Alle verhalen

Nooit getransitioneerd — maar wel zijn plek in de detrans-gemeenschap gebouwd

Man · Gedesisteerd696
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde... nee — ik ben een mannelijk lid van de detransitiegemeenschap dat nooit is getransitioneerd of dysforie heeft gehad, en ik post adviezen en onderzoekskritieken om anderen te steunen. Ik ben als man geboren, ben 1,65 m, Latino met inheemse Zuid-Amerikaanse voorouders, en kreeg te maken met licht pesten, sociale uitsluiting en weinig romantisch succes doordat ik een verlegen, gevoelig, niet-masculien type was. Ik ontwikkelde een paniekstoornis op de universiteit, die reageerde op SSRI's, en vond gemeenschap en zelfvertrouwen via CrossFit en gewichtheffen, waarbij ik in 3,5 jaar 20-30 pond (ongeveer 9-14 kg) spier kreeg. Ik ben sterk kritisch over medische transitie voor jongeren, vooral puberteitsremmers, en pleit actief voor voorzichtigheid, therapie en desistance-vriendelijke bronnen. Ik identificeer me nu als man die vrede heeft met zijn geslacht, al heb ik soms gewenst als vrouw geboren te zijn.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and have never transitioned; I'm a detransition community member who posts mostly to advise others. I'm 5'5" with small hands, thin wrists, a high and reedy voice, patchy facial hair I can't grow out, and a receding hairline; I'm Latino with significant native South American ancestry. I was the shy, sensitive, nerdy type and struggled to fit in as a teen, dealing with mild bullying and social exclusion through middle and high school. I've never had dysphoria or considered transition myself, though I've envied women at times for being able to be openly sensitive, selective in relationships, bear children, and show vulnerability, and I've more than once thought my life might have been better if I'd been born female. I've made peace with that because wishing for what can't be won't solve anything. I've had little romantic luck and still want kids but have no partner yet. I'm not very comfortable around highly masculine men and struggle to relate to them. I developed panic disorder in college, which was awful - I never knew when an attack would come, feeling like I couldn't breathe and wondering if I was dying. I eventually got diagnosed and went on SSRIs, and the attacks stopped. I've been on this subreddit for years, reading and commenting regularly. I found community through CrossFit in my neighborhood - people I see around town who recognize me and say hello, and whom I've hung out with outside the gym. I started lifting and doing CrossFit a few years ago and put on probably 20-30 pounds of muscle over 3.5 years; I look completely different and much more masculine than before, and I felt like more of a man. I graduated high school 17 years before 2019, and there are exactly six people I went to high school with that I've seen regularly since; they're my oldest and closest friends. I missed social media growing up - MySpace had just come along but the closest equivalent I used was AIM. I grew up rural. I'm acquainted with a surprising number of trans people. I've never missed an MtF that I know of, but I knew an FtM for about a year and had no idea he was trans until he mentioned a correction for his top surgery. I also know another FtM with a full beard who's proportioned wrong - extremely narrow, delicate shoulders on a small frame but still hip width, clearly pear-shaped. I'm a heavy reader of research and news on this topic: Lisa Littman's ROGD study, Blanchard's typology, Biggs 2019 on the GIDS experiment, the Jazz Jennings interview, the Washington Post piece on transmen's experiences, the Times UK article on puberty blockers, NIH and FDA regulations on research with children, and the Kelsey Coalition's Lupron materials. I've advocated strongly against puberty blockers for children, calling their use unethical and likening it to a science experiment on children, and I've argued that clinicians prescribing them are a short step from being monsters. I've advised parents to limit their children's internet access, to be cautious about schools socially transitioning kids without parental permission, and to seek out non-affirming therapists like Sasha Ayad or support groups like Parents of ROGD Kids. I've recommended the Detrans Advocacy Network founded by Charlie Evans and the 'Detrans Replies Only' post flair. I've told young people considering transition to wait, get off the internet, work on trauma and suicidal ideation with a real therapist, and that they can always start hormones later if they still want them. I've argued that gender identity is 'made up' and that there's no credible evidence of a biological basis for transgenderism. I've pushed back on concepts like male privilege and internalized misandry, and I've discussed desistance rates of 60-90% for childhood gender dysphoria.