Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde vrouw (nooit medisch getransitioneerd) die als tiener sociaal transitioneerde voordat ik besefte dat het niet bij me paste. Ik maakte seksueel misbruik mee in een kring buiten mijn directe gezin, disfunctie en verwaarlozing, een eetstoornis en lichaamsdysmorfie, waaronder dat ik van mijn kindertijd tot mijn 19e een labiaplastiek wilde. Ik heb nu sterk kritische opvattingen over gender-affirmerende zorg, medische transitie en trans-activisme, en ik doe actief mee in deze detransitie-gemeenschap. Ik heb af en toe nog gedachten als 'ik wou dat ik een man was' en voel me ongemakkelijk bij het woord 'vrouw', en ik werk aan acceptatie van mijn lichaam. Ik heb nooit hormonen gebruikt of een operatie gehad.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female. I never went on testosterone or had any surgeries — I only socially transitioned for a time before I realized it wasn't right for me, so I describe myself as having desisted rather than detransitioned, since I tapped out before medical changes could affect me. I was a tomboy as a kid with strong feelings against traditional femininity; from around the same age as a poster I was replying to until I was about 19 I wanted a labiaplasty, hated my vulva, wanted a flat chest, and vehemently denied girly-girl femininity, and I also had disordered eating that I'm still working on. I now see that pattern in myself as body dysmorphia, low self-esteem, and disinterest in stereotypically feminine things rather than evidence of being trans.
I don't remember much talk about LGBT stuff until I was a teen, when my mom thought I was a lesbian (though she didn't know about the gender stuff) and got me an informational LGBT book I never read. She told me she loved and supported me but didn't know how to help with things involving this, which I'm grateful for. My family all loved each other, but there was unintentional neglect and dysfunction; I encountered different forms of sexual abuse, though not from anyone in my immediate family, and things that happened in my early teens caused tension between my mom and me. I'd call my childhood decently good overall, but there are some blank and empty spaces where my brain has blocked things out. I only had social enablers for my transition — online friendships — and I consider myself lucky that there was no physical enabler around to medicalize me during that period.
A friend once told me my discomfort was 'internalized transphobia' and just another barrier to break through to achieve my 'true self.' I now think that framing exists to push people through transitions they don't actually want, because when everyone on the outside is cheering you on it's hard to have an honest moment with yourself. I still occasionally have 'I wish I were a man' thoughts and struggle with societal expectations attached to femininity. I have a strong aversion to being called a 'woman' — it feels too mature and adult, like I'm being put on a higher social and developmental peg than I am, and it triggers a small panic of 'I'm not ready for that yet' — though 'adult' doesn't bother me. The word 'girl' gives me a different, smaller discomfort that I think is just residue from what I've desisted. I'm fine with most other female terms.
I've never been on T; someone told me my voice sounds like a more elegant version of their own, and I took that as a compliment. I've dealt with uncomfortable encounters where people who seem focused on transition can only pick out the trans angle — one worker once approached me in a way that assumed I was still on that path, which felt invasive, and I hope they realized the wrong they did. I've also been told by someone that I was 'just an egg back then' when I described being a tomboy, which infuriated me — tomboys aren't eggs, they just aren't traditionally feminine, and it felt like a recruitment campaign.
I'm critical of gender-affirming care and therapists, which have always intimidated me: they're all smiles and support until you start questioning the changes being thrown at you, then suddenly you're a TERF or transphobe, and it feels less like care and more like a brainwashing station. I believe the affirmation business makes you a lifelong patient for profit. I don't believe 'truly trans' exists, and I think pushing hormones and irreversible surgeries on people — especially gender-nonconforming girls — is sexist: they claim to smash the binary while enforcing gender roles more harshly than ever. I was one of those tomboys, and if a physical enabler had been around I'm certain I would have been medicalized. I'm skeptical of trans activism's claims about lost rights and openly question the political framing of the debate, noting that plenty of centrist and left-leaning people in this sub push back because they've been burned by it. I also criticize fujoshi culture as straight women fetishizing gay men, and I'm frustrated by how aggressively trans content is pushed on platforms like Pinterest. I've had Reddit notifications off for over five years and mostly keep to myself, which has made the app far more bearable. I believe strongly in body positivity over cosmetic surgery — I thought losing weight would make me love myself, but the depression and self-esteem issues remained, and I warn about the danger of surgery addiction paired with untreated body dysmorphia. I'm active in this community, offering camaraderie to others with similar experiences and pushing back against people who encourage staying on hormones.