have a specific history. My family used to make comments about my big butt ever since I was a child, and no matter how angry I got they would just say "oh stop! Men love big butts!" I didn't care what men like, especially at 10 years old, and all those comments did was make me want to cover my butt as much as possible — I always felt like people were just staring at it. Honestly it isn't even that big; it probably looked big for my size because I was skinny. It took me years to get over it. I dressed like a boy as soon as I hit puberty, at only 12, because I hated how womanly my figure became and I was scared of the sexual attention. My girlyness didn't come back until I was about 18 or 19. I don't have gender dysphoria, so I don't know what the coping mechanisms for it are, but I find it interesting to see all these detrans stories from women who just wanted to step out of their body for similar reasons that I did.
I also have my own insecurities around body hair: I don't have PCOS and never went on T, and my body hair is thicker than what people might expect. I don't like my body hair either, but the older I got the more I accepted it, and I've come to see being hairless as an unfair trait pushed on women — a lot of us are hairy and it's just a stereotype to peg us as smooth and hairless.
On transition and detransition, I've said that I'd assume gender dysphoria is like any other disorder, in that you can't just remove it. Since society at large thinks transitioning is the only coping mechanism, but a lot of trans people never transition, there's gotta be a lot more to it — I've suggested asking trans circles why some of them chose not to transition, since they might lead you down a path in your mindset on being more comfortable with your body.
Politically, I feel this is one of the only places I can say I support certain bills (referring to state bills that Democrats brand as "hate") because I know for a fact I'll be labeled a TERF if I say it anywhere else. I suspect a lot of Dem voters secretly agree but bite their tongue because they know liberals are going to attack them. I think hardcore liberals are more of the issue than extreme leftists — extreme leftists would be anarchists, whereas hardcore liberals would be the type to say "don't say the word uterus, that's transphobic." Leftists don't like liberals and compare them to centrists, at least from what I've seen in political groups on Facebook.
On misogyny, I've argued that as a ciswoman I'm confident in the gender I present and no, people don't treat me better because I'm confident — several studies show women are literally respected less. I cited a viral post about a man who started emailing clients under a female name and found the way people treated him was night and day, to the point his job became hard to do because of how nasty clients got, even though he talked exactly the same. More broadly I've said men literally don't respect women — I've pointed out how often men, after having a daughter, say "now I understand that women are just people," and how often people have to remind men who hurt women that "she's someone's daughter, mother, sister," whereas I've never heard a woman have a son and say "wow now I understand that men are just people." I've argued that it's men viewing women sexually that causes a lot of the disrespect, seeing women as sexual objects rather than whole people. I also relate this to the male gaze in body insecurities: insecurities aren't just about stuff you hate about yourself, they're also about stuff that draws unwanted attention, and I hate when the latter get dismissed with "but guys love big boobs!"