Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een als vrouw geboren persoon die zich als gedetransitioneerd identificeert, nooit medisch is getransitioneerd, maar mijn uiterlijk bewust heeft gemasculiniseerd — kaalgeschoren hoofd, spieren, ruime kleding, lage contra-altstem — als een omkeerbare „pseudo-transitie”, en ik leef nu het prettigst als vrouw. Ik schrijf mijn ongemak met vrouwelijkheid toe aan geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat in een seksistische samenleving en niet aan trans zijn, en ik heb afstand genomen van familie en vrienden die hun wil aan mij oplegden. Ik sta kritisch tegenover transitie voor anderen, vooral voor jongeren, en heb anderen geadviseerd te stoppen met porno, uiterlijk los te koppelen van identiteit en therapie te zoeken. Ik heb geen chirurgische of hormonale voorgeschiedenis, beschrijf geen spijt over medische ingrepen en geen mentale diagnoses of suïcidale gedachten.
Volledig verhaal
I am a natal woman — I was born female — and I have never taken hormones or had any surgical changes to my body. Even so, for a long time I did everything within my own power to look male: I shaved my head, gained a lot of muscle mass, wore loose clothes, and leaned into a masculine presentation. I eventually realized this amounted to a reversible, non-traditional transition. My voice is naturally low — I'm a contralto — and people sometimes don't register me as female when I first speak, which I no longer blame them for and which I even find a little fun.
Over time I noticed I felt a slight relief when I was initially misgendered, because in my mind it signalled the other person saw me as deserving of the same respect a man receives — that they weren't yet thinking about raping or harming me. I said I would run with that as long as it served my safety or my interests. Despite all of that, I am most comfortable moving through life as a woman when I can. I feel kinship with other women, I've never wanted to use the men's room, and I have no desire to do anything irreversible to my body, knowing I can be impulsive in my decision-making.
I have thought a lot about why being female has at times been so uncomfortable for me, and I've come to believe it stems from living in a misogynistic society that treats women as inferior. I've argued that instead of changing ourselves — through surgery and pharmaceuticals — to fit a bigoted standard, we should resist those standards. I've said that finding peace for me meant distancing myself from family and friends who kept imposing their will on me, and asking myself who I am outside of being feminine or masculine: what do I stand for, where do I want to go. Letting those things define me brought great relief and helped me let go of voices telling me I need to look a certain way to be myself or successful. I've described the body as just a vessel for the mind.
I've also dealt with intense scrutiny of my own appearance — obsessing over my brow line and hair — and I've told others, and myself, that no one is examining those features nearly as closely as I am, and that decoupling appearance from sense of self is the path to peace. I have short hair now and wear Carhartt and Dickies regularly, and I say that's what makes me feel womanliest. I live in California. I've recommended therapy — including art and music therapy — as a way to work through pain, noting you may have to try a few therapists to find the right fit, and I've emphasized that the person is not the problem; the world they were born into is.
On transition generally, I've been openly critical. I've attributed rising transition rates to identity politics and constant internet connectivity, argued that wanting to be male is not a good rationale for transitioning and signals deep-rooted internalized misogyny, and pushed back on puberty blockers and HRT for 18-year-olds by comparing it to society becoming more cautious about what we let 18-year-olds do with student loans and military service. I've told a young person watching porn that their feelings were being triggered by porn and dopamine overload and that stopping would let them recalibrate and decide clearly whether they're trans. I've also said that unless someone transitioned in youth, HRT does nothing to bone structure, and that an adult's bones are their bones. I offered to contribute illustrations if another community member wanted to make a book out of their story, suggested organizing local meetups, recommended time in nature and vacations to reset, and endorsed psychedelics ('Shrooms ftw'). I have not described any formal advocacy or activism beyond participating in this community.